AdventAI

“A SINNER IN THE CITY.”

By W. H. Littlejohn

From Review and Herald, Vol. 64, No. 33., August 16, 1887

In a recent number of the REVIEW there appeared a very exhaustive discussion of the vexed questions relating to the number of times that our Lord was anointed, and the identity of the person who performed that act. It is not our present purpose either to indorse or disapprove the conclusion reached. The differences of opinion entertained by scholars on this subject are so numerous, and have existed for so many centuries, that it is more than doubtful whether it is possible for an argument to be framed that would prove satisfactory to all the parties to the controversy. As it is not improbable, however, that discussion may serve to relieve the question of some of its embarrassments, it is desirable that it should be continued so long as facts and circumstances that will throw light upon the matter may be evolved. With this object in view, the subjoined quotation from Geikie’s “Life of Christ,” p. 661, is given:—

“On the early morning of Sunday, the tenth of Nisan—the Jewish Monday, therefore Jesus and the twelve left their hospitable shelter at Bethany, and passed out to the little valley beneath, with its clusters of fig, almond, and olive trees, soon to burst into leaf; and its evergreen palms. Somewhere near lay the larger village of Bethphage; like Bethany, so close to Jerusalem as to be reckoned in the Rabbinical law, a part of it.” (The italics are our own.)

The point that we wish to make is this: some of those who object to the theory that there was but one anointing, claim that the event of that character spoken of in Luke 7:36, 40 was performed by a woman who is styled “a sinner in the city,” and, therefore, could not have been in Bethany at the time, since the latter was but a small village. But if Mr. Geikie is correct in saying, as he does in the quotation cited above, that Bethany was a part of Jerusalem, the woman brought to view in the narrative of Luke might with propriety be said to be a woman in the city, i. e. Jerusalem, even though she resided at Bethany. In other words, if Mary Magdalene and Mary the sister of Lazarus were identical, the fact that the latter resided in Bethany and performed the anointing there, as some claim, would not have made it improper for Luke to style her “a sinner in the city,” since Bethany was in reality but a part of Jerusalem.

To the objection that in the seventh chapter of Luke the last city spoken of was Nain, and that it therefore must have been the one to which the evangelist alludes, it may be replied that there are twenty-four verses that intervene between the mention of Nain and the introduction of the account of the anointing,—a space so great that those acquainted with the habits of Luke as a writer would hesitate long before concluding that the events spoken of in verses 36–40 of necessity transpired at that city.

W. H. LITTLEJOHN.