AdventAI

THE GOD OF THE LIVING. MATT. 22 : 32.

By L. A. S.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 64, No. 46., November 22, 1887

AMONG the numerous Scripture passages which are popularly supposed to prove that the souls of the righteous dead continue to exist as living intelligences in paradise, none perhaps is quoted oftener or with greater assurance than Matt. 22 : 32: “I am the God of Abraham, and the God of Isaac, and the God of Jacob. God is not the God of the dead, but of the living.” The last clause of this verse is seized upon, independent of the connection in which it occurs, and people reason that if God is the God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob, and is God only of the living, these three ancient worthies must be in the land of the living. Let us see, by a brief examination, if the text proves this.

The words here used are the words of Christ, spoken to the Sadducees on a certain occasion when they had attempted to entangle him concerning one of the doctrines which he preached—that of the resurrection. A step which very many persons seem to overlook, in searching for the meaning of a particular portion of Scripture, is to first clearly settle the question, What is the writer trying to prove? Who is he talking to? and what is he talking about? From the reasoning of our orthodox friends the natural conclusion would be that the subject under discussion was whether or not the soul continued its conscious existence after death. This point did not enter into the discussion at all. The preceding verse shows that this language is spoken, not as touching the present nature of man, but “as touching the resurrection of the dead.” The Sadducees did not believe there was to be any resurrection, and Christ was trying to prove to them that there would be a resurrection. Did he then start out to prove this, and, forgetting all about the point in question, go to work to prove something entirely different? He did, according to the popular orthodox view. He set out to convince the Sadducees of the resurrection, and immediately proceeded to show that the dead are already alive in heaven! Very remarkable proof they would have thought it. If the Sadducees had understood the language of Christ to mean what our orthodox friends now say it means, the Pharisees would never have heard that he had put the Sadducees to silence.

The popular style of reasoning on this subject, in condensed form amounts to this:—

God is not the God of the dead, but of the living; Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob (i. e., their souls) are now living; Therefore there is to be a resurrection of the dead!

This is too absurd to need any comment, yet we challenge any one to put Christ’s reasoning into a different form, consistent with the popular view, or to show how, according to this view, Christ proved to the Sadducees what he sought to prove.

According to the other view, however, that the dead simply sleep unconscious in their graves, the reasoning of Christ to the Sadducees is condensed as follows:—

God is not the God of the dead, but of the living; Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob are now dead; Therefore Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob are to live again; i. e., there will be a resurrection.

This is logical and consistent, and the Sadducees so understood it, as is evidenced by the fact that they were put to silence. L. A. S.