Similarity of National Reform Theories of Government and the Papacy

3%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Jul 12, 1887

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 64, No. 28.

Read the full edition

Similarity of National Reform Theories of Government and the Papacy.

BY W. A. BLAKELY.
In order that the National Reform Association may extend its influence as much as possible, and at the same time avoid raising the opposition of many who would oppose it if they saw that work in its true light, the leading workers of the movement use all kinds of sophistry, both in their writings and public speaking. As an illustration of this, we would refer to the following words of W. J. Coleman, one of the leading public lecturers of the Association, in explaining the changes that would have to be made to conform the present Constitution to the proposed amendment for which they are now laboring:—
“The first sentence of Article 1 of Amendments reads, ‘Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof.’ This would be made consistent with the proposed amendment by substituting the words ‘a church’ for ‘religion,’ making it read, ‘Congress shall make no law regarding an establishment of a church.’ This is what the Reform Association believes should be the rule in a rightly constituted State. There should be religion, but no church.”
Here we have stated just what the National Reformers claim that they want. They desire to give this Government the power to make laws respecting the establishment of religion. But what does that mean? Let us see. The National Reformers say:—
“This being a Christian nation, we want such an amendment to the Constitution of the United States as will . . . place all the Christian laws, institutions, and usages of our Government on an undeniable legal basis in the fundamental law of the land.” Or, as we find in the Christian Statesman of Oct. 2, 1884:—
“Give all men to understand that this is a Christian nation; and that, believing that without Christianity we perish, we must maintain by all right means our Christian character. Inscribe this character on our Constitution. . . . Enforce [i. e., “execute with vigor.”—Webster] upon all that come among us the laws of Christian morality.”
This, say they, is what we want; there should be [the Christian] religion, but no church; i. e., no sect of the Christian religion. But in connection with this, let me record, for their benefit, an important historical fact, which our zealous National Reform friends, in their extensive researches into the history of nations and into the principles of government, seem to have overlooked. It is this: The greatest persecution the world has ever witnessed, has followed from taking the very step which these Reformers advocate; i. e., to establish the Christian religion as a whole and then to “enforce upon all” the “laws, institutions, and usages” of that religion. Of course, after the religion was established, all Christians, or sects of Christians, who did not agree with the majority, were “heretics,” “infidels,” or “atheists;” and this is just where the religious amendmentists propose to class them, as we will show further on. This so-called “reform,” if carried out on the proposed plan, will “reform” our Government into one as corrupt morally as was the Roman government during the supremacy of the papacy and the reign of the “Holy Inquisition.”
In Gibbon’s “Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire,” we read the following:—
“The gratitude of the church has exalted the virtues and excused the failings of a generous patron, who [A. D. 323, see Mosheim’s Historical Commentaries, cent. 4, sec. 7] seated Christianity on the throne of the Roman world . . . The exact balance of the two religions [pagan and Christian] continued but a moment.” Chap. 20, par. 17.
Here, then, according to the National Reform theory, we have a Christian nation in the full sense of that term, the Christian religion being established as the national religion. For, according to the Rev. M. A. Gault, one of the leading lights of the Association,—
“The individual may confess Christ through motives of hypocrisy, but not so of the nation. Such a confession in its Constitution can only be made through the prevailing sentiment of the nation. And, therefore, as true conversion in the individual, so this amendment in our national Constitution includes the triumph of every moral reform.”
All that followed, then, according to these words, we may consider a triumph of moral reform. But what did follow? Gibbon says:—
“The piercing eye of ambition and avarice soon discovered that the profession of Christianity might contribute to the interests of the present, as well as to a future life. The hopes of wealth and honors, the example of an emperor, his irresistible smiles, diffused conviction among the venal and obsequious crowds which usually fill the apartments of a palace.” Chap. 20, par. 17.
