BIBLICAL ANTHROPOLOGY

10%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Sep 13, 1887

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 64, No. 37.

Read the full edition

BIBLICAL ANTHROPOLOGY.

The Independent, in a recent issue, devotes a brief space to the consideration of the above subject, in the style in which it is usually handled by Biblical expounders of the present day, in the course of which it makes some statements which seem to us to be utterly without foundation, either in reason or revelation. The popular view of this subject has always seemed to us to involve some great absurdities, and to give rise to many queries, for which there seems to be no reasonable answer. Two or three of these we can hardly forbear noticing.
For example, the Independent quotes, in support of this view, 2 Cor. 5:1: “For we know that if our earthly house of this tabernacle were dissolved, we have a building of God, an house not made with hands, eternal in the heavens.” For the popular doctrine of the nature of man, this is considered a strong text; but the query arises, What is meant by this “building of God,” or “house not made with hands,” which is reserved in the heavens? Popular theology very complacently appropriates this text so far as it seems to relate to what happens at death, but ignores that part of it which relates to this condition afterward. Does it teach that the soul, after leaving the “earthly house of this tabernacle,” and entering the realms above, is given another “house” to inhabit, as this and the next verses would in that case intimate?—Not at all; it simply lives there as a disembodied spirit. For this “house which is from heaven” it does not try to account. If this text proves anything in support of the popular view, it proves too much.
Again the statement is made: “We must not trace the existence of the mind to the body, or make it dependent upon the body.” That such an idea as this should ever have found its way into the belief of civilized and enlightened people, we could never comprehend; for every one knows, when not arguing to support a theological dogma, that the mind is dependent upon the body, and that to a very large extent. It is all very well to make such an assertion upon paper in the editorial sanctum, or from the eminence of the popular church pulpit; but it would be a fatal step for the young physician passing medical examination, or for the scientist who cared anything about his reputation. There is hardly a person upon the face of the earth who does not demonstrate its falsity every twenty-four hours. When the body is affected, the mind is affected, and vice versa. When the body is filled with rum, the mind is stupefied; when it is dyspeptic, the mind is filled with morbid fancies. Diseases of various kinds leave it unsound. A stunning blow upon the head instantly paralyzes it; and in a thousand and one other familiar ways the mind shows its close dependence upon the body, in every way in which it is possible to be dependent.
Take, for example, the condition of man in a sound sleep. What happens to the immortal soul, the really conscious, intelligent part of man, which is not at all dependent upon the body, during this time? Does it continue its thinking, and all its actions, the same as at any other time?—Oh, no; it is dormant, wholly unconscious, without a thought or emotion of any kind. What a strange thing this is! The body goes off to sleep, and immediately the mind, which is a separate thing and not dependent upon it, is blotted out of existence! Or is it the mind that goes to sleep, in order that the body may have rest and be recuperated? Claim what we will about this, there is a period in every few hours of every man’s life when neither the body, the immortal soul, the undying spirit, or any other part of man, real or imaginary, knows anything whatever. Why does it not know anything?—Because part of the functions of the body have been suspended. But when death suspends all the functions of the body, behold, the mind is not affected in the least! In the full, active possession of all its powers, it soars away to the realms of glory above; or (fearful alternative)!—“With shuddering horror pale and eyes aghast”—takes its place in the fiery abode of the damned. So says popular theology. Of the small gnats of error we doubtless absorb our share; but for the swallowing of such camel-like absurdities, our minds have not, and we presume never will have, sufficient gullibility.
After such a statement as that the mind is not dependent upon the body, it is with no surprise that we read further that “we must not make thought a mere secretion of the brain, and consequently terminate its career with the destruction of the brain.” No; not, it is said, unless we would deprive ourselves of all the comforts and consolations of the Bible. But the trouble is that, according to this, the Bible does this work itself; for no language could be more explicit than that which it utters upon this very point: “His breath goeth forth, he returneth to his earth; in that very day his thoughts perish.” Ps. 146:4. What is it that thinks?—The mind, of course; or, as it is said, the never-dying soul. This is the only thing about man that does think; therefore, when a man’s thoughts perish at death, the part affected by this result is the mind. So, then, according to the Bible, the immortal soul, whatever else it may have, has no thoughts after the death of the body. Yet this doctrine of the immortal soul, which lives on after death, is, we are told, the source from whence we are to derive a large amount of comfort. We are perfectly willing to resign to others our share of whatever consolation there is in the anticipation of such a future state of existence, either for ourselves or for our friends.
Just what the steps are which take place in the transition from one state to the other—from life to death, or vice versa—is very clearly set forth in the 37th chapter of Ezekiel. The prophet there narrates his remarkable vision of the valley of dry bones, and the raising again to life of the great multitude who had fallen in that place. The valley, as the prophet tells us, was full of bones, which were very dry. The immortal souls had doubtless long since departed from the bodies which they represented, and were then in different portions of the spirit world,—some in the realms of endless joy, others in the abyss of torment. The prophet was directed to prophesy unto these bones: “Again he said unto me, Prophesy upon these bones, and say unto them, O ye dry bones, hear the word of the Lord. Thus saith the Lord God unto these bones; Behold, I will cause breath to enter into you, and ye shall live. And I will lay sinews upon you, and will bring up flesh upon you, and cover you with skin, and put breath in you, and ye shall live; and ye shall know that I am the Lord.” The prophet prophesied as directed, and proceeds to tell what happened: “So I prophesied as I was commanded: and as I prophesied, there was a noise, and behold a shaking, and the bones came together, bone to his bone. And when I beheld, lo, the sinews and the flesh came up upon them, and the skin covered them above: but there was no breath in them.”
At this point one great step of the process is represented as completed; the elements composing one part of the man had been brought together and united. So far as this part of the man was concerned, the work was done. But they did not yet live, for “there was no breath in them.” They were in precisely the condition a dead person is in immediately after the breath has left his body. There remained then but one more step to the process, and that was to summon the immortal souls of this multitude from their abodes in the spirit world, to re-inhabit the bodies they had so long forsaken. But, lo! nothing of the kind was done. The prophet was simply told to “prophesy unto the wind,” “and say to the wind, Thus saith the Lord God; Come from the four winds, O breath, and breathe upon these slain, that they may live.” That was all. And the prophet says, “They lived, and stood up upon their feet, an exceeding great army.” Their immortal souls, then long inhabitants of the spirit world, were passed by in utter silence. This is the testimony of the Bible as to the elements which make up the living, organized human being. They are, the body, composed of bones, sinews, flesh, skin, etc.; and the breath, or that which composes “the four winds.” Put these together, and the man lives, without the need of any immortal soul or never-dying spirit.
We very much doubt whether there are, among civilized, enlightened people, any considerable number who really believe, deep down in their every-day hearts, this nonsense about man’s conscious, immortal soul. They may silently assent to the flowery statements of pulpit rhetoric, but they think of their lost friends as persons whom they have laid away in the grave, not as disembodied spirits. There is, indeed, one notable exception—Spiritualists—to whose doctrine the idea of natural immortality, when too persistently and ardently cherished, naturally and inevitably leads. To this and other dangerous errors does it lead, while it has not, on the other hand, any redeeming features. It rests upon no valid authority, human or divine. Viewed in the light of either reason or revelation, its appearance is the same; it is a theological hedgehog, bristling with absurdities.
L. A. S.