AdventAI

Bismarck's Canossa

From Review and Herald, Vol. 64, No. 19., May 10, 1887

With the passage of the Ecclesiastical Bill, now assured, by the Prussian Diet, the war between Prussia and Rome, which has been on the wane several years, practically comes to an end. It has been one of the fiercest struggles of modern times, and during the pontificate of Pius IX. it seemed as though the result must be ruin of the Church in Germany. By the vigorous enforcement of the Falk Laws, dioceses and parishes were vacated, and the faithful were without oversight or spiritual ministrations. The pope was as inexorable as the “Man of Iron” himself, and launched his anathemas against the German government as freely as he did against the Italian despoiler of the papal states. Bismarck declared he would not go “to Canossa;” he would not yield as did that proud emperor of Germany who crossed the Alps in midwinter to humble himself in submission to Pope Gregory VII. He was determined, so the Protestant world understood, to break the power of the vatican over the subjects of the state, and make the Church of Rome in Germany a German national church, owing its allegiance first to Germany, and secondly to the Holy Father. “In the kingdom of this world,” he maintained, in defending in 1883 his proposal to modify the Falk Laws, “the state is entitled to power and precedence.” The conflict, he insisted, was between royalty and the priesthood, and, though a Protestant state could not expect to establish a perfect understanding with the vatican,—which was a problem like that of squaring the circle,—it was possible to arrive at a modus vivendi. He did not, he declared, ever prosecute war for the sake of war, but for the sake of peace.

A modus vivendi has certainly been established. The “pope and king are agreed on the subject,” as the chancellor remarked in the Prussian Diet, a few weeks ago, and when “the pope and king are agreed, we need not be afraid of Dr. Windthorst and his Centrists.” How this modus vivendi was brought about a few words will suffice to explain. The state has simply repealed the belligerent legislation of 1874, not all at once, but by degrees. First came a relaxation in the enforcement of the laws, which was emphasized by the appointment of Herr Von Puttkamer to succeed Dr. Falk as Minister of Public Worship in 1879; then came modifications by the Diet, year by year, until now, with the passage of the pending bill, which has already been through the Upper Chamber, hardly a single feature of the rigorous system of 1874 remains. The May Laws have simply been swept away by Bismarck, who now appears as the champion of the Church. Has he gone to Canossa?

In seeking for an answer to this question, we must remember that Pope Leo XIII. is a very different pope from Pope Pius IX. It was under the régime of the latter that modern ideas and modern civilization were denounced, and the ecclesiasticism of the Church of Rome thrown obstructively across the track of all progress. Out of the rusty mediævalism of Pius IX. and his Ultramontane supporters came the dogma of papal infallibility; and simultaneously with the acceptance of the dogma of infallibility came the outbreak of hostilities between France, the eldest son of the Church, and Germany. The result of this war made the unification of Italy possible, and sealed the fate of the temporal power of the pope. But the pope, whose motto was Non possumus, would not accept the lessons of these events. As represented by him, vaticanism was a menace to the liberty of civil government, and Bismarck did not hesitate to grapple with it. The Center party was then the party of the pope and of Ultramontanism, and the chancellor united Conservative and Liberal in common cause against it. Recently he had need of the Center party, which is still Ultramontane, but not fully papal, to play against Conservative and Liberal, and he hastened to remove, as he explained in his March address in the Prussian Diet, all pretext for Centrists to continue in petulant opposition. By this promise to repeal the Falk Laws he won the friendship of the pope, and did not scruple to use the influence of his holiness to induce Herr Windthorst and his Centrists to vote for the Septenate. This was clearly sharp practice. The pope, at the suggestion of the wily statesman, laid his commands on Windthorst and party not only to vote for the Septenate, but to accept, without amendment, the Ecclesiastical Bill. This they did, not with the best grace, but submissively; and nobody enjoyed their chagrin more than Bismarck himself, who reminded them that he and the pope were in accord, and it mattered little what they thought or did. The pope and Bismarck in accord! The pope participating in German politics at the request of Bismarck! What stranger things than these has this century witnessed?

The policy of repeal is in the line of wise and generous statesmanship, though political exigency and not high principle has evidently dictated it. Bismarck has gone to Canossa, but not on a penitential journey; and Leo XIII. is not Gregory VII.—The Independent.