A THOUSAND YEARS APART

8%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Jan 10, 1888

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 65, No. 2.

Read the full edition

A THOUSAND YEARS APART.

IN THE REVIEW, Vol. 64, No. 31, we offered some criticisms upon an article written by Eld. J. W. Morton, to controvert our views on the subject of the sanctuary. To this he has replied in a pamphlet of 32 pages, 14 of which are devoted to this subject. It has been, and still is, our purpose to notice some of the misapprehensions under which Mr. M. still labors in reference to our position. We shall, however, at this writing take time to notice only one point, introduced in a “Note” on the last page of his pamphlet. He says:—
Though it is outside of my subject, I cannot forbear calling attention to a remarkable discrepancy between Mr. Smith and Mrs. White. The latter teaches, in the closing chapter of her “Great Controversy,” that the wicked dead, then lying unconscious in their graves, will be judged by Christ and the glorified saints, during the “thousand years” that shall follow his second coming, and that then they shall be raised from the dead and utterly destroyed. The former says that “when Christ appears,” the righteous and the wicked, “in a moment, in the twinkling of an eye,” shall be divided, and that, in the same moment, the righteous shall be “made immortal and the wicked given over to destruction.” Who can reconcile these clear and unequivocal, but contradictory, statements? Truly, the Prophetess and the denominational Editor are “a good way—at least a thousand years—apart.”
That is true; we were just about a thousand years apart, and Mr. M. labors hard to find a contradiction between us, by strangely representing that we speak of one and the same time. The wicked living on the earth at the time Christ appears, at the commencement of the thousand years, are surely a different company from the entire multitude of the wicked who will be raised from the dead at the end of the thousand years, most of whom will be in their graves at the second advent. When we speak of the righteous being changed in a moment, in the twinkling of an eye, at the appearing of Christ, and the wicked being given over to destruction, we refer only to the righteous and wicked who will be alive on the earth at that time; and it never occurred to us that it was possible for any one to misapprehend that point, and think that we referred to the company who come up in the second resurrection, a thousand years later.
Having made this distinction, which we trust all will now understand, let us look at the events which take place at the second coming of Christ. Before some of the circumstances which here appear, every system of theology must stand confounded and dumb which does not provide a place for a preliminary or investigative Judgment before Christ appears.
In 1 Cor. 15:51, 52, the apostle says: “Behold, I show you a mystery: We shall not all sleep, but we shall all be changed, in a moment, in the twinkling of an eye, at the last trump: for the trumpet shall sound, and the dead shall be raised incorruptible, and we shall be changed.” In verses 53 and 54, he goes on to explain what this change is: it is the exchange of corruption for incorruption, and mortality for immortality, so far as our physical bodies are concerned. This is made certain by what the same apostle writes to the Philippians (3:20, 21): “For our conversation is in heaven; from whence also we look for the Saviour, the Lord Jesus Christ; who shall change our vile body, that it may be fashioned like unto his glorious body, according to the working whereby he is able even to subdue all things unto himself.”
But we do not know but some may deny that the time of the last trump, spoken of in Corinthians, is the time of the second coming of Christ. If there are any such, we invite them to read 1 Thess. 4:16, which inseparably connects the coming of the Lord with the general resurrection of the righteous dead: “For the Lord himself shall descend from heaven with a shout, with the voice of the archangel, and with the trump of God: and the dead in Christ shall rise first.”
From these plain unequivocal declarations of Scripture, these facts appear; namely, 1. Not all of the church were to “fall asleep,” or die; a remnant would be living on the earth when the time should come for the Lord to return to this earth for his people; 2. Accompanied by the all-penetrating notes of the last trump, and the voice of the archangel, the Son of God appears at his second advent to this world; 3. Then these righteous persons who are living and looking for him (Heb. 9:28), do not go down into the grave at all, but are changed from corruptible to incorruptible, from mortality to immortality, having their bodies fashioned like unto the glorious body of their Lord; 4. At the same time all who are sleeping in the grave, who have “died in the Lord,” and who are “the dead in Christ,” are singled out from the great multitude of the dead, and raised incorruptible; 5. This change upon the living righteous takes place instantaneously, “in a moment, in the twinkling of an eye,” and immediately in connection therewith, the righteous dead are raised.
