AdventAI

WERE THEY CHRISTIANS?

From Review and Herald, Vol. 64, No. 20., May 17, 1887

One of the most common and transparent specimens of sophistry in connection with the Sabbath controversy is the oft-repeated challenge thrown out by the opponents of the Sabbath, after the tenor of these words: “Where are Gentiles commanded to keep the Sabbath?” “Show us a place where Christians are required to keep the Sabbath;” or, “Show us some apostolic example for keeping the seventh day;” etc., etc. The latest comes from the Christian Oracle (Disciple paper), of Des Moines, Iowa. In its issue of May 5, 1887, its editor says:—

“Give us an apostolic command or example where Christians kept the Sabbath, and we will keep it.”

This is a pledge squarely put. Now when we present the examples, the only possible loop-hole for him to attempt to wriggle out of is touching the question whether the persons named were Christians or not. We will see how he will succeed in unchristianizing them. Here is the testimony: “And the women also, which came with him from Galilee, followed after, and beheld the sepulcher, and how his body was laid. And they returned, and prepared spices and ointments; and rested the Sabbath day according to the commandment.” Luke 23 : 55, 56.

Here we have the specific and unqualified statement that certain ones did, this side the crucifixion, keep the Sabbath, and that, too, according to the commandment. Were these persons Christians? If they were, then we have an “example where Christians kept the Sabbath,” which is just what the editor of the Oracle challenges us to find.

Who, then, were these women who rested the Sabbath day according to the commandment?—They are again mentioned in Matt. 27 : 55, 56: “And many women were there beholding afar off, which followed Jesus from Galilee, ministering unto him; among which was Mary Magdalene, and Mary the mother of James and Joses, and the mother of Zebedee’s children.” Mark (15 : 40, 41) refers to them as follows: “There were also women looking on afar off: among whom was Mary Magdalene, and Mary the mother of James the less and of Joses, and Salome, (who also, when he was in Galilee, followed him and ministered unto him,) and many other women which came up with him unto Jerusalem.” John (19 : 25) bears this record concerning them: “Now there stood by the cross of Jesus his mother, and his mother’s sister, Mary the wife of Cleophas, and Mary Magdalene.”

Now the question is simply this: Was the mother of Jesus a Christian? Were the mother of James the less and Joses, and the mother of James the greater and John, and Mary Magdalene, Christians? Were the women who had followed Jesus and ministered unto him; who had listened with joy to his words, and accepted in their heart of hearts his teaching; who did not desert him during the agonies of the cross, but hastened to perform the last offices which human hands could render to the object of their sacred love;—were these women Christians? We repeat and re-emphasize the question, Were these women Christians? If they were, we have the example of Christians’ resting on the Sabbath; for they “returned and prepared spices and ointments, and rested the Sabbath day according to the commandment.”

But some one, floundering about for a way of escape, may say, “These were women, not men.” Very well; cannot women be Christians? Could not women understand what Christ taught, and know and receive the truth as well as men? Do not all the circumstances show that they would be as scrupulous to carry out his will as men? The challenge calls for an “example where Christians kept the Sabbath;” and we have given it. How far the Disciples are inclined to repudiate the sisters we do not know. Perhaps we shall learn.

Grasping desperately in another direction for some support, they may seize upon this straw: “This was before Pentecost!” Well, what of that? Were there no Christians before Pentecost? Wasn’t the Sabbath abolished till Pentecost? Didn’t the dispensations change till Pentecost? Every Bible reader knows that the dividing line was at the cross. At the cross all the shadows ceased. To the cross everything that was to end with the Mosaic economy was once and forever nailed. On the cross the new testament came into force. Heb. 9 : 16, 17. Whatever survived the cross is for Christians. If the Sabbath ceased at the cross (as it did, if it has ceased at all), then there was no Sabbath for these holy Christian women to rest upon while the Saviour lay in the tomb. If the commandments were nailed to the cross and blotted out, there was no “commandment,” according to which they could keep it. But they did keep the day, and kept it according to the commandment. The day and the commandment are thus recognized as in full force this side of the cross, after that blow had fallen which blotted out and took out of the way every vestige of “the handwriting of ordinances.” We anticipate (for it is safe to anticipate a resort to every conceivable absurdity to parry the force of this fact)—we anticipate that some one will be simple enough to say, “The disciples had not yet learned in regard to the change, and this is why they went right on keeping an old dead Sabbath.” Oh! Then surely Christ had not taught them very much about the abolition of the law; and if he had told them nothing about the going out of the Sabbath, he had told them just as little about the coming in of Sunday. But we would give a thousand times more for what truth Christ imparted to his disciples during his ministry of three years and a half, than for all that Rome was able to invent and bring in during a thousand years of apostasy. It is no help to the matter to say that the disciples did not then know of the change; for Luke certainly knew, or should have known, of it thirty years later, when he wrote his Gospel; or, if he did not, the Holy Spirit who was to inspire his record knew of it all the while. And why should inspiration take the trouble to record a blunder of the disciples, and parade before the world their ignorance, instead of putting in a few words of testimony so grieved and longed for in the Christian world, in behalf of Sunday? But there it stands, a clear, explicit, unequivocal testimony that, after all Mosaic ordinances had forever passed away, the most intimate disciples of our Lord, better Christians than the world can show to-day, did even suspend the affectionate work of embalming their Lord, that they might keep the Sabbath and do it according to the commandment. And inspiration thirty years afterward made a record of this act of integrity to their praise and glory.

Now we call upon the Oracle to stand up squarely to its pledge in the face of this testimony. No cowardice on this issue. Let it (1) unchristianize those women, or (2) keep the Sabbath, or (3) repudiate its own pledge. On which horn of this trilemma will it choose to impale itself? We shall see.