AN OPEN LETTER

6%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · May 31, 1887

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 64, No. 22.

Read the full edition

AN OPEN LETTER.

BY C. P. WHITFORD.
MY DEAR FATHER: The World's Crisis of March 9 which you so kindly sent, is before me, and the article from the pen of Eld. J. Litch, to which you invite my special attention, has been carefully examined.
Eld. Litch gives eight reasons why he does not keep the seventh day Sabbath; but in them all I find not one word from God, or Christ, or the inspired men of old, teaching the abrogation of the Father's law, or that the day on which he “rested” (Gen. 2: 1–3), and which he “blessed” (Gen. 2: 3) and “sanctified” (Ex. 20: 11), has been superseded by another day. Indeed, it is a matter of the greatest surprise to me, how Eld. Litch or any other person can so easily satisfy himself that “these ten commandments . . . were never binding on Christians.”
I wonder if you considered the full meaning of this strange statement as you read it in the Crisis. Consider for a moment that the law which Christ “came not to destroy” (Matt. 5: 17), and of which he says, “It is easier for heaven and earth to pass, than one tittle of the law to fall” (Luke 16: 17),—consider for a moment the claim that this law is not, and “never was” binding on Christians; the law which Paul declares to be “holy, and just, and good” (Rom. 7: 12), is not and “never was” binding on Christians. “James, a servant of God and of the Lord Jesus Christ,” in his letters to the twelve tribes which are scattered abroad, declares that “whosoever shall keep the whole law, and yet offend in one point is guilty of all.” James 2: 10. But Eld. Litch would have us understand that this law “never was binding on Christians.” Paul declares that he “had not known sin, but by the law.” Rom. 7: 7.
It is surprisingly strange to me how an old dead law that “never was binding on Christians,” could convince Paul that he was a sinner, especially when I consider another declaration he has made; viz., “For where no law is there is no transgression.” Rom. 4: 15. It is plainly evident to my mind that Paul considered as truth the words of David as recorded in Ps. 111: 7, 8: “All his commandments are sure. They stand fast forever and ever.” “A good understanding have all they that do his commandments.” Verse 10.
Now, we would not for a moment underrate the natural ability of Eld. Litch or others who teach that the “ten commandments never were binding on Christians,” but we do believe that gross darkness covers their minds respecting the two covenants, which leads them to such absurd and contradictory conclusions with regard to the binding claims of God's law. To illustrate this, we will investigate Eld. Litch's own statement. After saying that the ten commandments were the covenant which God made with the Israelites, and that they “were never binding on Christians,” he makes an exception in the following language: “All that Christ made obligatory on his followers under the new covenant . . . he quoted, and re-inforced in the gospel, and that is the substance of all the commandments, except the fourth, and that he never enjoined on them.”
If the great Author of all truth had given us this information, instead of Eld. Litch, it would lead us to pause, and seriously review the evidences of our position concerning the immutability of that law which we are taught in Eccl. 12: 13, 14 is to be the rule of the Judgment. See also James 2: 11, 12 and Rom. 2: 12, 13. But since the Lord has never told us that his commandments “were never binding on Christians,” our faith is not at all shaken in the binding obligations of those precepts of the decalogue “quoted and re-inforced by Christ,” and we still believe as Christ himself has said, that “it is easier for heaven and earth to pass, than for one tittle of the law to fail.” Yet Eld. Litch would have us believe that (1.) these ten commandments “never were binding on Christians,” and (2.) that they were binding on Christians; and all of them, too, except the fourth.
“Oh fourth command, what trouble thou hast been, Source of vexation to the sons of men!”
Does not Eld. Litch know that the first four commandments of the decalogue are not quoted by Christ in the New Testament? Is it possible that he would have us believe that we can have other gods, worship images, take the Creator's name in vain, and profane his Sabbath? Such are the logical conclusions reached by the arguments set forth by him in the article under consideration. Does it appear that such reasoning indicates a “good understanding,” such as David says those have who keep all the commandments?
