DISCUSSION IN BOONE CO., ARK.
By J. G. Wood
Last September, at the close of a tent meeting which I held on Gaither Mountain, in Boone county, Ark., I was pressed by Elds. Wm. Harris and J. N. Kerns, for a public discussion on the Sabbath question and other points of difference between us. As soon as the arrangements were made, Eld. H. wrote to prominent lawyers at Harrison, the county seat, asking them two important questions (requesting an immediate reply), the first being based on the word “fulfill.” Matt. 5:17:— Ques. 1.—“To fulfill a law is to do what?” Ans.—“To render obedience to all its requirements.” Ques. 2.—“What virtue, power, or force has a law where the penalty is taken off?” Ans.—“Organic or fundamental laws do not have penalties affixed, but are the basis of legislation, to which legislation penalties may be affixed, and may be made or changed at the will of the legislature. A law based upon, or growing out of, a fundamental law, without a penalty is no law at all. “Next to the ten commandments, the Constitution of the United States has been and is regarded by jurists as a master embodiment of fundamental or organic law.” These important decisions were based upon the writings of Blackstone, and were signed by two of Harrison’s best lawyers, Samuel Murphey and G. E. Burney. The discussion was a complete triumph in favor of the positions on the Sabbath and kingdom questions as held by S. D. Adventists. A gentleman at Harrison, whose mind the Lord had favorably impressed with his truth, seeing the above questions and answers in the lawyers’ hands, copied and brought the same to me, in good time to clearly refute Eld. Kern’s position, namely, that “to fulfill is to abolish and do away”; also, that “no law without a penalty is binding,” it being an answer to their own questions. The gentleman who thus favored me, in writing to the Harrison Times of Sept. 10, concerning the debate, makes the following statements:— The main point of difference was the day we should observe as the Sabbath. The first question was stated as follows: “Do the Scriptures teach that the seventh day, commonly called Saturday, is the Christian Sabbath, and binding in this dispensation?” Eld. Wood affirmed, Eld. Kerns denied. It was the opinion of nearly all present that Eld. Wood sustained his position by an abundance of testimony from the Bible. In his summary of fifteen minutes, he gave forty-five proof-texts.766 . . . He closed by saying that there can be no Christian Sabbath except the one that Christ kept, for “Christian” means Christ-like. Eld. Kerns, taking the headache, was not able to go further in the discussion, so Eld. Harris took his place. The next question was, “Do the Scriptures teach that the first day of the week, commonly called Sunday, is the Christian Sabbath, and binding in this dispensation?” Eld. Harris affirmed, Eld. Wood denied. They took the Protestant guide,—the Bible and the Bible alone,—and it was found uncomfortably silent on the Sunday Sabbath. Several took their stand for the Bible Sabbath, and I learn that others have since taken hold, and that the work is progressing. J. G. WOOD.