A “DUMFOUNDER,” TO THE ADVENTISTS

20%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Aug 9, 1887

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 64, No. 32.

Read the full edition

A “DUMFOUNDER,” TO THE ADVENTISTS.

The editor of the Michigan Christian Advocate has announced in a late issue of that journal the discovery of what he terms, “a dumfounder to the Adventists.” Having never come across anything of this sort before, we might be in the dark as to what a “dumfounder” was, did he not accompany his announcement by the explanation. It is, in brief, that a prominent minister of that denomination has renounced the doctrines which he once held, and to the promulgation of which he had devoted himself for a quarter of a century. This might appear to be something of a “dumfounder” to the individual who made such a record, but the Advocate puts it as being such to the denomination he has left. Let us glance a moment at this awe-inspiring assertion.
Yes; undoubtedly it is an occasion for surprise when one who has so long devoted himself to a certain work suddenly turns against it, and joins the ranks of its enemies; but perhaps it is not an occasion for such overpowering surprise as the Advocate seems to think. One would get the impression from what it says that such a thing had never happened before in connection with any good cause; but it has, as the history of every such cause informs us. The cause of truth has had such incidents connected with it from the days of Adam down. For instance, at the present day it is not an uncommon spectacle to see persons of unquestioned ability and intellect renouncing Protestantism and joining the ranks of Catholics. Is this a “dumfounder” to Protestantism? The Advocate ought to consider it such. And how many of the Advocate’s own profession of faith (Methodist), men of intellect and sound reason, have left that denomination to cast in their lot with the Seventh-day Adventists?—More than one, it is needless to say. Are these to be considered as so many “dumfounders” for Methodism?
But when we come to consider this individual’s course more minutely, we find that it is more surpassingly strange than would appear at first glance. It is a fact well known and often observed that when a person once makes a failure in a certain direction, he is not apt to make that failure again. A person rarely exhibits the same weakness twice. This is what makes the course of the one in question so anomalous. He did not stop with the first exhibition, but manifested the same weakness several times. How strange it is that after separating himself more or less from his denomination four times, he should finally do the same thing again! Who would not be overcome with surprise, in view of such an unaccountable phenomenon!
As before stated, the cause of truth has been assailed by “dumfounders” of this sort very often in the course of its long struggle with error. Individuals of prominent connection with it have turned against it, and its enemies have indulged in imaginary triumphs and predicted its speedy overthrow. A very signal instance of this occurred in the life of our Lord. One of his nearest disciples suddenly forsook the cause with which he had been connected for several years, giving it at the same time what many thought was its finishing blow. The Pharisees were not at that time publishing a paper in the interests of their errors, but had they been, we imagine there would have appeared in its columns a paragraph something like this: “A hard stroke for the Nazarites.” “When a man like Judas Iscariot forsakes the cause of the much-talked-of Nazarene, it signifies a great deal. He was very prominently connected with it for three years and a half, and if there was anything to it he would be the one to know. But the more he thought about it, the more he became convinced that the pretensions of his master were only a fraud, and accordingly he has delivered him into our hands, to be dealt with according to the law. This sudden step on the part of one so well informed as Judas is a dumfounder to the Nazarene’s followers. All of them appear to be seized with consternation. We are mistaken if his cause does not speedily collapse.” But it survived then, and it will sustain no injury now from a stroke of comparatively so much less significance. L. A. S.