It will be seen that the final line is here drawn between the righteous and the wicked; the two classes are separated and set apart respectively to their eternal destiny. Now we submit it to any man to tell us if this is not a part of the judgment which is to pass upon all men, and if all such decisions are not based upon an examination of the records of the deeds done in the body. Dan. 7:10; 2 Cor. 5:10; Rev. 20:12. Then we ask further if any such work of investigation of character and decision of cases is brought to view in connection with the second advent; and is there a moment of time allotted for any such work? Every one knows there is not. Then another question inevitably follows; namely, When did the investigation and decision, inseparable from this bestowal of immortality, take place? Christ appears, and in the twinkling of an eye every righteous person alive upon the earth receives the stamp of immortality, and is set apart for eternal life. When was this decision made in their cases, and they accounted worthy to receive this boon? And without any special lapse of time after Christ appears, at any rate without any Judgment work in connection with his coming, touching their cases, all the righteous dead are raised incorruptible, receiving, like the righteous living, the stamp of immortality. With reference to these also, we raise the question, When was the decision made in their cases, and they accounted worthy of a part in the first resurrection?
To this question we shall insist upon an answer. When Christ appears, these great results instantaneously appear subsequently to that event—all the righteous living are changed to immortality, and all the righteous dead are raised. When were these classes so far judged that they were set apart to this blessing of immortality? It must have been before the appearing of Christ. This conclusion is absolutely inevitable. Now let any system of theology which does not have any place for any part of the Judgment before Christ appears, as Mr. Morton’s does not, wrestle with this problem. We say there is a beautiful and harmonious solution of the matter furnished us in the Scriptures, but it is only in connection with the subject of the sanctuary, which brings out in clear light the fact that the last work of Christ as priest is to confess to his Father the names of all those who have accepted of him as their Saviour, before he comes with “his reward with him, to give every man according as his work shall be” (Rev. 3:3; 22:12), to confer upon them the gift of immortality.
In our former article we used the expression respecting the wicked that they were “given over to destruction,” when the righteous were made immortal. Mr. M. construes this so as to make us say that the wicked are destroyed in a moment, in the twinkling of an eye. No fair construction of the language would lead to any such conclusion. To be “given over to destruction,” and to be “destroyed,” are two things. Look at the situation: here is the world teeming with population when Christ appears. Some are to be saved, the remainder to be destroyed. Rev. 19:20, 21. He comes, and in a moment, in the twinkling of an eye, all who are to be saved out of this mass of living beings are changed to immortality. When this is done for the righteous, what does it just the same instant declare for the wicked?—It declares that they are lost; their fate is sealed; they are given over to destruction. In due process of time their destruction follows (but that is only the cutting off of this mortal life), and they take their place with the other wicked dead who are not to live for a thousand years. Rev. 20:5. During this time the saints, in conjunction with Christ (Rev. 20:4; 1 Cor. 6:2), examine their cases, not to determine whether they shall be saved or not (that question being already settled), but to determine the amount of punishment which will be proportioned to their guilt. This being determined they are brought up from the dead to confront the record of their lives, and to die, not this time in Adam but for their own individual sins, receiving indignation and wrath, tribulation and anguish, according to their deeds written in the books. Rom. 2:8, 9; Rev. 20:12. This is the view we have always held and maintained; such is also the view taught by sister White; and the “editor” and the “prophetess” are in the most complete accord.
It would save a good deal of confusion on the subject of the Judgment, if men would remember that the trial through which we are passing for eternal life is conducted with as much wisdom as trials in earthly courts. Here we have the investigation, the decision, and the execution. So in the divine Judgment, there is the same order: examination is had, decision is rendered, and the sentence is executed. But in the divine Judgment these several particulars appear in two stages. First, there is an investigation to determine how many have accepted the work of Christ. This must be determined before Christ’s priesthood ends, for it is a part of that work, and is his closing work in that office. This determines the number of the saved; and up to this point the sentence is then executed, by Christ’s coming to reward every man as his work shall be; that is, to take to himself and crown with immortality those who have been decided to be his, leaving all others to be food for the second death. The saints having now themselves passed the test, are made associate judges (Rev. 20:4), and another period of investigation, or judicial examination, follows, in which all cases are reviewed, to apportion the amount of reward due to the righteous, and the amount of punishment due to the wicked. The sentences here rendered are executed at the end of the thousand years, when the wicked perish in the lake of fire (Rev. 20:14, 15), and the righteous enter upon their full reward, hearing from Christ the words, “Come, ye blessed of my Father, inherit the kingdom prepared for you from the foundation of the world.” Matt. 25:34.
Then the great work and the great period of the Judgment are completed. With the view here presented, we find a place for everything and all the parts come in consistently and in order. With any other view unsolvable problems meet us at every turn, and the subject is lost in chaos and confusion.