A LEGITIMATE REQUEST

6%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Jun 7, 1887

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 64, No. 23.

Read the full edition

A LEGITIMATE REQUEST.

WHEN we are told that the Sabbath is or was a Jewish institution, and that it has been abolished or changed to the first day of the week, we ask those taking such positions to give us—
  1. A text which calls the Sabbath of the fourth commandment a Jewish Sabbath.
  2. A text which states that God has changed the Sabbath of the fourth commandment from the seventh to the first day of the week.
  3. A text which commands the first day of the week to be kept in memory of Christ’s resurrection, or for any other reason.
The Christian Oracle (Disciple paper, Des Moines, Iowa) thinks it “very easy to ask such questions with an air of bravado,” and says: “Let us try it a little. Jesus said to his apostles after his resurrection, to go and make disciples of all nations, those that had the law, and those that had it not, and said to them, ‘Teach these disciples to observe all things I have commanded you.’ Now the apostles went out and taught ‘all things’ that Christians must observe. Now we will give a reward of $10 to any one who will find an answer to any one of these three questions:—
“1. Where is the text in which the apostles commanded Christians to observe the seventh day as the Sabbath?”
“2. Where is the text that shows that Christians met on that day for worship?”
“3. Where did an apostle ever condemn a Christian for not keeping the Sabbath?”
These questions the Oracle offers as parallel to those first named. Perhaps it thinks this an exhibition of good logic. But here is where the surprise comes in; that men who have reached years of maturity and are living under the shadow of a “University,” should apparently be unable to discern the difference between these two series of propositions, and should offer the latter as an equivalent of the former.
We do not contend for the observance of the seventh day as a new institution, resting upon new obligations. It is simply the continuance of one already ordained and explicitly commanded. Why; then, should we look for a repetition of the command? Why should we call upon the apostles for any command concerning it? We might just as reasonably call for a formal re-enactment of the Constitution of the United States upon every change of administration. Such a proposition is about as thoughtless and short-sighted as could well be conceived.
But how is it with the first day of the week? This comes in as a new institution, either as a successor of the original Sabbath by means of a change, or as an independent rest day, the former having been abolished to make way for it. In the face of such claims as these, it is perfectly logical and legitimate to call for some proof for the innovation. Hence we say, Give us some text to show that the original Sabbath has been abolished, some text that it has been changed, or some command for the observance of the new institution. And unless they can do this, it is an imposition upon common sense to urge upon us that we are under any obligation to keep it, or are released from the prior obligation of the antecedent institution.
It seems to be the misfortune of some men to lack continuity. In their minds lines of thought seem to be chaotic and fragmentary. It seems to be impossible for them to conceive that God has a uniform purpose running through all his works from beginning to end. So they will have it that at the close of every dispensation, God rubs out all that he had previously done, and begins on a new plan to accomplish a new purpose by other means. So, according to their scheme, when Christ came all that existed before had to go to everlasting smash. The whole scheme of God’s moral government broke up. The ten commandments ceased to exist. Men were left for a time without law and consequently without responsibility. But, thanks to this moral chaos, the beneficent institution of the Sabbath—hold! no that awful seventh day—disappeared. And the apostles were left to gather up what fragments they saw fit, and organize a new order of things. And where, oh! where, “have they commanded us to keep the seventh day?” Yes; and where, oh! where, have they commanded us to keep Sunday?
It is most astonishing to observe, notwithstanding all that God has done and said in regard to the seventh day, and all Christ’s care to show what was according to the Sabbath law, and his declaration that the law of which it is a part cannot change in a jot or tittle while heaven and earth endure,—it is astonishing that notwithstanding all this it is impossible to keep the seventh day upon its feet; but nevertheless the first day, without Christ or apostles, precept or example, can stalk abroad like a giant. Why is this?—It is simply because all the world is wondering after the beast, whose pet progeny it is. Rev. 13:3.
The Oracle says that the apostles went out and “taught” all things that Christians “must observe.” Now as the apostles certainly taught nothing concerning Sunday-keeping, it follows that Sunday-keeping is not among the things which Christians are to observe. Yet the Disciples reverence Sunday as the Lord’s day. It certainly seems very strange, if the Lord has reserved to himself one day in each week as his (and it is no “Lord’s day” if he has not)—it seems very strange that he should lay no obligation upon any one to pay any regard to it.
The disciples kept the Sabbath this side the cross where everything distinctively Jewish was taken out of the way, and they kept it, too, “according to the commandment,” the record thus showing that the commandment was still in force: “And they returned [from the burial of Christ], and prepared spices and ointments; and rested the Sabbath day according to the commandment.” Luke 23:56. How timely for the Sunday institution would be some such testimony as this in its behalf—if, for instance, Acts 1:12 could be made to read like this: “Then returned they unto Jerusalem from the mount called Olivet, which is from Jerusalem a Sabbath day’s journey, and rested the first day of the week instead of the seventh, as the Lord had instructed them!”
What longing there has been for a text of this kind; but the “aching void” can never be filled; for the testimony is nowhere to be found. Give us some passage like this and we will keep Sunday also; but until you do, we shall “stand fast in the liberty wherewith Christ has made us free,” and not come into bondage to an institution which has paganism for its father, and Roman Catholicism for its mother.
A complete safeguard against all this confusion of ideas set forth by the Disciples and all other Antinomians, the reader will find in the thought that God will judge all men by one uniform standard at the last. What is sin in one age of the world is sin in another. From first to last it is violation of the great moral principles of God’s government, touching our duties to himself and to our fellow creatures. “Sin is the transgression of the law.” 1 John 3:4. And these principles find expression in the decalogue, written under the shadowy dispensation on tables of stone, but under the gospel written in the heart. Jer. 31:33; Heb. 8:10. Among these is the Sabbath. “And hallow my Sabbaths; and they shall be a sign between me and you, that ye may know that I am the Lord your God” (Eze. 20:20) “that doth sanctify you.” Ex. 31:13. It is so important now as at any time, that people be sanctified by the Lord Jehovah; and the constant outward sign of connection between God and his people is his Sabbath.
In Rom. 2 Paul puts all men, both Jews and Gentiles, on the same footing, all to be rewarded according to their deeds, without respect of persons. Only the Jews having greater light than the nations around them while they were God’s chosen people, fall under greater guilt for transgression. But the dim shadow in the hearts of the Gentiles, of that law of which the Jew was for the time being God’s appointed custodian, will be a sufficient witness of their guilt, and show the justice of their condemnation, in the day of Judgment. The standard is the same; the guilt is proportioned to the light enjoyed, and the integrity with which that light is followed. James warns all Christians that they “shall be judged by the law of liberty;” and to show what law that is, he declares that it is the one which has among its formal enactments the precepts, “Thou shalt not commit adultery,” and “Thou shalt not kill.” James 2:10–12.