It is a rare and hopeful sight when we see a Roman Catholic of the standing and influence of Dr. McGlynn, pleading for freedom of conscience, even if to maintain it one has to brave the dungeon and the stake. This doctrine maintained would be the vindication of Protestantism, the defense of all the conflicts of the past three hundred years in behalf of religious liberty, and the knell of papal tyranny. But one of the results of the McGlynn controversy is to bring such sentiments before multitudes of Catholics, and they are received with tumultuous applause. It is surprising that any respectable Protestant journals should espouse the cause of the hierarchy, and justify the excommunication of McGlynn as some do. They say he was summoned to Rome and refused to go, and for his disobedience deserved to be punished; and Rome could do no less than to excommunicate him. But why deal simply with these later phases of the controversy? why not go back to the point which touches the real principle involved, and inquire what right the pope had to summon him to Rome at all, simply for expressing a political opinion in a foreign country? Here is where the mask begins to fall, revealing the lordly and boundless usurpations of the pontiff, sufficient, it would seem, to open the eyes of any Protestant; and here resistance becomes a duty which Dr. McGlynn very properly performed.
We are led to these thoughts by the report of a meeting recently held in the Academy of Music, New York, which was so fully attended that an overflow meeting was held in Irving Hall, from which also hundreds were turned away for lack of room. The Academy meeting was presided over by Gahan, of the Catholic Herald, who in his introductory remarks said:—
“‘We are here to-night to let Rome know that in matters political not one jot of our allegiance is rendered to any power or potentate, but in its entirety is given to the laws and Constitution of the United States. [Cheers.] All of you went to your several churches this morning. In not one church did any one dare stand up and read the decree of Michael Augustine Corrigan.’ [Hisses and cat calls.]”
“Dr. McGlynn was received with tumultuous applause. In the course of his speech, he said: ‘Our God is a merciful as well as a wise one. He will never condemn any being who follows the dictates of his conscience, even be that conscience an erring one. In obeying it, he is forever obeying the will of God, as a dogma of the Catholic faith and according to all Christian philosophy and teaching. The man who goes against his conscience sins against the Holy Ghost, and, despite the power of any authority, even the pope, if a man does or says anything in obedience to that power, if in so doing he goes against his conscience, he sins. Even if a high Roman tribunal summons a man before it for teaching the truth which he knows to exist, and if that tribunal should condemn his doctrines without giving him a trial, and command him to retract them, it is his duty before God to refuse to do so [cheers prolonged], and if it was in his power, as it one time was,—but, thank God! no longer is,—to imprison and martyr the truth in the persons of those who have read God’s word in nature before they have been able to see it,—should it summon him and command him to retract under the penalty of imprisonment or martyrdom, it is his duty to resist, and even be burned alive at the stake rather than commit the unpardonable sin against the Holy Ghost of declaring what his conscience believed to be false.’”
Beginning with political action, the principle runs inevitably into the precincts of religion, where it is equally entitled to a place, and will make itself felt there. And when it comes to the expression of so broad a claim for liberty of conscience as that to which Dr. McGlynn gives utterance above, it is all that the most earnest Protestant could desire.