The Lost-Time Question

3%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Oct 23, 1888

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 65, No. 42.

Read the full edition

The Lost-Time Question.

BY LOYD J. CALDWELL.
Among the many excuses and pretexts for refusing to keep the seventh day, that of probable lost time stands prominent. A loss of time, somewhat general but not world-wide, would still preserve the week and the Sabbath. That a loss world-wide and permanent is utterly improbable, yes, utterly impossible, may easily be proved:—
1. The week and Sabbath were correctly kept up to and after the time of Christ’s resurrection. Luke 23:54–56; 24:1; Acts 16:13. Why expect and how prove that they have become permanently disarranged since?
2. If the week of one is wrong, the week of all is wrong; but all agree with each other,—including the Jews, who, all admit, were able to keep the week from Moses to Christ—why less able or unable since?
3. Millions and millions of time contracts are constantly falling due,—and always have been since the time of Christ. How could they all lose one or more days all at once sometime, and none know it, and such a loss never be repeated or corrected? Think of the dated traffic, law-suits, wars, etc., constantly going on. Were there no mortgages coming due then, or could such a Rip Van Winkle sleep come over money-lenders now?
4. Pagans for thousands of years kept the day of the sun, till Pope Sylvester christened it the “Lord’s Day,” and together with the Roman emperors, from Constantine, enforced it on the world as the successor of God’s Sabbath. Many have kept God’s Sabbath from Eden. How could both parties lose at once, and lose just as much?
5. The Sabbath could not be lost, except by losing the week (which none will claim), or by disarranging permanently the days of the week—a thing no man can prove ever happened to a single individual, much less the whole race of mankind.
6. But to record days and weeks is one of the earliest lessons of childhood, and one learned alike by all classes and conditions of mankind, from the cradle to the grave. Aside from one’s daily physical needs, there are perhaps no more universal facts.
7. But there is, if possible, still clearer proof. Whence came the week of seven days, if not from creation? and how marked off, save by a rest-day at its close? How came it to be so universal, from time immemorial, if not divine? What source so likely, what measure so fit, as this ever-recurring copy of the creation week, supported by divine command? Says La Place (next to Newton, the greatest of philosophers):—
The week is the most ancient and incontestable monument of human knowledge. It appears to point to a common source whence that knowledge proceeded.—Craft’s Sabbath for Man, pp. 328, 365.
It [the week] has been used from time immemorial in almost all Eastern countries, and as it forms neither an aliquot part of the year or of the lunar month (29½ days), those who reject the Mosaic recital, will be at a loss to assign to it, as Delambre remarks, an origin having much semblance of probability.—Encyclopedia Britannica, Art. “Calendar.”
To the ancient Chaldeo-Babylonians, we owe not only our division of time, but also the week of seven days, dedicated in succession to the sun, moon, and five planets—an arrangement still maintained. And more than all that, there were days set apart, and kept holy, as far back as the time of Sargon of Accade (about 3400 B. C.). There are, however, essential differences between the two [Hebrew and Chaldean Sabbaths]. In the first place, the Babylonians kept five Sabbath days each month, which made them more than one a week. In the second place, they came round on certain dates of each month, independently of the day of the week; on the 7th, 14th, 19th, 21st, and 28th.—Ragozin’s Chaldea, (Putnam’s edition), p. 230.
We find among all the ancient nations,—Chaldean, Persian, Hindu, Chinese, and Egyptian,—that the seven days of the week were in universal use, and each named the seven days, after the seven planets, including the sun and moon. We shall find the probabilities millions to one against its being an accident.—Planetary and Stellar Worlds, p. 7.
8. Let us hear the testimony of the languages. Eld. W. M. Jones, of London, a linguist long resident in the East, has published a “Chart of the Week,” giving the meaning of the word “week” and of each day, in 160 of the principal languages, ancient and modern. From it we learn the following: (1.) Every one,—Sanskrit, Babylonian, Egyptian, Chinese, etc.,—has a week of just seven days. (2.) One hundred and eight of the 160 languages call the seventh day, or Saturday, Sabbath, or some word indicating no work. (3.) But three call Sunday by any sacred name. (4.) Among those calling it the seventh day Sabbath are the ancient Persian, Arabic, Armenian, Turkish, as well as the later Italian, French, Spanish, German, Russian, etc.
9. The science of astronomy absolutely demonstrates that there has been no day lost since long before Christ,—which is more than is needed to destroy the objection.
Johnson’s Cyclopedia, Art. “La Place,” says:—
The earliest authentic observations of eclipses, made at Babylon in the years 719, 720, 721, B. C., show that they occurred 1¾ hours sooner than if the present mean motion of the moon then obtained. . . . At each lunation, she approaches nearer to the earth than during the last, by one fourteenth of an inch! . . . The revealing, after many years of study, of the source of the resulting discrepancy between astronomical tables and observation, is regarded as one of the proudest achievements of the author.
