A REFORM WHICH IS NO REFORM

33%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Feb 7, 1888

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 65, No. 6.

Read the full edition

A REFORM WHICH IS NO REFORM.

THE so-called friends of temperance who advocate “high license,” have a very curious idea of what constitutes temperance reform. If prohibition cannot be had, and they are always of the opinion that it cannot, we ought, they say, to take the “next best thing,” by which they mean high license. This class of self-styled temperance “reformers” have just two arguments, which they are never tired of sounding. One is, “It brings in a large revenue.” This argument has become attenuated to the last degree, and scarcely any one now has any difficulty in seeing through it. All that was necessary to render it transparent was to make clear where this “large revenue,” which “reduced taxes,” etc., came from—that it proceeded from the pockets of the drinking classes, who not only had to pay that, but enough more to support the saloons. The second argument, viz., “It reduces the number of the saloons,” seems to have generally escaped comment, though its density is even less than that of the first argument. It rests upon a false assumption; namely, that a reduction in the number of saloons is equivalent to progress in temperance reform. High license does reduce the numerical importance of the saloon, but it does not decrease its power. A glance at the subject makes this evident. Suppose the number of saloons in a place which adopts high license to be reduced thereby one half, or even more than this. What is the result? Simply that the remaining one half or one fourth, whichever it may be, has one half or three fourths of the former number less to compete with, and can consequently well afford to pay as a license an amount which very likely comes far short of the gain which they derive from a restricted number of competitors. And the more the number is reduced, the better the business becomes for the remainder.
And how does the reduction of the saloon numerically by high license, affect the drinking classes themselves? Because one saloon has been closed by means of high license, does it therefore follow that the lover of strong drink will refrain from going to another saloon, or that he will drink any less than formerly? Has strong drink no greater hold than this upon its victims? Possibly an advocate of high license would claim this, but no one else would be so foolish. Advocates of high license are continually pointing to statistics showing great reductions in the number of saloons, but there is one kind of statistics which, so far as we know, they have never attempted to compile, perhaps because they did not care to; namely, statistics showing how far high license has decreased the amount of drunkenness. When a few such statistics have been carefully compiled and made public, it is probable that this next-best-thing argument will have a more secluded place in the public press. L. A. S.