The Chicago Inter Ocean, of Nov. 16, devotes a column and a half to a discussion of the above subject. The heading in this case is not inappropriate, as the discussion does not relate to the fixed seventh day, but to a period of weekly rest from labor on the part of the Jews, and them alone, which of course might be on the seventh day or any other day. The question of when this shall be, has been agitating Jewish circles in all parts of the land for a long time, and the present discussion consists of the opinions of the leading rabbis of Chicago, and some other Jewish leaders, upon the subject. For several years past there has been a growing tendency on the part of Jewish worshipers toward Sunday services, to the great detriment of Jewish regard for Saturday, until at the present time a large number, probably the majority, are openly in favor of transferring their period of weekly rest and worship to the first day of the week. As might be expected, however, this proposal meets with bitter opposition on the part of some, who realize that such a step will be nothing less than an open violation of the fourth precept of that law for which the Jews profess so great reverence. Among this number is Rabbi Sonnenschein, of St. Louis, one of the most noted rabbis of that city. The rapidly increasing tendency of the evil, it appears, has finally resulted in a formal challenge from Dr. Sonnenschein to Rabbi Hirsch, of Chicago, a leading advocate of Sunday worship, to discuss the question of the advisability of substituting that day in place of Saturday as the Jews’ rest-day. The terms of the challenge provide that if Dr. Hirsch shall convince the St. Louis rabbi, the latter shall declare himself in favor of the new movement; but if not, then the former shall cease to agitate the question further. The announcement has created a sensation in Jewish circles, and the discussion, if it takes place, will doubtless mark an era in the history of the new movement.
The preliminary discussion of the question, given in the Inter Ocean, is interesting to us as showing the extent to which the Sunday-Sabbath idea has already worked its way into the favor of leading men among the Jews, and forecasting the position which they as a body will occupy in reference to the proposed national Sunday Sabbath. The following are a few extracts showing the opinion of leading Jews in Chicago, as mentioned above. First is that of Mr. Julius Silversmith, editor of the Occident:—
The tendency of the reform movement in the United States is not particularly to translocate the Sabbath, but to bring about a day of rest, a day of worship, so that the younger generation may have the facilities for attending divine worship, and listening to a lecture, discourse, or sermon, and at the same time participate in the charitable work of the Jewish institutions as they exist to-day; receiving that natural training which is an inherent part of Judaism, and has been practiced by all our people from time immemorial. With regard to the keeping of the Sabbath day, the orthodox Jews will brook no abatement from it, because they believe that it is transmitted through revelation, and that that seventh day which they recognize as the Sabbath is holy to them, and that it is sacrilegious to celebrate on any other day. The time was when they thought that to transpose that day would be to acknowledge the supremacy of the Christian religion, to imitate the Unitarians and other sectarian beliefs; and Judaism, according to their beliefs, would not tolerate that. The modern idea of the Jews is one of unity with this nation, and, if possible, to conform to the national day of rest; to make all the younger Jewish people prefer to go on Sunday to divine services, like their neighbors of other creeds, who go to the Catholic, Presbyterian, and Baptist churches, in their temples, and listen to the expounding, and be taught in the principles of their religion.
In Chicago there are three temples where Sunday lectures and services are held: Sinai Congregation, Zion Congregation, and North Side Hebrew Congregation. In Cleveland there is the Tifereth Israel Congregation; in St. Louis there is the Shaare Emeth, and the Temple Israel; Baltimore has the Har Sinai; Philadelphia, the Keneseth Israel; New York, its Temple Bethel; and San Francisco, the Emanu-el Temple. All these places hold services or lectures on Sunday.
In the Chicago Sinai Congregation they have worshiped for sixteen years, and they have full houses. It is no renunciation of our faith, or detraction from our veneration for the Bible, that we keep holy the Sunday. It is because it is impracticable to worship on Saturday. Here I am, a business man. I have certain indebtednesses to pay, certain drafts to meet, railroad matters to look after. I am not dealing exclusively with Jews, and they can come in only on Saturday. I am compelled to deal with them, and, in consequence, it is impracticable to keep the Sabbath, because my business encroaches upon it. The Government says Sunday shall be the national day of rest. Now, as a class, we Jews claim that we can keep that national day just as well as any other day. There is nothing in the Jewish law—the decalogue—that prevents us from doing so. The intelligent masses of the Jews are willing to accept the national day of rest as a day of rest, to recognize it as a day set apart for religious devotion. Such is the modern tendency of the Jewish race in this country.