Now, if astronomers, by a study of eclipse-tables and observations, can detect a gain of but 105 minutes in 2600 years, what nonsense to talk of a possible loss of years, weeks, or even a day!
10. Again, see how easily astronomy detects and corrects errors in counting time! The Julian year (after Julius Cæsar, since 45 B. C.) counts 365¼ days for a year. The Gregorian, or true solar year (after Pope Gregory VIII., since 1582) has 365 days, 5 hours, 48 minutes, and 46 seconds; or eleven minutes shorter than the Julian year. Thus the Julian almanac would lag behind the sun and seasons three days in 400 years; or get ten days behind from A. D. 325 to 1582, when Gregory ordered it to be set right by commanding Oct. 5, 1582, to be dated Oct. 15, 1582, and the Gregorian year to be used thereafter. Catholic Europe obeyed at once; Protestant England and her colonies delayed until Parliament ordered Sept. 3, 1752, to be dated Sept. 14, 1752 (the Julian almanac being then eleven days behind the sun), and the Gregorian calendar to be followed. Greek Russia still uses the Julian almanac, which is now twelve days behind the sun, and our Gregorian, or true, almanac; and therefore while we all keep Christmas on the same calendar day (Dec. 25), Russia observes it Jan. 6! But Rome, England, and Russia alike count the same day for Sunday, Monday, etc., and always did! Thus does God preserve the week, by making it so simple that a child can measure it. Suppose the people had lost a few days now and then, would not the seasons tell the astronomers of it?
11. Astronomy is the oldest of sciences. It flourished under the clear skies and on the boundless plains of Chaldea and Egypt, thousands of years ago. Says a recent and able authority:—
The astronomers of ancient Mesopotamia . . . had succeeded, by their knowledge of the period of 223 lunations [moons], in predicting eclipses. The most ancient calculation of this kind,—that for March 10, 721 B. C.,—was made by them, and differs from ours by a few minutes only. . . . Thus we have seen two solar eclipses; those of July 2, 930 B. C. and June 13, 809 B. C. are mentioned on the monuments.—Le Normant and Chevallier’s Anc. Hist. of the East, pp. 316, 448–451.
Says the great Sir John Herschel, prince of astronomers:—
Remarkable eclipses, for instance, now that the lunar theory is thoroughly understood, can be calculated back for thousands of years, without the possibility of mistaking the day of their occurrence. And whenever any such eclipse is so interwoven with the account given by an ancient author of some historical event, as to indicate precisely the interval between the eclipse and the event, and at the same time to identify completely the eclipse, that date is recovered and fixed forever. This has been done in the case of four remarkable total eclipses of the sun: Thales, May 25, 585 B. C. (mentioned by Herodotus as predicted by Thales, and as causing the suspension of a battle between the Medes and Lydians, followed by a treaty of peace); Larissa, May 19, 557 B. C. (related by Xenophon as causing a panic among the Median defenders of that city, thus enabling the Persian besiegers to capture it); Agathocles, Aug. 15, 310 B. C. (witnessed near the southern part of Sicily by the fleet of Agathocles, in its escape from the Carthaginian blockade by Syracuse); Stiklestad, Aug. 31, 1030 A. D. Too recent for use.
Speaking of that of Larissa, Sir John says: “We are thus presented with a datum in those remote times, having all the precision of a most careful modern observation,” etc. Of Agathocles he says: “No other eclipse by possibility could have done so.”
Says one of the highest living authorities:—
In China the same idea has prevailed from time immemorial; and from the reign of Ta-tsong, 1100 B. C., a court astronomer has been regularly employed, whose business it has been to announce any approaching eclipse. The court then assembled (a custom even in our own day), the emperor solemnly beat a tambour, while the mandarins shot arrows into the sky, to assist the eclipsed luminary.—Sir John Lubbock, in Origin of Civilization, p. 231.
The following will explain itself:—
U. S. Naval Observatory, Washington, Jan. 31, 1883.
Mr. L. J. Caldwell, Battle Creek, Mich.
Sir: To the several questions in yours of the 23d inst., the following answers are returned:—
1. “Did not the ancient nations predict and record eclipses long before Christ?”—Yes.
2. “Is not the day of the week on which some of the most noted ones occurred, recorded?”—No.
3. “Have not modern astronomers retraced and identified some of them, even to the day of the week?”—Yes [as to identifying them], but not as to the day of the week, which could be, however, readily ascertained.
4. “Did the Julian or Gregorian corrections of the calendar disarrange the days of the week?”—No.
Very respectfully, R. S. Pythian, Superintendent.
But if time has been lost, how could astronomers predict, record, and retrace eclipses in all nations for thousands of years, without finding it out? How can one be expected to admit a “may be so,” in contradiction to science, history, and all individual experience? Not a scrap of reliable proof can be shown. Is not the “wish father to the thought,” since those who cannot find a definite day for the seventh day, can yet find one for the first? Selkirk, Kane, Livingstone, Magellan, etc., lost no time. Are we to believe that once on a time, all the world lost their wits?