SOLUTION OF THE SUNDAY AND SABBATH QUESTION

5%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Aug 28, 1888

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 65, No. 35.

Read the full edition

SOLUTION OF THE SUNDAY AND SABBATH QUESTION.

BY ELD. J. O. MATTESON.
(Concluded.)
On pages 32 and 33 in his book, the Bishop shows further how the Sunday, in the fifth century, was made holy, and more strictly enforced:—
In the laws of the States, we find from this time the prohibitions against work on Sunday constantly further and further enforced by penalties which become more and more severe, and thus it was kept more and more strictly. Alongside these laws, we also find a new theory concerning Sunday. It is the doctrine which so often was rejected in the ancient church, that the Christian practice of keeping Sunday holy is founded on the keeping of the Sabbath which was ordained through Moses. Yet it does not appear that this doctrine, to the close of the sixth century, had become a definite church dogma.
The Bishop closes this branch of the subject with the following true and memorable words, found on page 37:—
If we now connect together what we find in the history concerning the origin and development of the doctrine of Sunday, it amounts to this: it is not the apostles, neither the first Christians, neither the ancient church councils, which have given unto the Sunday the name and stamp of Sabbath; but it is the church and scholastic teachers of the Middle Ages.
At last we will quote the first three paragraphs of what the Bishop says we can learn from this historical survey, page 47:—
We learn: 1. That Sunday is not the Sabbath of the Old Testament, and that it was not the common belief in the Christian church, but rather a misunderstanding, that the Sabbath was brought over from the seventh to the first day of the week.
2. That Sunday-keeping, by rest from labor and by divine service, is not by the most renowned ancient Fathers founded on the law of the Sabbath in the Old Testament; nor do we find that any reference to the law of the Sabbath in the Old Testament, is adopted into the confession of the church before the sixth century after Christ.
3. That Sunday-keeping is commanded in the third commandment, and that the essential and enduring in this commandment is an instruction from God, that one day in the week must be kept holy,—all this is a doctrine which has originated in the papal church.
All that is said about keeping Sunday as a memorial of the resurrection of Christ, is indeed an empty sound, when we consider that it has no foundation in the word of God, and that the estimation Sunday has obtained rests upon the civil law and the authorities of different States. Christ himself has given us a memorial of his death, burial, and resurrection, and those who use this memorial properly have no use for a production of human origin. This memorial is baptism. Rom. 6:3–5. We will now show from the confessional books of the Lutheran church how empty every doctrine is, which is not founded directly upon the word of God.
No man has a right to abrogate a duty which rests upon a divine commandment.—Augsb. Conf., Art. 27, Sec. 5.
Thus also Christ himself says (Matt. 15:14) of those who request us to obey the commandments of men: “Let them alone; they are blind leaders of the blind,” and Christ rejects such worship, saying, “Every plant, which my heavenly Father hath not planted, shall be rooted up.”—Id., Sec. 14.
Some assert that Sunday-keeping may not be a divine institution, but that it nevertheless is as good as a divine institution. They give rules concerning holidays, and how far it is lawful to work on them. What are such assertions, but snares to our consciences?—Id., Sec. 20.
In order that it may not appear that they themselves are abrogating the commandments of God, they say that the Scripture has repealed the Sabbath, and point to Col. 2:16, 17, where the apostle speaks of Sabbaths which are a shadow of Christ. If any one will take pains to read Lev. 23:27, 32, 37, 38, he may see plainly what kind of sabbaths they had in the old covenant that foreshadowed Christ; they were yearly,—days of atonement or days for sacrifice,—and there is a plain distinction made between them and the Sabbath of the Lord. It is also very unreasonable to understand Paul in such a way that his testimony contradicts Christ and his own statement in other places. The apostle declares plainly that the law is placed in the New Testament to convince men of sin, and that this law is the ten commandments. “I had not known lust, except the law had said, Thou shalt not covet.” Rom. 7:7. He declares that the Christian faith does not make void the law. Rom. 3:31. And Jesus testifies, that “it is easier for heaven and earth to pass, than one tittle of the law to fail.” Luke 16:17.
Melanchthon writes in the apology of the “Augsburg Confession,” Art. 3, Sec. 2:—
These and similar testimonies prove that the fulfilling of the law must begin, and more and more be practiced in us. Yet we do not here speak of the ceremonial law, but that law the commandments of which are directed to the feelings of the heart; viz., the ten commandments.
It is undeniable that the word of God alone can dictate articles of faith, and no one else, not even an angel.—Schmalk. Artikler, Art. 2, Sec. 8.
We believe, teach, and confess that the only rule and guide whereby all doctrines and teachers are to be judged, are the prophetic and apostolic writings in the Old and New Testaments.—Konkordienformelen, Introduction to “Kort Begreb,” Sec. 1.
Thus we see, not only from the Holy Scriptures, but also from the testimonies of the learned theologians themselves, 1. That Sunday-keeping is not founded upon the commandment or ordinance of God, and consequently is vain worship; 2. That the ten commandments, and consequently also the fourth, are firmly retained in the new covenant; and that no man has a right to do away with a duty which is directly founded in the commandment of God.