Mr. Julius Rosenthal, a well-known lawyer, said:—
I have read the special telegram from St. Louis concerning Rabbi Sonnenschein’s challenge in regard to the Hebrew Sabbath, which you just show me, and also read the long extract of Sonnenschein’s sermon in the St. Louis Globe Democrat of yesterday. Dr. Sonnenschein is nothing if not sensational. This time he is mistaken when he says “that he knew that he was about to utter things that would create a sensation.” These things are old, and the sensation is over long ago. Chicago has acted and solved the problem. Our true orthodox Jews of this city conscientiously keep and enjoy their Sabbath as a day of rest as of old, on Saturday, and nobody interferes with them. Of the non-orthodox Jews, a very, very large number conscientiously keep and enjoy their Sabbath, in the true Jewish sense, as a day of rest from business, on the day on which they can keep it, to wit, on Sunday; and they are not interfered with. They act upon the principle that the Sabbath was made for man, and not man for the Sabbath, and that the day is not of the essence. There are three congregations in this city, those of Dr. Hirsch, Dr. Norden,p. 729 and Dr. Stolz (Sinai Congregation, the North Side Hebrew Congregation, and Zion Congregation), who have regular Sunday services. Another portion of the non-orthodox Jews have not found their Sabbath, or day of rest, as yet, rejecting Sunday because it is Christian, and disregarding Saturday on account of business. This is the Sonnenschein class. They pretend a kind of Platonic love for Saturday as a Sabbath for others to keep, or cling to Saturday as the true Sabbath day by romanticism, or superstition, or early education, or hypocrisy; but never go so far as to keep it themselves. But they are not interfered with. Our Chicago principle is, “Fair play for everybody.” Among the Chicago Jews a sensation-monger in the pulpit would find no place. The burning question among the modern Jews is not whether they should have a Saturday Sabbath or a Sunday Sabbath, but how to have a Sabbath at all, be it on Saturday or Sunday. Uniformity is immaterial, and of the evil I have no doubt as to the outcome in America. The Jewish Sabbath will be observed on Sunday. True life will decide, and not dusty theology or scholasticism.
Mr. Godfrey Suydacker, of Sinai Congregation, gave his opinion very emphatically, as follows:—
There will never be a reversion to the Saturday as a day of Jewish worship. I belong to the Sinai Congregation, and I know there is a unanimity that is very decided amongst the members. Practically we are holding divine service every day. After the experience we have had, no one would like to return to the Saturday. I believe the Bible to be a historical book, compiled by the men who reflected the spirit of the times in which they lived, and it does not smack of sacrilege, nor is it any departure from its truths, to hold religious Jewish services on Sunday.
Mr. Lazarus Silverman represented the minority, who look upon the Sunday innovation more nearly as their forefathers would have viewed it. He said:—
All the people that divert the Jewish Sabbath to Sunday are not Jews any longer. According to the Bible, the Mosaic law, the seventh day is the day designated as the Sabbath. It has been kept up from the time it was commanded until this day by the Jewish nation. The heathen kept it, and the Christians kept it for 300 years, until finally it was changed by the Catholic Church for Sunday. Now there is no question about it that the Sabbath to be kept holy on Saturday is the true meaning of the Bible; and the people that pretend to be Jews must believe in the Mosaic law as the fundamental principle of Judaism, and in consequence they that divert the Sabbath are not Jews any longer. They may be just as good as other people,—there are just as good Unitarians as Protestants,—but so far as the Sabbath is concerned it is Saturday, not Sunday. The question of business cuts no figure whatever, but whenever a man weighs dollars and cents against religion, then it is a matter of conscience, and will have the first weight with him. It is immaterial what the opinion of Dr. Hirsch or Dr. Sonnenschein may be. Dr. Hirsch would like to keep up the Sabbath on Saturday, but his congregation would rather do business on Saturday, and observe Sunday because they do no business on that day.
It will be evident to the reader, from these extracts, that the National Reform party, in enforcing upon the country their universal Sunday Sabbath, are likely to meet with but little opposition from the Jews. The latter, so far as religious scruples are concerned, can keep the first-day Sabbath without any difficulty. Already many congregations hold regular Sunday services, and devote the seventh day to business, and it is not unlikely that by the time this proposed “reform” is ready to be enforced, the great majority of them will be in respect to Sunday worship just like the orthodox world around them. This will take away one of the strongest arguments now used by opposers of the Bible Sabbath, since the first day of the week, and not the seventh, will then have pre-eminent claim to the title of “the Jewish Sabbath.” For our part, if the Jews are determined to give up the seventh day, we think it would be no more than proper compensation that the Jewish Sabbath should hereafter fall on the first day of the week.
It seems to us not unlikely that this giving way on the part of the Jews to the innovations of a false Christianity, will be made to operate against those who cannot so easily accommodate their conscience to the demands of the pagan day of worship. In the minds of such men as are now pushing the National Reform scheme, observers of the seventh day, whether Jews, Baptists, or Adventists, are all in the same class, and they will not be likely to allow that one of these has any better conscience than another; and, the Jews having come into harmony with their plans, they will point to them and say, Why can you not do the same? The standard of the Jews will be made the standard for all. Thus the great enemy of the truth is preparing the way for his final attack upon those whom his artful delusions have failed to turn from their allegiance to the Most High. L. A. S.