CONFLICT OF STATE AND CHURCH IN ITALY.
By Alexander Robertson
Italy at present is fast approaching a conflict which may have far-reaching results. That conflict is between the state and the church, between the king and the pope, between a popular constitutional government and a clerical oligarchy. Every day is demonstrating the impossibility of the coexistence of these powers. Hitherto they have existed together, but only in a state of armed neutrality, ready to throw themselves at each other should a casus belli arise. The jubilee of the pope has brought that crisis within appreciable distance. Already we hear of skirmishes between the outposts all along the line. The late papal celebrations gathered the dignitaries of the church, lay and clerical, round their head. They were thus enabled to consult together, to measure their strength, and to determine on their future course of action. Previous to this they were anything but united. Personal ambition, family differences and jealousies of various kinds, kept them apart. Now there is at least a temporary agreement to sink these petty causes of estrangement and quarrel, and to unite their forces to make a stand and fight for the restitution of the temporal power. The clerical party has received instructions to take even a more active part than they have hitherto done in municipal and senate elections, and to do everything in their power to secure the elections of clericals to the “Giunta” and to all public offices. These instructions are already being carried out with a measure of success in various provincial towns and villages, where the people are ignorant and do not know their rights, and where, consequently, the priests are nearly all-powerful. Hitherto the clerical party has been disloyal, now it is rebellious. We were lately staying with Italian friends in a town in Lombardy. Our host held a high position in the law courts, and so we met all the society of the place. At no gathering, however, did we find a priest among the guests. We asked the reason of this. “Because,” said our host, “friendship with a priest means disloyalty to the government. Any one seen with a priest is at once suspected. We feel sure he is not a good man—at least, we know this about him, he is an enemy of the state.” Last summer at Venice, we heard ex-Padre Gavazzi, the eloquent leader and preacher of the Free Italian Church, when lecturing on the lay schools, denounce the pope and priests as the worst foes of Italy; that they are disloyal to the core; that they are against the king, against the government, against real education, against civil liberty, against all the rights as men and citizens which Italy had fought and bled on many a battle-field to secure. A town-councillor of this place, when calling upon us the other day, said: “We never shall make our young men honest and patriotic until we deliver them from the influence of the priests.” Any offense against the state, the priests not only condone but often commend. The church is thus regarded all over Italy, as the enemy of the state, and her activity as such comes out everywhere in a thousand ways; and we have reason to believe that she will more openly and emphatically show herself in this character in the immediate future. Now, hitherto the state has not meddled with the church except to fulfil the obligations it undertook toward it. Roman Catholicism is the established religion. A certain number of churches are sustained by government money. The pope himself, although he calls himself “the poor prisoner of the Vatican,” is protected and provided for by the state. It is true he does not accept the handsome pension allowed him; but that is his affair. But now when the church trespasses on the province of the state, when it sets up its head, Leo XIII., as a rival to Humbert I., when it demands the restitution of the temporal power, the state must act, and it is acting with promptitude and firmness. In the very midst of the papal celebrations, the government took a most unexpected and decided step by turning out of the highest civil post in Rome that of the Syndic, the duke of Torlonia, the representative of one of the richest and most influential families of the capital, because he went and presented his homage to the pope. A jubilee address was gotten up in which the hope was expressed that the pope would yet regain the temporal power. The syndics of several towns signed this address, both in their own names and in those of their colleagues. These men the government dismissed from their posts. In one case we know of, and perhaps this thing happened in others, the town-councillors wrote to the government explaining that they had signed the address in ignorance of its real meaning and drift, and begged to withdraw their signatures. In many cases the posts of school-master are held by priests. Some of these men not only signed the petition, but induced their pupils and their parents to do so. The public education department turned all these men adrift. Indeed, a strong effort is being made to remove all priests from the public schools, and to declare that the priesthood, as a body of men, is disqualified to hold the office of government teacher. Before mentioning another action of the government, and in order to its being understood, it must be remembered that all school-books written by priests, are full of misrepresentations, omissions, and falsehoods. They are so written as to prejudice the youthful mind in favor of the church and against the state. These books are not allowed to be used as text-books in the schools, but the priests have been in the habit of giving them as prizes. Signor Crispi has just sent out a circular to all the municipalities, and to the principal libraries, and editors of scholastic books, in which he warns them that the ministry cannot longer permit such books to be so used. “Books of this class, so-called religious,” he says, “are an offense against liberty of conscience which can no longer be tolerated;” and he adds that “henceforth the scholastic provincial councils will examine all books intended for prizes, and that the government will punish any attempt to infringe these regulations.” Another interesting fact is this, that at Rome, at Venice, and in other cities, monuments are being erected by public subscription, to those who, fighting for freedom of thought under papal despotism, were martyred by the Vatican. For example, at Venice, Fra Paolo Sarpi, who was assassinated because of his holding and preaching evangelical doctrines, is being so honored; also Giovanni Bruno, who was martyred at Rome. In connection with this latter an interesting episode occurred, which is still a matter of discussion and agitation. Signor Bonghi, a professor in the University of Rome, wrote and spoke against the erection of a monument to Bruno, and supported the ex-syndic Torlonia in his opposition to it. The next day when he entered his class-room, 150 students hissed him215 for over an hour, so that he was not permitted to deliver a word of his lecture. After some explanations and conferences with the university senate and the authorities, it was believed that the affair had ended, and that he might resume his lectures. To minimize, however, the importance of the demonstration against him, Professor Bonghi wrote a letter stating that they were not bona fide students who had hissed him, but only a handful of roughs who had gained admittance to the lecture-room for that purpose. The students again showed their patriotism and opposition to clericalism, and disapproved Professor Bonghi’s words by hissing him out of countenance a second time. Their action has led to other complications, and, as we have said, things have not yet settled down. Indeed, the university had to be closed altogether for a day or two, while the students of other universities throughout the land have taken up the matter, and are sending addresses of sympathy and support to their fellow-students at Rome. Such are a few of the “skirmishes” to which we referred as the forerunners of a common struggle. We might multiply their number, but perhaps we have instanced enough to show the attitude of the church and the state in Italy, and how if the former is about to throw down the gauntlet of defiance, the latter is ready to pick it up. How the struggle will end, there can be no doubt. How even the most bigoted and blinded clericals can hope for success, amazes us. They can know nothing of the temper of the government, nor of the power of the people. The battle will mean the downfall of the church—of the church let it be noted, not of religion. The Italian nation is religious, and the Liberals, who are against the Vatican, perhaps more truly so than the clericals, who are in its favor.—Alexander Robertson, in Independent.