S. D. Adventist views have been so long before the world in one uniform line of teaching, that any variation from what have been considered established positions is sure to call forth numerous demands for an explanation.
Some variation in dates appears in the S. S. lesson of last week, and as a consequence, queries are pouring into this office, too numerous to be practically answered, otherwise than through the paper, asking why these changes are made. The date given to mark the division between Grecia and Rome, is B. C. 168, instead of B. C. 161, as heretofore taught; and the date to mark the division between Rome and the ten horns, is given as 476 A. D., instead of 483 A. D. The writer of the lessons of course conceived that there were good reasons for the changes—a necessity which, however, to us is not so apparent.
Take, for instance, the one first mentioned. The view presented by the prophet is the succession of kingdoms; and we would naturally look for each kingdom to continue till the succeeding kingdom appeared. With the first two kingdoms there can be no question; for the rise of Persia was simultaneous with the downfall of Babylon; and the rise of Grecia was simultaneous with the downfall of Persia. By one great event, as the overthrow of Belshazzar by Cyrus, B. C. 538, and the overthrow of Darius Codomannus by Alexander, B. C. 331, the entire dominion passed from one kingdom to another,—from Babylon to Persia, and from Persia to Grecia.
Not so, however, with respect to Grecia and Rome. The succession of Rome to Grecia was not instantaneous, but progressive. First, Macedon, one of the horns of the goat (Daniel 8), was conquered by Rome, B. C. 168; afterward Syria, another horn, was absorbed by Rome, B. C. 65; Judea was made a Roman province B. C. 63; and finally Egypt, the last horn of the Grecian goat, became a part of Rome, B. C. 30. Thus, as a matter of fact, the greater part of the old Grecian kingdom, continued for more than a hundred years after the conquest of Macedon by Rome. And while it is true that this event took place B. C. 168, and from a merely historical point of view, the contact of Rome with Grecia, would be marked by that year, we must remember that in the Scriptures these kingdoms are treated from a prophetic stand-point, and the prophecy would necessarily contemplate the Grecian kingdom as still existing (especially as only so small a fragment of it as Macedon had disappeared), till the next kingdom came into view. But Rome did not come into the field of vision till its connection with the people of God, by the famous league with the Jews, B. C. 161.
The conclusion is this: If we divorce the matter from the prophecy, and treat it in a purely historical sense, we could not say that the old Grecian kingdom had ended till its last independent province had been engulfed by Rome, which would not be 168, nor 161, but 30 B. C. But if we look at it from a prophetic stand-point, we cannot place the dividing line between Grecia and Rome at B. C. 168, because Rome had not then come into the prophecy. The year when it did come in, we may properly adopt as the date of the division between the two kingdoms; for from that point, Rome becomes the main theme of the prophecy. Therefore B. C. 161 is the only allowable date in the premises.
As to the other date, 476 A. D., there is more ground for difference of opinion. But these general propositions may be laid down in reference to it: 1. The ten kingdoms were to arise out of the Western Roman Empire; 2. After the ten kingdoms had arisen, there was no portion of the empire left; 3. While the empire might fall before the ten were developed, we cannot certainly look for the last of the ten kingdoms before the empire becomes extinct; but, 4. The date of the extinction of Western Rome is involved in some doubt. Gibbon says, “476 or 479. Extinction of the Western Empire.”—Rome, Vol. iii, chap. 36. (Chronological Table of Contents. There is a possibility, therefore, that the date cannot be placed earlier than 479. But the empire was certainly extinct before 483. This latter date, adopted by Bishop Lloyd, and followed by Adventists, may hence be set down as a safe one, with respect to the extinction of the Western Empire, and the development of the last of the ten horns, and not many years, at most, from correct. It is safe to say that all was accomplished by that date.