Joseph Benson on the Soul.
By N. J. Bowers
I HAVE in my possession an old volume printed sixty-three years ago, and which belonged to my grandfather. It is entitled, “Memoirs of the Rev. Joseph Benson,” by the Rev. James McDonald. Mr. Benson was one of the early Methodist preachers in England, and was contemporary with Mr. Wesley. He is the author of Benson’s Commentaries on the Bible, and his abilities, both natural and acquired, seem to have been more than ordinary. He was a staunch believer in the immortality of the soul, as the “Memoirs” plainly show, yet he and his biographer, the Rev. James McDonald, confess that there are some stubborn difficulties attaching to the subject, enough so, indeed, to cause one to well doubt the truth of this popular doctrine. Mr. B. seemed perplexed as he looked at the subject in the light of common facts, yet he clung to the dogma notwithstanding. He says:— I have employed some time this week in perusing Drew’s book on the soul. The reasoning is close and, in general, conclusive. But two great difficulties stand in the way: 1. Have we not our souls by traduction? and if so, are they necessarily immaterial and immortal, and incapable of dying? [Italics his.] Does not their immortality depend on the sovereign will and pleasure of God? 2. Have not the brutes perception, memory, a will, and passions? [Italics his.] Have they, therefore, in them an immaterial and immortal spirit? [He then adds.] The declarations of Scripture are of more weight with me than any philosophical or abstract reasoning I ever saw on the subject.—Page 252. We learn from the above some of the perplexing things Mr. B. encountered in believing in the immortality of the soul. Two great difficulties stood in his way:— 1. Our souls are transmitted. How, then, can they be incapable of death? “That which is born of the flesh is flesh,” says our Saviour. This being true, how can the soul be immortal? Physical peculiarities “run in the family,” and so do mental. If mental bent and bias are of descent,—and they undoubtedly are, as they develop and manifest themselves as physical development progresses from childhood to maturity,—then certain it is that the human mind is subject to physical conditions, and so, not immortal. 2. The lower animal possesses perception (“cognizance by the senses or intellect.”—Webster), memory, power to will, etc. These faculties, we are told, prove immortality in man. If so, they prove the same in brutes. The learned Bishop Warburton, of England, long ago said:— I think it may be strictly demonstrated that man has an immaterial soul; but then, the same arguments which prove that, prove, likewise, that the souls of all living animals are immaterial. If, then, the human soul being immaterial is immortal, and the Bishop thinks it can be “strictly demonstrated” that it is, beasts as well as ourselves have immortal and never-dying souls, and so there must be a beast hereafter, a beast paradise! Just imagine the “spirit-land” peopled with bugs, “woolly bears” and porcupines! Mr. B. gives us to understand that the Scriptures only can instruct us certainly as to the nature of the soul; and this is true. We there get full information regarding this subject. We there read that the soul can be killed (Josh. 11:11); that it can die (Eze. 18:4, 20; Num. 23:10, margin; Jud. 16:30, margin); that it can be torn in pieces (Ps. 7:1, 2); that it can be strangled (Job 7:15); that it can expire (Job 31:39, margin); that it can go into the grave (Ps. 49:15; 89:48); and that it can with the body be destroyed in hell at last. Matt. 10:28. Surely, according to all this, the soul is not immortal.