The Papacy and Civil Government.
By Editor
When recently a distinguished prelate of the Roman Catholic Church in this city [New York], insisted in a notable interview that the Roman Church no longer concerned herself with vested political rights, the statement arrested public attention and led to the inquiry as to whether or not this were true. There was affirmation followed by denial, and then the discussion seemed to fall to the ground. But there is evidence to the point which ought to satisfy the most incredulous, showing that if at times the Roman Church has seemed to bow to the tempest, it was simply because it could not stand up erect before it. Thus in the Syllabus of Errors put forth by the last Vatican Council, the church distinctly condemned the proposition that “it appertains to the civil power to define what are the rights and limits with which the church may exercise authority;” and it further condemned the proposition that “the ecclesiastical power must not exercise its authority without the assent and permission of the civil government.” And it also condemned as heresy the declaration that “the church has not the power of availing herself of force or any direct or indirect temporal power.” Here the right to resort to temporal power to enforce her views is asserted, an assertion which we think has been made good in her dealings with various countries. So, too, it is pertinent to recall the fact that the attempt on the part of the liberal Catholics, Montalembert and Lacordaire, to unite religious faith with social progress, was formally condemned by the Vatican Council. Prof. De Laveleye, of Paris, writes very strongly on this subject in an article in the current issue of The Forum, entitled “Civil Government and the Papacy,” in which he marshals his facts to show that the Roman Church, if logical,—and she is nothing if not logical,—stands where she always has stood; or, if it seems otherwise, it is only from expediency, to acquire an ulterior advantage. Some years ago a general tendency was manifest to consider the papacy an old-fashioned institution whose influence was waning—an institution that had abandoned much that had been claimed for it; but how mistaken this view is, Prof. Laveleye shows. In the first place, as to the waning power of the Roman Church, this has not followed as was supposed would be the case from the loss of the temporalities—the states of the church. It is true many ecclesiastical principalities created during the Middle Ages are done away with; but it is still true that the majority of the inhabitants of nearly all the Roman Catholic countries, and very powerful minorities in Protestant lands, such as Germany and England as well as those of schismatic nations like Russia, obey the orders of their priests, who, in turn, receive instructions from the bishops and the pope. As Prof. Laveleye says, it was thought the loss of the temporalities of the church would shear the Vatican of most of its power; but, instead, it has added to it. In former years it was comparatively easy when the Roman Catholic curia troubled a European sovereign, for the perturbed king, emperor, whoever he might be, to threaten some part of the papal dominions; a frigate dispatched to Civita Vecchia, or a few troops sent to Bologna, gave His Holiness subject for reflection. But now that he is disarmed, what reprisal can be had?—None, except the establishment of some kulturkampf which cuts both ways—so that Bismarck in Germany, Protestant as the country is, was glad to get rid of it and effect a reconciliation with the pope. Nor is it strange; for not a full century has passed since Joseph II. of Austria lost his crown through just such a measure as Bismarck attempted to carry out, while scarcely half a century ago the revolution in the Netherlands caused by the same conditions, drove its king into retirement. In France, Germany, Austria the papal parliamentary forces generally decide the weightiest events, and papal ballots are more effective than papal bullets. So, too, in order to induce the Irish to cease their opposition to the English government, Lord Salisbury dispatches the Duke of Norfolk as an envoy to Rome, where he represents the interests of the Irish landlords. In Italy the pope forbids his partisans to take part in parliamentary elections because they must not recognize the kingdom which has annexed the states of the church; but in municipal elections the clericals often have the best of it, even in large towns like Rome and Naples. The old monasteries have been suppressed, it is true; but on all sides, thanks to freedom of association, fresh convents are springing up, which will very soon exceed the old ones, both in number and wealth. In Austria, the clerical influence has been successful in restoring to schools their former denominational character, and in placing them entirely under ecclesiastical supervision. In Spain, although the clericals are occasionally in power, the bishops have so much the upper hand that the doctrine of intolerance is enforced by the civil authority, and the ostensible practice of Protestantism is strictly prohibited. Recently, as we took occasion to notice at the time, two Protestants were imprisoned for refusing to salute a Roman Catholic procession in the streets, and others were some years ago condemned to hard labor for reading the Bible. Autos da fé still take place from time to time, though fortunately just now only books are consumed. Furthermore, in many countries, such as the Tyrol, the Rhenish Provinces, Belgium, and Lower Canada, the real sovereign is not the reigning monarch, but the pope, who rules through the medium of his bishops and priests. The pope will be obeyed in preference to the laws of the land, unless these are in accordance with, and accepted by, ecclesiastical authority. And as showing how the Roman Church accommodates herself to the times, it may be stated that while the Roman Catholic journals of this country laugh at Renan and heap ridicule upon the great Frenchman for saying the pope will yet allow priests to marry, the fact has just been brought to light that an active propaganda, controlled by the Vatican, is being carried among the Slavs of the Eastern Church; and in order to win these, not only have these Slavs been authorized to continue the use of the orthodox Greek liturgy, but their priests may avail themselves of the privileges of the priests of the united Greek Church, and marry. And it is unnecessary to say they are finding wives rapidly. As to what are the claims of the Roman Church to sovereignty, and to what extent she insists upon the right to enforce her claims,—a right not one whit abandoned because circumstances here and there deprive her of the power of enforcing it,—the testimony is too voluminous to more than hint at it. No pope ever more thoroughly indorsed the teachings of St. Thomas Aquinas than Leo XIII.; he commended the teachings of “this father of the church” when he assumed the tiara. Now note this utterance—and there are plenty of like kind—of St. Thomas:— If heretics did not corrupt their fellows, they could, nevertheless, be suppressed. Secular justice can legitimately put them to death; for they are blasphemers now, and observers of a false faith.
The fact is, the papacy has always considered the destruction of heretics a triumph for the church, illustrated in the fact that the horrors of St. Bartholomew’s Eve and the massacre of the Huguenots are still perpetuated on the Vatican halls, as you enter the Sistine Chapel. “The residence of the pope is the only place in the world where murder is publicly glorified.” In 1830 Gregory condemned Belgium for granting religious liberty; and in the Concordat with Spain, in 1850, one of the articles reads:— The Catholic religion shall be maintained as the exclusive religion of the realm in such sort that the practice of all other worship shall be forbidden and prevented.
In the Concordat with Ecuador in 1862, there is the following stipulation:— The Roman Catholic and apostolic religion is to continue to be the religion of the republic of Ecuador. Consequently no other worship may be practiced nor any other sect tolerated in the republic.
When freedom of worship was proclaimed in Mexico, the encyclical letter of Dec. 15, 1856, denounced it to the world as “an abominable act, destined to corrupt men’s minds, and to root out the holy religion.” In Protestant countries Roman Catholics either dissimulate or deny this dogma of intolerance; but when Rome is master, she applies it with all the power she possesses. It is this religious system, this ecclesiastical machine to which Mr. Gladstone gives the name Vaticanism, that has not only a footing secured in these United States, but which enjoys that toleration that it always has denied to dissenting religions when it has had the power. It is the same to-day that it was 600 years ago, when St. Thomas wrote in the thirteenth century, in defense of proscription and death for dissidents, for the admiration of Pope Leo XIII. in the nineteenth century. This is the foe that threatens our free institutions, and notably our schools. It is a poor servant; but as master it would work the ruin of the country. Those who think the Roman Church seeks the general good to the exclusion of ulterior purposes, would do well to give a little attention to the facts we have submitted.—Christian at Work.