THE CHRONOLOGICAL POSITION OF THE ATONEMENT.
Christ's work as priest is not all a work of atonement. While his work in general is that of intercession, pardon, and reconciliation, there is a portion of it which is specifically called “a work of atonement.” This is made certain by the services of the Levitical priesthood under the type. Let it ever be borne in mind that those priests “served unto the example and shadow of heavenly things” (Heb. 8:5); that is, unto the example and shadow of Christ's priesthood in heaven. But their work was not all a work of atonement. Their daily work was to receive the blood of those offerings which the people brought to be their propitiation, and perform therewith a ministry in the tabernacle, all of course with reference to a final work of atonement to be subsequently accomplished (Lev. 4:20); yet there was a particular time set apart in the year, and a specific work appointed, which were called, the “day of atonement,” and the work of atonement. “And this shall be an everlasting statute unto you, to make an atonement for the children of Israel for all their sins once a year.” Lev. 16:34. See verses 29-33, and chap. 23:27-32. This is the picture we have to teach us in regard to the work of Christ. They served unto the example and shadow of heavenly things. So we say that, according to this evidence, Christ must have a long general work to perform, and besides this, a comparatively short and specific ministry to accomplish, called, the making of the atonement. If this is not so, then less than one three hundred and sixty-fifth part of the work of the earthly priests was a shadow of Christ's work in heaven, and three hundred and sixty-four parts of it, out of three hundred and sixty-five, were a type and shadow of nothing. But Paul says that they “served [certainly more service than that indicated above] unto the example and shadow of heavenly things,” or the work of Christ in heaven. Now, in what portion of Christ's ministry is this work of atonement located? Does it occur at the commencement, in the middle, at the close, or where? We boldly aver that nearly all Christendom, losing sight of the great subject of the sanctuary, have gone astray on this point. Failing to distinguish between the slaying of the offering, and the making of the atonement, they have come generally to locate the latter at the time of the former, and assert that the atonement was made on the cross. Mr. Morton, in his essay against us on the sanctuary question, falls into substantially the same error; for although he does not have the atonement made upon the cross, he does have Christ enter the most holy place immediately on his ascension to heaven, and then and there make the atonement, before taking his seat on the right hand of the throne of the Majesty in the heavens. On this ground we objected to Mr. M.'s view, because it makes the atonement precede the other acts of Christ's priesthood. He accuses us of greatly misrepresenting him on this point. He says:— What I said was: “In the natural order of things the atonement preceded the session of Christ on the mediatorial throne.” Mr. S. ought to know that this is a very different statement from what he attributes to me. How did he come to make this misrepresentation? Was it a blunder? Or was it intentional? He surely knows that I hold that Christ's first priestly act, since his incarnation, was the offering of himself on the cross, and he must admit that this was prior to the atonement. And surely he will not say that his “sitting down on the mediatorial throne” was a priestly act. Will he undertake to give us a scholarly exegesis of Heb. 1:3 and 10:12, or of either of them, that will be consistent with his theory, that Christ's atonement was first made in 1844? Though I am no prophet, I venture to predict that he will not attempt to do so. We positively disclaim any “intentional” misrepresentation in replying to Mr. M.; and we do not plead guilty to even a “blunder.” We do not suppose that Mr. M. will deny that Christ is now, and has been ever since his ascension, our great High Priest above; that he has during all this time been doing a priestly work, pleading his blood in behalf of all who would come to him. But as he has the atonement made when Christ ascended to heaven, over 1800 years ago, he has the atonement precede all this priestly work, or stand at the beginning of this long ministry; whereas the Scriptures place the atonement as the close and not the beginning of his priesthood; and it was this service through all the Christian dispensation down to 1844 that we had in mind. So far as the real issue is concerned it matters not a particle whether we place the atonement on the cross, or forty-three days later, at the ascension. We showed in No. 17 that the crucifixion was not a part of Christ's work as priest; but suppose we grant with Mr. M. that it was, that Christ performed one priestly act before he made the atonement at his ascension, the whole objection, from our standpoint, still remains; for this atonement on this ground is followed by a long priestly service, which according to the type, and other scriptures is not possible. To illustrate: Let us suppose a young man leaves Battle Creek for Ann Arbor, there to take a four years' course of study in the University of Michigan, and then graduate. Now, it would not matter one whit whether his friends should claim that he graduated when he took the cars at Battle Creek, or that he graduated when he reached Ann Arbor. We know that the one statement is equally false with the other; for his graduation is not to come till he has completed his course of study. So with the ministry of Christ. The great work of atonement is the graduating service, if we may so express it, of his priesthood; that is, it is the closing part of it, and does not transpire till a long preceding work has been accomplished. On this point Mr. M., in his essay, objects, as follows:— Now, if Jesus, the only true priest, did not enter the holy of holies till 1844, it follows that the church and the world were left without any atonement for more than eighteen centuries! Not one drop of his blood was, during all those ages, sprinkled upon, or before the mercy-seat! For it could be offered only in the inner tabernacle where God resides. This is the plain teaching of the Levitical law, and is in full harmony with New Testament teaching. This objection is based on the idea that all Christ's work is the atonement. The church and the world don't need the atonement till the time for the atonement comes. But meanwhile they were not left without a sacrifice, without a priest, without the cleansing blood, and pardon of sin and reconciliation to God. During all the time previous to the antitypical work of atonement, the church and the world had just what Israel had through all the year previous to the day of atonement; that is, opportunity to come and confess their sins over their offerings, and through that blood and the ministration of the priest have them borne into the sanctuary, and so receive pardon for them. So ever since Christ entered upon his priesthood, every true penitent has secured pardon through him, and had his sins transferred to the sanctuary of which Christ is minister. In the type the daily service went on through the year, the