A CORRESPONDENT sends us a 126-page pamphlet on this subject, by “Rev. W. A. McKay, B. A., Pastor of Chalmers’ Church, Woodstock, Ont.,” which she requests us to notice, as she confesses herself somewhat perplexed and confused on the subject of baptism, by some of its alleged arguments and statements. Being desirous to aid as far as possible any one who is liable to be affected by the deceptions of error, we will notice a few of the points presented in this work.
The full title of the book is, “Immersion Proved to be not a Scriptural Mode of Baptism, but a Romish Invention; and Immersionists shown to be disregarding Divine Authority in refusing Baptism to the Infant Children of Believers.”
This startling title page betrays a certain recklessness of statement which will go far to weaken the confidence of the reader in whatever the book itself may contain. It strikes us as a little singular, if immersion is a Romish invention, that it has so completely disappeared from the Romish communion. Who now ever hears of any one’s being immersed in the Romish Church? And who ever knew of a Romish invention which was once established in the Church and then abandoned? That is utterly contrary to the whole traditional policy of that Church. Again Mr. McKay says (p. 121), “No instance of baptism by a single backward dip occurs in history prior to Sept. 12, 1633.” And yet he calls immersion a Romish invention. Shall we understand, then, that Rome invented this in the 17th century, and the Baptists caught it from them, and they have now given it all away? The very face of Christendom to-day blots out one half his title-page to begin with.
To meet the objection that there is no command in the New Testament to baptize children, he says:—
“The argument for infant baptism, like that for the observance of the Christian Sabbath, is inferential, cumulative, and conclusive” (italics his).
The argument for the so-called Christian Sabbath is here rated at its true value, only that starting out from its basis of mere inference, it is “cumulative” in the negative, not affirmative, direction, and finally “conclusive” as showing that there is not a scrap of authority for it in the word of God. Mr. McK. does well to place the argument for infant baptism in the same category. They are both of them children of apostasy and tradition. Such reasoning indeed presents a dilemma to those Baptists who still adhere to the man-made Sabbath; but with those who have returned to the Sabbath of the Lord, it has no weight.
The testimony of Mark 16:16 is conclusive as showing that baptism is to be administered to believers only. The divine order is, “Repent, believe, and be baptized.” The proper subject for baptism is therefore one who has reached such a degree of maturity that he is responsible for his own actions, and is able understandingly to repent of his sinful acts, and to exercise faith in the remedy for the same. Our author attempts to dispose of this testimony as follows:—
Baptist reasoning concerning the baptism of infants.
The same reasoning applied to infant salvation.
“‘He that believeth and is baptized shall be saved.’ (Mark 16:16.)”
“‘He that believeth not shall be damned.’ (Mark 16:16.)”
“‘But infants cannot believe;”
“‘But infants cannot believe;”
“‘Therefore”
“‘Therefore”
“‘Infants are not to be baptized.”
“‘Infants shall be damned.”
The utter fallacy of such reasoning must be apparent to any one. The belief required on the part of him who would be baptized, is a positive exercise of the mind of which infants are not capable; therefore they cannot be subjects of baptism. But the disbelief (he that believeth not) is also a positive exercise of the mind, in the other direction, of which infants are no more capable than of the first; and therefore infants do not come under the denunciation of the text. A man who will try to make it appear that the inability of an infant to believe, is the same as the positive and conscious disbelief which alone the text condemns, and then draw the conclusion that therefore all infants will be damned, taxes to the utmost our confidence in his honesty. He adds, “Both these conclusions are ‘utterly and awfully false,’ but both are the logical conclusions of Baptist reasoning on this passage;” to which it is sufficient to reply that both are not the logical conclusions of Baptist reasoning on this passage. One is a necessary conclusion from the testimony itself, and the other is a hideous caricature of logic to which the pedobaptist is driven to sustain his antichristian doctrine.
Another specimen of the reasoning of this divine may be found on pp. 55 and 56. He says:—
“As to other cases of Scripture baptism, Baptists act on the principle that the less said about them, the better for immersion. They all indicate very clearly some other mode than immersion. The baptism of Paul by Ananias (Acts 9:17, 18; 22:12–16) was in the solitary chamber where the penitent man was fasting and praying and was received standing” (italics his).
We find it isn’t always safe to take even a minister’s reference to Scripture without an examination of the passage itself. Let us, then, read Acts 9:18: “And immediately there fell from his eyes as it had been scales: and he received sight forthwith, and arose, and was baptized.”