A strange kind of moral reform indeed! But it was not long until they put to shame and disgraced their profession with their evil deeds, which overpassed the deeds of the wicked. Jer. 5:28. But, notwithstanding this, the amendmentists publish to the world, that “this amendment in our national Constitution includes the triumph of every moral reform!” But what might be somewhat surprising, they profess that to the world, but do not believe it themselves. This is proved by expressions used by Rev. R. Audley Browne, D. D., one of the vice-presidents of the Association, in a National Convention held in Pittsburg, in 1874. He describes what the movement will bring about, giving the same thought quoted from the historian Gibbon. Dr. Browne spoke as follows:—
“There is no more persistent man alive than the typical representative American office-seeker. Of that class, the most of those who have not yet found whether they are for Christ or not, or who are openly decrying this movement, are ready to be its firm friends as soon as they acquire wisdom to discern the signs of the times, and are assured of its speedy success. They may pull back now at the hind axle, or scotch the wheels on the car of progress, but when they see it move, they will quickly jump in to get front seats, and vow that they always thought it was a good thing,” etc.
They can themselves see that a premium will be placed on hypocrisy, and that the church will become a place to which the “venal and obsequious crowds which usually fill the apartments” of our political halls, will flock. In fact, the church would then be “the habitation of devils, and the hold of every foul spirit, and a cage of every unclean and hateful bird.” Rev. 18:2.
Gibbon further says:—
“The Edict of Milan [A. D. 313, ten years before he made a profession of Christianity], the great charter of toleration, had confirmed to each individual of the Roman world the privilege of choosing and professing his own religion. But this inestimable privilege was soon violated; with the knowledge of truth, the emperor imbibed the maxims of persecution; and the sects which dissented from the Catholic Church were afflicted and oppressed by the triumph of Christianity. Constantine easily believed that the heretics, who presumed to dispute his opinions, or oppose his commands, were guilty of the most absurd and criminal obstinacy.”—Chap. 21, par. 1.
This is also the doctrine of the Reformers. The Christian Statesman of Oct. 2, 1884, says:—
“Enforce, [i. e., “execute with vigor.”—Webster] upon all that come among us the laws of Christian morality.”
And as in Constantine’s time all “who presumed to dispute his opinions or oppose his commands were guilty of the most absurd and criminal obstinacy,” and were classed and punished as “heretics,” “infidels,” and “atheists,” no matter how good their lives were, nor how firmly they held to the Scriptures, so it is with the National Reformers; they class all persons who believe the Christian religion, but who happen to differ with them, as “atheists,”—even persons as eminent for piety as are the Seventh-day Baptists.
This is National Reform doctrine, for that Association published the address of one of their eminent vice-presidents, Rev. Jonathan Edwards, D. D., LL. D., who, after speaking of the atheist, deist, and Jew, the dissenters from their doctrine, says:—
“The Seventh-day Baptists believe in God and Christianity, and are conjoined with the other members of this class by the accident of differing with the mass of Christians upon the question of what precise day of the week shall be observed as holy. These are all, for the occasion, and as far as our amendment is concerned, one class. They use the same arguments and the same tactics against us. They must be counted together.”
Then let us ask Dr. Edwards what religious liberty they propose to give to the Seventh-day Baptists, who are good Christians, but differ from Christians generally only, in that they take the Bible as it reads in regard to the Sabbath, instead of in the way that Christians generally accept it. What are the rights of these “atheists”?
“What are the rights of the atheist? I would tolerate him as I would tolerate a poor lunatic; for in my view his mind is scarcely sound. So long as he does not rave, so long as he is not dangerous, I would tolerate him. I would tolerate him as I would a conspirator. The atheist is a dangerous man.”
Then to show the “Christian” spirit of the movement, we quote from Rev. E. B. Graham, another vice-president, who says:—
“If the opponents of the Bible [that is, the National Reform views of the Bible] do not like our Government and its Christian features, let them go to some wild and desolate land; and in the name of the Devil, and for the sake of the Devil, subdue it, and set up a government of their own, on infidel and atheistic ideas, and then, if they can stand it, stay there till they die.”
And again from Dr. Edwards:—
“Tolerate atheism, sir? There is nothing out of hell that I would not tolerate as soon.”
Remember, too, that the learned doctor ranks Sabbatarianism with atheism, and says “they must be counted together,” and “for the occasion, and as far as our amendment is concerned, one class.” Religious liberty, indeed! In view of such statements as the foregoing, can any one say that this movement does not mean persecution, and that it is anything but a repetition of the very things that led to the establishment of the Inquisition and the greatest persecution ever known? If such is the “reform” that we are to have, it will undoubtedly add to the number and wealth of the professed church; but may the Lord come to the deliverance of his people.