sins accumulating all the while in the sanctuary. From these sins it must be cleansed. For this purpose the day of atonement with its special service was instituted. Then the high priest went into the most holy and sprinkled blood upon the mercy-seat, the only time he did so in all the year. By this means the sins were removed from the sanctuary, and the sanctuary was cleansed. That sins are thus treated as entities and transferred from one object to another, first from the sinner to the offering, then from the offering to the sanctuary, and from the sanctuary to the scape-goat in whom they perish, is plainly stated in Lev. 16:21. For as the concluding service of the year's ministry and the atonement, the record states: “And when he hath made an end of reconciling [cleansing] the holy place, and the tabernacle of the congregation, and the altar, he shall bring the live goat, and Aaron shall lay both his hands upon the head of the live goat, and confess over him all the iniquities of the children of Israel and all their transgressions in all their sins, PUTTING THEM upon the head of the goat, and shall send him away by the hand of a fit man into the wilderness.” Thus the sins of the entire nation which had accumulated during the year were disposed of, and we can easily trace them from inception to end. They first attached to the transgressors who committed them. Through the prescribed offerings they were transferred to the sanctuary, and by the services of the day of atonement they were removed from the sanctuary and placed upon the head of the scape-goat in whom they perished. Each year's work, in the type, was complete in itself ; and the same service was repeated year after year. Paul gives us the reason why the earthly ministration was divided up into such short periods. It was because those priests were not able to continue by reason of death (Heb. 7:28); and by making the length of a complete round of service one year, ordinarily the same priest would go through the entire service, and so the better typify Christ in the one round of service which he performs in the heavenly sanctuary. In Christ's ministry, the service does not need to be divided up into short periods, because he “ever liveth,” and hence, however long the period may be, he, as the deathless priest, is able to perform it all. Now, as each individual yearly round of service in the type, represented Christ's whole work as priest, who performs but one round of service, it follows that any distinct divisions of his work will occupy the same relative position in the period covered by his ministry, that the type of such division occupied in the aforesaid yearly typical service. And there were two such distinct parts: the common or daily service, and the atonement. And the atonement was the last and closing service; it completed the year; it finished the round of the representative ministry of these priests. Had it not been for the yearly repetition, after the atonement had been made no more sacrifices would have been offered; and when the atonement was made, and the sanctuary was cleansed, then the work immediately began again in the holy place, just as it had begun the year before. So in Christ's ministry; his work of real atonement, answering to the typical atonement, must be the very closing portion of his work as priest. It comes at the end not at the beginning of his ministry. To locate it in any other place is to utterly ignore this beautiful structure of the type, and do violence to many scriptures. Yet Mr. Morton has the atonement made when Christ ascended, and a long priestly work of over 1800 years following it! We leave the reader to contemplate the incongruity and unscripturalness of such a position. Though professing himself no prophet, Mr. M. ventures to predict that we will not attempt an exegesis of Heb. 1:3 and 10:12. We think it would have been better for him to stop with his disclaimer of being no prophet, rather than to venture forward as he has done, and prove himself a false one; for there is nothing in those texts to cause the least hesitation in the way of exposition. The first one says of Christ that he, “when he had himself purged our sins, sat down on the right hand of the Majesty on high;” and the second reads: “But this man [Christ], after he had offered one sacrifice for sins forever, sat down on the right hand of God.” The last text explains the first. Christ gave himself up as a sacrifice for men; and in that sacrifice he made, or provided, expiation for our sins. (See Greek.) And this is the one only sacrifice which is available with God. And this alone has been pleaded, and will be pleaded till probation shall end. There is no force in Mr. M.'s reference to these texts from his standpoint, unless he would have us believe that Christ purged or atoned for our sins before he sat down on his Father's throne on high. Does he believe this? Does Christ atone for, purge, or put away sins before they are committed? Has he atoned for the sins of all men, so that all will be saved, and Universalism prove true? or has he atoned for only a few who consequently must be saved, and passed by all others who consequently cannot be saved? If so, here we have the doctrine of predestination in its most ghastly and hideous form. Has Christ atoned for any one's sins in a general way? Then he may plunge into every form of vice and crime, and still reach heaven; for atonement has been made for all those sins, and that has canceled them. But are the sins specified for which atonement has been made? Then it has been ordained just what sins one shall commit, and in committing them, he is no free moral agent, but acting under compulsion which he cannot resist, and hence is not responsible. But if a person's sins have not been atoned for, then no matter how hard he may agonize to enter heaven, the gates will be inexorably closed against him. Away with such a travesty of the divine government! Heb. 1:3 simply means that Christ has made provision whereby sins can be purged, or put away; but whether they will be or not depends upon our own action in accepting or rejecting the provision. A parallel to this method of speech may be seen in Eze. 24:13: “I have purged thee, and thou wast not297 purged;” that is, I have endeavored, provided means, to purify thee, but thou didst not accept of them. Rom. 2:4: “The goodness of God leadeth thee to repentance;” that is, endeavors, or tends, to lead thee. Gal. 5:4: “Whosoever of you are justified by the law;” that is, seek to be justified. Many like passages might be quoted. So with Christ's blood; it has purged or expiated our sins in the sense of providing means whereby they may be expiated, if one will avail himself of it. It is the blood which has secured pardon through all the ages, and is employed in making the atonement at last. And as the atonement comes in as the closing service, it can be made, and will be made, only for those who have sought it on the prescribed conditions and so are entitled to it. Thus the error of Universalism is avoided on the one hand, and predestinationism on the other, and everything comes in, in its proper place. The session of Christ on the mediatorial throne, is his priesthood; and the “natural order” is, not for the atonement to precede it, as Mr. Morton says, but to follow it.