This passage our astute logician puts in as evidence that Paul’s baptism took place there in his solitary chamber, and that he received it standing. Let us test it by another scripture: Num. 22:21: “And Balaam rose up in the morning, and saddled his ass.” Now let us draw our conclusions à la McKay: “Balaam kept his ass in his private chamber; he always had him standing there beside his bed; one morning he wanted to saddle him, and all he had to do was to rise up and put the saddle upon him right there in the room. Balaam didn’t leave the house to saddle his ass; oh, no! the record simply says that he ‘rose up;’ that is, he merely assumed the perpendicular, and saddled him ‘standing!’”
Take another: Josh. 24:9: “Then Balak the son of Zippor, king of Moab, arose and warred against Israel.” “This, mind you,” Mr. McK.’s rule would compel us to say, “took place in Balak’s private chamber; Balak ‘rose up’ there in his little room, and slashed around against the whole host of Israel.”
Should we attempt thus to reason seriously upon these passages, would not the sober judgment of every reader be that we were playing the part either of an idiot or a knave in reference to the sacred record; yet we have the same data as in Acts 9:18, and the reasoning is the same, and the conclusions are exactly as legitimate as those Mr. McK. attempts to draw from the latter passage, to show that Paul was not immersed!
Another passage will show how he suffers his prejudice to drive him not only far away from legitimate methods of reasoning, but even from the plain statements of the record itself. On p. 56, he says:—
“The baptism of the jailer and his household at Philippi (Acts 15:32–44) [this should be Acts 16:32–34] was at the dead hour of night and in a jail, and by one of his prisoners—at a time, and in a place, and by a person which forbade the use of other mode than that of sprinkling or pouring. Every one of these instances is strong evidence against immersion.”
In this case, too, we must go to the record for ourselves, to get at the truth of the matter. Verses 25–27 state how Paul and Silas sang in the prison, how a great earthquake shook the prison, opened its doors, and loosed the bands of every one, and how the jailer, seeing the doors open, and supposing the prisoners had escaped, drew a sword and was about to kill himself. In verse 28, the record continues: “But Paul cried with a loud voice, saying, Do thyself no harm; for we are all here. Then he called for a light, and sprang in, and came trembling, and fell down before Paul and Silas, and brought them out, and said, Sirs, what must I do to be saved.”
This testimony assures us that the jailer “brought them out.” Then they were not in the prison; but we are told that this baptism took place “in a jail.” The record goes on to say that they spake the word of God to the jailer and to all that were in his house. Where were they then?—In the jailer’s house, not in the jail. Then he washed their stripes; and it was after all this, when they were out of the prison, loosed from their bands, had had their stripes washed, and had preached to the household, that they baptized the jailer. Yet we are coolly told that that baptism was in a jail, and under circumstances which forbade any other mode but sprinkling or pouring! Couldn’t immersion possibly be performed in the night? If Paul was loosed from his bands, couldn’t he immerse as well as pour or sprinkle? And it must have been a very barren place if water enough to immerse a person could not have been found immediately at hand. Philippi was a sea-port town (Acts 20:6), and there was a river there near the city “where prayer was wont to be made” (Acts 16:13), hence abundance of water must have been within easy reach.
Other like specimens might be produced, but these will suffice. If pedobaptism would commend itself to the people, it should seek some one to champion its cause who is able or willing to quote the Scripture correctly, and able or willing to draw correct conclusions from established premises.
Like a man treading on eggs he glides very lightly and very swiftly over those passages which set forth the real intent and object of the ordinance of baptism, and which are absolutely decisive in regard to the form in which alone it can be properly administered. One little section of his book is devoted to such passages as Rom. 6:3, 4 and Col. 2:12; but he betrays a very manifest disinclination to dwell upon them, and hastens away as soon as possible. He is pleased to call these “some figurative expressions concerning spiritual baptism.” Baptism, he says, is a symbol of the operation of the Holy Spirit; and as the Spirit is “poured” out, and our hearts are “sprinkled from an evil conscience,” therefore water is to be applied to the person by being poured or sprinkled upon him; and this is baptism. This is the pedobaptist ground concisely stated. The whole scheme is simply a manifestation of that disposition which is natural to the human heart, to mark out and follow a way of its own. It does not like to do just what God says, and for the reason that God assigns. So in this case men have devised a purpose of their own for baptism to answer, and then have perverted the ordinance to suit that purpose, and then try to wrest the testimony of the Scriptures to sustain them in it. Where is it said that the church should maintain a symbol of the work of the Holy Spirit? Where is it said that baptism is a symbol of that work? This is a figment of human imagination.
The Scriptures have given us two great memorials of the work of Christ—the supper to show forth his death, baptism to show his burial and resurrection. Having perverted baptism to the senseless mummery of sprinkling, the church found itself without a memorial of Christ’s resurrection, and to supply the lack proceeded to make the matter worse by bringing in an equally human and anti-scriptural device, that of the celebration of the first day of the week; and then took occasion through this to degrade to secular time and trample under foot the holy Sabbath of the Lord. Such are the grievous evils that follow a departure from the Scriptures and the acceptance of the vile husks of tradition in their stead.
