PROPHETIC CONFUSION

13%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Aug 9, 1887

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 64, No. 32.

Read the full edition

PROPHETIC CONFUSION.

In the Christian Herald and Signs of Our Times of March 10, 1887, “the Rev. M. Baxter,” who we think might appropriately be called “professor of prophetic muddlement,” publishes a diagram of what is called “the six prophetic cycles of Daniel’s prophecy,” designed to prove that the coming of the Lord will take place in the year 1900. As we look it over we notice one feature which to us is a very striking one; and that is, that every starting-point, and every terminal-point, and every date in the whole scheme is entirely wrong. This is unusual; for however wild a theory may be in its general make up, we usually find something somewhere in it that is correct; but we are unable to discover one such point in the view before us.
That the reader may not think we wish to set up our own judgment as a standard in the matter, we will name the points, and then he can judge for himself.
1. In the first place he introduces a period of “seven times,” or 2,520 years, dates them from 620 before Christ, and ends them in 1900 after Christ. One great trouble with this part of the program is that there is no such period as seven times or 2,520 years brought to view in all the Scriptures. The language from which this view is drawn, is found in Lev. 26; but the words there used are not a noun and its adjective, as would be the case if it was meant to signify duration; it is simply an adverb, both in the Hebrew and the Greek, meaning “sevenfold.” The expression, “I will punish you yet seven times,” refers simply to the intensity of the nature of the punishment, not to its duration. But even if it did refer to a prophetic period, what was there in 620 B. C. to mark its commencement?—Nothing whatever. Judah went into captivity fifty-seven years before.
2. The next point is the beginning of the 2300 days of Dan. 8:14, which he places in the days of Nehemiah, 445 B. C. But there was no commandment issued to Nehemiah to restore and build Jerusalem. The full authority for this work was given to Ezra twelve years before, in the 7th of Artaxerxes, B. C. 457. This scheme, of course, makes those days end in 1855-6. But what was there there to mark their termination?—Absolutely nothing, from the standpoint of Mr. B., who believes that the Sanctuary is here upon the earth. It would be interesting to have him show us what cleansing of the Sanctuary is now going on.
3. The sixty-nine weeks which, reckoned from the commandment to restore and build Jerusalem, were to reach to Messiah the prince, dated from 445 B. C., would extend to A. D. 38-9. This period, Mr. B. says, reaches to the “cutting off of the Messiah;” but every careful reader of Dan. 9 will see that this cannot be so. It is after three-score and two weeks (Dan. 9:26), added to the seven mentioned in the verse before; that is, after sixty-nine weeks, or 483 years, from the going forth of the commandment to restore and build Jerusalem that the Messiah was to be cut off. How long after the sixty-nine weeks this cutting off was to take place, verse 27 informs us: it was to be “in the midst,” or middle, of this last, or seventieth week; that is, three and one half years later than the termination of the 483 years; and if these ended A. D. 38-9, the middle of the following week would be A. D. 43. But this is twelve years too late for the crucifixion. But if we allow him to place the cutting off erroneously at the end of the 483 years, when he terminates them in A. D. 38-9, he is seven years too late for the crucifixion, which the most reliable historical testimony places in the year A. D. 31.
4. His next attempt is to fix the terminal points of the three prophetic periods of Dan. 12; namely, the 1260, 1290, and 1335 days. These he commences all together in A. D. 565-6. But it is evident from Dan. 12:11, 12, that the 1290 and 1335 begin before the 1260; for these latter mark the career of the papacy,—“the abomination that maketh desolate;” but the daily abomination, or paganism, had to be taken away in order to the setting up of the papacy (see margin); and it is from this taking away of paganism that the 1290 and 1335 days are to be reckoned, according to this scripture. He is therefore entirely wrong in dating them all together. From his starting-point he ends these periods as follows: the 1260 in 1825; the 1290 in 1855 (where he also places the termination of the 2300 days); the 1335 in 1900, where he has the end come. But what took place in 565 to mark the beginning of papal supremacy?—Nothing; the pope was made spiritual head of Christendom in 538, and Phocas did not confer upon him temporal sovereignty till 606. And what overthrow of his power took place 1260 years later, in 1825?—None; this was accomplished in 1798, twenty-seven years previous. And what took place in 1855-6 to mark the end of the “abomination of desolation”? And echo is so astonished at the proposition that it goes back to the beginning of the question, and repeats the word “what;” and that is all the answer we get.
5. And now we come to the most surprising part of the whole scheme. He takes the seventieth week of Daniel’s period of seventy weeks, detaches it from the sixty-nine, and throws it away over to the close of this century, making it commence in 1893 and terminate where he wants everything else to terminate, in 1900. Why he begins them in 1893 does not appear, only that it is just seven years from the close of the century. We need say no more. The reader can now judge whether the estimate made at the outset of the correctness of his applications was sound or not.