AdventAI

The Joanna Southcott Fraud Exploded.

By Editor

From Review and Herald, Vol. 65, No. 29., July 17, 1888

As our readers are well aware, a great effort has been made for some months past, in certain quarters, to smirch the cause of Sabbath reform at the present day, by associating it with the fanatical movement of Joanna Southcott, in the early part of the present century. It has been paraded before the public with great gusto, that she taught and practiced the observance of the seventh day as the Sabbath, and that her followers to the number of 100,000 were observers of the seventh day; that the remnant of this delusion had scarcely disappeared before the observance of the seventh day, was commenced by Adventists; that Sabbath-keeping is always associated with fanaticism; and that the present movement is destined to come to nought, as Miss Southcott’s did.

The story that she kept the seventh day was attributed to the Schaff-Herzog Encyclopedia, which makes that statement. We could not find a confirmation of that assertion in any other authorities, and felt morally certain that there must be some mistake in the matter; as it would be impossible for so large a company to arise, distinguished by so peculiar a feature as the observance of the seventh day, and that fact not be noticed by at least the majority of the writers who have described that work. S. D. Adventists as yet number less than 50,000, but who would not know from any description given of this work, by either friend or foe, that they kept the seventh day as the Sabbath?

As the statements above referred to were, however, calculated to exert some influence against our work, it was thought best that one of our brethren in London look the matter up, and ascertain the facts in the case. He has done so, and we are happy to submit herewith his report. He says:—

In looking up the Southcott matter, I have consulted all of the encyclopedias, and not a word is said of her keeping, or teaching the observance of the seventh day, save in the one exception, the Herzog. It seems rather surprising that the London encyclopedias should omit so important a testimony, if there were any foundation for it, and yet this work published in Germany announces that of which the English writers were unaware. I have looked through seven volumes of doggerel verse, dictated by Joanna to her scribe, as well as her prose works, written during the last fifteen years of her life, and not a word could I find referring to the Sabbath question, or even teaching any special ritual or service. But she, and others of her writers, condemn the world for the attention to forms, and inattention to the spiritual teachings of the Bible. In stating the principles and doctrines of the sect, not one of the writers say a word about the Sabbath, which would be singular, if she had taught any such doctrine as the Herzog supposes. The daily papers and the magazines and reviews of her time, have considerable to say of the doings of Joanna and her followers, and while reference is often made to Sunday services, and to various peculiarities of the sect, not a word do they say of seventh-day observance.

Kirby, in his “Museum of Eccentric Characters,” published shortly after the death of Joanna, says:—

“On Sunday, July 31, 1814, the Rev. Mr. Tozer asserted in the pulpit of Joanna’s chapel the following sentence, . . . and on Sunday, Aug. 28, 1814 (the day on which the whole of Joanna’s chapels closed), Mr. Tozer declared,” etc.

A pamphlet, written shortly before her death, called the “Remarkable Life of J. Southcott,” says:—

“She has a chapel in Duke St., near the obelisk, where they have preaching every Sunday, and afterward the liturgy of the Church of England is also read . . . They minister in the chapel the sacrament of the Lord’s supper the first Sunday in every month, and profess themselves members of the Church of England.”—H. Hann.

Johnson Grant, M. A., in writing a history of sects which have separated from the Establishment, says of the Southcottians: “Professing themselves members of the Church of England, they read the liturgy, and administer the sacrament once a month.” He wrote his history in 1814, just before her death. This must place it beyond all controversy that the idea that they kept the Sabbath is without foundation, only in rumor and imagination. But I might add two more notes. A daily paper shortly before her death told of a lady of rank who had ordered a font made for the child when it should be born, and says, “The same lady personally applied to a celebrated shoe-maker in Bond St., on Saturday last, and instructed him to make without delay a pair of white satin shoes.” At another time it is stated also that the cradle, which was made in the city, was removed on Saturday to the suburbs. Mrs. Jones, who has lived here all her life, and who had a chance to learn of affairs here in London through her father, Mr. Black, Pastor of the S. D. B. church of Millyard, London, told me the other day that it was entirely untrue that the Southcott followers kept the Sabbath, or taught it.

It thus appears that the statement that Miss Southcott and her followers kept the seventh day, is wholly without foundation, and the Schaff-Herzog Encyclopedia is convicted of a gross blunder in the matter. She never taught or observed the seventh day, nor enjoined it upon her followers. On the other hand, she was a Sunday observer and worshiper. But the statement above referred to by some means erroneously creeps into print, and the enemies of the Sabbath catch it up, and bandy it about with great delight. With such husks they are stuffing themselves, and behind such a refuge of lies they are trying to hide. We respectfully hand back Joanna Southcott and all her followers to her Sunday-keeping friends. She belongs on their side of the house, not on ours.