Verses 3–5 of Rom. 6, read as follows: “Know ye not, that so many of us as were baptized into Jesus Christ were baptized into his death? Therefore we are buried with him by baptism into death: that like as Christ was raised up from the dead by the glory of the Father, even so we also should walk in newness of life. For if we have been planted together in the likeness of his death, we shall be also in the likeness of his resurrection.” And Col. 2:12 reads: “Buried with him in baptism, wherein also ye are risen with him, through the faith of the operation of God, who hath raised him from the dead.”
If these scriptures do not teach that baptism is an ordinance which involves a form of doctrine (Rom. 6:17) that represents in symbolic character a burial and resurrection, it would be impossible for language to express it. “Planted together in the likeness of his death,” “that like as Christ was raised up from the dead,” etc. What do “like” and “likeness” mean? Do they mean that there is to be in the act of baptism any likeness or resemblance to a burial and resurrection or not?—They mean this if they mean anything. But what likeness to this is there in sprinkling or pouring upon a person a few drops of water?—None at all. This is found only in the act of immersion, a beautiful symbol of these great facts in the work of Christ, a beautiful ordinance by which the believer expresses his faith in these great facts, and his hope of the resurrection through Christ at last.p. 313
The force of this idea of burial Mr. Mc K. attempts to meet in a manner as irrelevant as it is wicked. He says:—
“The Romish theory adopted by the Baptists, that baptism is a burial, is founded on an entire misconception of the mode of burial practiced in the East. We bury our dead under the earth, and this, by a stretch of the fancy, may be conceived as something like putting a person under water; but there was no such custom known to the apostles or those to whom they preached or wrote.”
A statement uttered in more reckless defiance of truth it would be difficult to conceive. “No such custom” as burying the dead “known to the apostles.” Indeed! When Ananias was smitten to death for lying, young men arose, wound him up, carried him out, and buried him, Acts 5:6. When Sapphira was smitten down, the same men carried her out and buried her by her husband. But we are told the apostles did not know any such custom as burying people. What, then, did they do with these bodies? Did they burn them up? Did they hang them up somewhere to be devoured by vultures? Did they take them to some house and lay them upon the shelf? Then we read in Matt. 27:7 about the potter’s field which was secured “to bury strangers in.” Did the man make the foregoing statement not knowing these facts? Then he is to be pitied for his ignorance. Did he make it knowing them? Then he is to be held in utter scorn for his dishonesty. He adds:—
“The Greeks and Romans who were numerous in Judea, and almost the sole inhabitants in the other countries where the apostles labored; always burned the dead bodies of their friends.”
Suppose they did; what has that to do with the teachings of the Scriptures? He might just as well have told us how they slew polar bears in Greenland. It would have had just as much to do with the subject. The Scriptures did not go to the heathen practices of the Greeks and Romans for the figures and illustrations necessary to set forth its doctrines. With the chosen people the general custom was to bury. Some who were able had, to be sure, their sepulchers and tombs, with niches for the bodies; but the generality of the people, as shown above, were buried in the earth, and the essential idea with all was the same—that the body should be inclosed in the earth or tomb, and concealed from sight.
The Scriptures refer us in baptism to the burial of Christ. Why, then, does our author bring in the burning of the dead by the Greeks and Romans?—Only to throw dust and try to confuse the mind. Then he tries to show that Christ’s burial was not such that immersion would furnish any resemblance of it. He says:—
“How was Christ buried? Not in our manner by being put into a coffin and covered up with earth, but by being carried into a cave cut out of the face of a perpendicular rock, and laid on a niche in the wall. Many such tombs are still to be seen around Jerusalem. If four men took up a dead body, carried it into a room, and laid it on a table, would there be any likeness between that and immersion? Yet just this was the burial of Christ.”
Here he adroitly turns the mind aside upon a false idea, and then says that such was the burial of Christ. Such was not the burial of Christ. To take a body into a building above ground, and lay it on a table, is a very different thing from putting it into a tomb beneath the ground or in the side of a hill. But whether buried in the potter’s field or put into one of these tombs, the idea was exactly the same—a covering and concealment in the earth. Christ, says the apostle, died, was buried, and rose again. 1 Cor. 15:3, 4. And such an attempt to nullify the figure which the apostle uses, betrays a weak mind or a desperate cause.
Did space permit, we might expose his criticisms on the Greek verbs and particles, which are equally illogical and unfair. But this will suffice. We lay down the book with the conviction that the doctrine of immersion will not be seriously affected by this effort.