At the close of Eld. Litch's article you append these words: “Call them back from the old law is my prayer,” by which I am led to believe that you fully indorse his views. I regret that you find it in your heart to thus ask God to “call us back” from the keeping of that holy law, which David declares to be “perfect” (Ps. 19: 7); which Christ did “not come to destroy” (Matt. 5: 17); which is to endure while heaven and earth stand (Matt. 5: 18); which is “the law of liberty” (James 2: 12) in which the apostle delighted (Rom. 7: 22), and which he declares is “holy, and just, and good” (Rom. 7: 12); which contains the whole duty of man (Eccl. 12: 13); which Christ came to magnify and make honorable (Isa. 42: 21); which is to be kept with the faith of Jesus (Rev. 14: 12); which must be kept as a condition of eternal life (Matt. 19: 16–19); and, finally, which is the law by which you and I and all the world will be judged at last. James 2: 12.
What reasonable objection can you have to the law of God? What fault can you find with it just as it stands? Have you wisdom enough to alter it for the better? Says David, “The law of the Lord is perfect, converting the soul.” But Eld. Litch claims that this perfect law was the old covenant, that it was faulty, and, consequently, only a part of it was made obligatory on Christ's followers. In short, that Christ changed it to meet the wants of the people living in the gospel age. He says that Christ “quoted and re-inforced the substance of all the commandments except the fourth.” But David said the law of the Lord is “perfect.” I ask in all candor, if to change a perfect law would not make it imperfect? Paul says in Heb. 8: 7, that the old covenant which was made with the Israelites was not perfect. One may search the Bible from Genesis to the Revelation, and nowhere will he find the statement made that the ten commandments are not perfect. Therefore the conclusion is both logical and reasonable that the ten commandments are not the covenant that was “faulty” and done away; but, on the contrary, they are binding on Christians today.
We thank God and take courage that we see amid the most bitter and determined opposition, thousands turning from the observance of the Sunday Sabbath, to keep the Sabbath of the fourth commandment. And while you find it in your heart to pray that men may turn their ears away from hearing this precious truth, we remember what God has said of such: “He that turneth away his ear from hearing the law, even his prayer shall be abomination.” And our Saviour has said: “Whosoever therefore shall break one of these least commandments, and shall teach men so, he shall be called the least [or of no esteem] in the kingdom of heaven: but whosoever shall do and teach them, the same shall be called great in the kingdom of heaven.” Matt. 5: 19.
But I must bring this letter to a close. Before doing so, however, I would like to present a few of the many reasons why I rest on the Saturday, the seventh day, in order that you may compare them with Eld. Litch's reasons for not doing so, and thus be better able to judge which of us has the best Bible reasons. 1. I have the example of God himself. Heb. 4: 4. 2. I have the example of Christ. Luke 4: 16. 3. I have the plain and positive command of God. Ex. 20: 10. Do you think God will condemn me for doing as he has done? Will he condemn me for doing what he has positively commanded me to do, and what Christ has reiterated, knowing that I have his own example and that of Christ and all the inspired men of all ages? Do you believe that in the Judgment he will condemn the Jews for breaking this commandment, and condemn me for keeping it, when we are all to be judged by the same law? Rom. 2: 11–16.
My reasons for not regarding Sunday, the first day of the week, as the Lord's day are these: 1. The Bible nowhere mentions it as such. 2. It nowhere commands its observance. 3. There are no blessings pronounced for keeping it. 4. There is not a prohibition in the Bible against laboring on that day. 5. The reasons specified in the fourth commandment for a weekly Sabbath, would not be true when applied to the first day of the week; hence it finds no support in the Bible, and therefore I cannot regard it as anything more or less than a common laboring-day.
I trust that God will bless you in all your investigations to know and do his will; and that we may meet at last, and greet each other in the soon coming kingdom, shall ever be my earnest prayer.
Moultrie, St. John's Co., Fla.