AdventAI

SUNDAY IN THE “SUNDAY NEWS.”

By A. Smith

From Review and Herald, Vol. 64, No. 30., July 26, 1887

BY A. SMITH.

The Detroit Sunday News of June 19 contains an editorial on the Sunday lesson of the day, in which the following points of interest on the question of the Sabbath are made:—

Under the Christian dispensation we have the authority of the Saviour himself for the declaration that man is not to be a slave to the Sabbath, but that the Sabbath is made for his benefit. Paul, in Col. 2 : 16, seems to teach that the Sabbath is abrogated under the new dispensation. He says: “Let no man therefore judge you in meat, or in drink, or in respect of a holy day, or of the new moon, or of the sabbath days: which are a shadow of things to come.”

On this point the editor takes a position contrary to that of some eminent writers who observed the first day of the week as the Sabbath. Dr. Adam Clarke has the following on the above text:—

The apostle speaks here in reference to some particulars of the handwriting of ordinances, which had been taken away; viz., the distinction of meats and drinks, what was clean and what unclean according to the law; and the necessity of observing certain holidays or festivals, such as the new moons, and particular sabbaths, or those which should be observed with more than ordinary solemnity. All these had been taken out of the way and nailed to the cross, and were no longer of moral obligation. There is no intimation here that the Sabbath was done away, or that its moral use was superseded, by the introduction of Christianity.

The following on this text is from the “New Testament with Notes,” by the American Tract Society:—

The days referred to are those required to be observed in the ceremonial law—days associated by God with meats, drinks, and new moons. The passage does not refer to the Sabbath of the moral law.

But the News draws the following conclusion from this text:—

The Jewish Sabbath, therefore, was neither enjoined by the apostles nor observed by the early church.

The apostles did virtually enjoin the observance of the Sabbath by teaching the perpetuity of the law of which the fourth commandment is an integral part. See James 2 : 10, 11; Rom. 7 : 7, 12; 3 : 31. The Sun calls the seventh-day Sabbath, “Jewish,” but it is not so called in the Bible. God calls the Sabbath his. See Ex. 20 : 10; 31 : 13; Isa. 58 : 13. The early Christians did keep the Sabbath. The day following the crucifixion day was the first Sabbath of the Christian dispensation, the new covenant having been ratified at the cross (see Matt. 26 : 27, 28; Heb. 9 : 15–17); and this day is called the Sabbath day in the New Testament, and holy Christian women are said to have observed it according to the commandment. See Luke 23 : 55, 56. For further examples of Sabbath-keeping, see Acts 13 : 14, 42, 44; 16 : 13; 18 : 4, 11 (seventy-eight Sabbaths). If the seventh day was not then, as it always had been, the Sabbath of the Lord, why is it called “the Sabbath day?” and if the Sabbath had been changed to the first day of the week, why is not that day called the Sabbath, and the original seventh-day Sabbath termed Jewish, as certain feasts were (John 7 : 2), and as modern D. D.’s term it? Lyman Coleman, a candid first-day writer, thus testifies:—

During the early ages of the church, it [Sunday] was never entitled “the Sabbath,” this word being confined to the seventh day of the week, the Jewish Sabbath, which, as we have already said, continued to be observed for several centuries by the converts to Christianity.—Ancient Christianity Exemplified, chap. 26, sec. 2.

Concerning the keeping of the first-day Sabbath, the News has the following:—

The Lord’s day, the first day of the week, which took its place, could not be observed, like the Sabbath, by abstinence from all occupations, as it would at once have given away the religion of the subject and, under the Pagan tyranny of the first three centuries, have insured his speedy persecution and death.

We had no idea that those early Christians were so pusillanimous. If the News is right about them, they could not have been worthy of their illustrious ancestors. See Dan. 3 : 16–18; 6 : 10–17; Heb. 11 : 32–38. We are inclined to the belief that the News is mistaken, it having judged from the stand-point of modern milk-and-water Christianity. We hope that the News mentally excepts Stephen (Acts 7 : 51–60), Paul (Acts 11 : 23–28), and other martyrs (Rev. 6 : 9) from its list of “little faith” Christians.

Concerning the keeping of Sunday from and after the decree of Constantine, the News makes some excellent assertions and admissions, as follows:—

When Constantine the Great made Christianity the religion of the empire, he decreed, as a matter of honor to the Christian festal day, that the courts should suspend their business on that day, and certain grosser forms of amusement be prohibited. From that time the observance of the Lord’s day became more or less intimately associated in the Christian mind with the obligations of the Jewish Sabbath.

The Scotch Presbyterians and the English Puritans at the Reformation, taking their theology and code of morals largely from the Old Testament, revived the term Sabbath, and applied it to the Lord’s day—the only instances in Christian history where Sunday has ever been called the “Sabbath.” With the name they revived also the strictest Jewish standard of observation of the day. Instead of a day of joy and feasting, they made it a day of severe repression, and the puritanical idea has very largely permeated the whole English-speaking branch of the Protestant faith of the present day. Few of us who have been brought up in pious families fail to remember with what dread the coming of Sunday was looked upon. While we were free all the rest of the week, on Sunday we entered upon a galling bondage. All amusements must be sacrificed, all entertaining books laid aside, all laughter and merriment studiously repressed. How glad we were . . . when the dawn of Monday set us free from the unnatural restraint! And still this restraint may be a good moral discipline for us, just as fasting and afflictions are; so the puritan idea may be, and probably is, promotive of piety, though not enjoined by Holy Writ or known to the primitive church.

Even John Calvin does not seem to have held the Sabbatical views of Sunday that his Scotch followers adopted, for only eighty years after his death, Evelyn tells us, in connection with his visit to Geneva, that “a little out of the town is a spacious field, which they call Campus Martius; for here on every Sunday, after the evening devotions, this precise people permit their youths to exercise arms and shoot in guns, and in the long and cross bows in which they are exceedingly expert.”

With all this difference of construction, therefore, even among the Christians, as to the precise obligations of the Lord’s day (Sabbath is a misnomer, there is no such thing as a “Christian Sabbath,” and the term “Sabbath-school” ought never to be used), the functions of the secular government in regard to it may well be considered an open and debatable question. On its face it would seem that, so long as no annoyance was occasioned to any considerable part of the community, under the correct principles of government the law should be very chary of interference with individual freedom of action.

On the point of political interference with the Sabbath question, the News takes a tenable position, and we hope that it is in receipt of the American Sentinel as an exchange, a paper devoted exclusively to this question, and that it will be in the near severe religio-political contest, what it has foreshadowed in the above brief statement, an able advocate of political and religious freedom.