High License Law Fails to Curb Drink Consumption
From recent investigations conducted in Philadelphia and Pittsburg, the territory most affected by the Brooks high license law of Pennsylvania, it would seem that high license is no success at all in restricting the consumption of intoxicating drink. Ardent advocates of this measure have pointed to the great reduction occasioned thereby in the saloons of those places (in Philadelphia, from 5,773 to 1,347; and in Allegheny County, from 2,185 to 525) as indicative of the great effectiveness of the law, but the evidence seems conclusive that the suppression of a large proportion of the saloons does not necessarily mean a proportionate reduction in the liquor trade. The Pittsburg Dispatch, which has been conducting the investigation, prints the following:— From a canvass of the breweries, the fact is evident that in Pittsburg, as well as in Philadelphia and other cities, the new law has not decreased their sales to any noticeable extent, but to many has been a boon, as in the case of the smaller breweries, which have built up an enormous trade in bottled beer and liquors for private consumption. This is not the kind of restriction which true temperance people desire. A decreased number of drinkers is wanted, not a decrease in the number of places where drink is sold. So long as the swollen river of intoxication continues to flow on undiminished, it matters but little whether the foul stream is made to issue from a large number of small channels, or a lesser number of big ones,—whether the liquor traffic is open to dealers of all classes, or whether a few are permitted to enjoy a monopoly of the trade. It seems safe to say, also, that if the Brooks high license law is a failure, as must be the case, if the above statements are correct, it is useless to expect the power of the liquor curse to be broken by any legislation which can be conducted upon the basis of high license.