We have had lying in our drawer several months an article by C. E. Harroun, Jr., clipped from the Free Methodist, of Chicago, of Oct. 26, 1887, bearing the title which stands at the head of these lines. It was sent in by a sister, with the request that it be answered. We had thought to notice sometime some of its points, but upon further examination hardly think it would be worth while; for when a person will so persistently misread our position as this writer does, or is possessed with a chronic inability to understand it, it is generally safe enough to leave the intelligent reader to detect the misrepresentation.
It will suffice if we show a sample or two of his misconstruction of our teaching. He accuses us of denying the atonement of Christ, because we deny that Christ made that atonement on the cross. Christ on the cross provided a general sacrifice for the world indiscriminately, of which all may avail themselves who will. But the atonement he makes at the close of his ministry, is not indiscriminately for all the world, but for those who have sought it, and are entitled to it. The popular view that the atonement was made upon the cross, establishes inevitably one of two enormous errors: Universalism, or the most ultra form of the doctrine of election or predestination.
He accuses us of misrepresenting the nature of Christ by applying to him the term “archangel.” But does not the Bible so call him? 1 Thess. 4:16; John 5:25. He says: “They tell us Christ is an archangel.” We tell them no such thing. We never use the expression “an archangel,” which would imply that there are multitudes of archangels, or at least more than one. Our friend needs to learn a little better the definition of words, and consider that there can be but one “archangel,” as there can be but one who holds the position of “chief” of the angelic hosts. And he needs to read a little more carefully his Bible, which calls Christ “the archangel,” but never “an archangel.” And it is in no respect derogatory to Christ to speak of him as the head of all the heavenly hosts.
He scouts the idea that Christ was not possessed of a dual nature while here upon the earth. At the same time he fails to answer the point made by S. D. Adventists, that if his nature can be separated into human and divine, and only the human part died, then the world is furnished with only a human sacrifice, not a divine sacrifice, as we contend.
Because we say that Christ took on him the nature of the seed of Abraham, he accuses us of perverting the scripture, and says: “Adventists do not admit that Christ in his incarnation took on the seed of Abraham. This would be a suicidal admission.” The passage referred to in these remarks is Heb. 2:16. Did Mr. Harroun, junior, ever read the margin of that text which is a literal translation of the Greek, and is adopted in the revised version? “He taketh not hold of angels, but of the seed of Abraham he taketh hold.” If this does not refer to the nature he assumed when he came into the world, to what does it refer? He took not upon him the nature of angels, but the nature of the seed of Abraham. He, the divine Son of God, appeared here upon earth, in human nature. He, the Word, “was made flesh,” assumed the nature of the seed of Abraham. But he was the Son of God none the less; and when he died, it was a divine sacrifice.
He says we deny that sins are forgiven when a person is converted, because we say that sins are not “blotted out” until the atonement is made in the heavenly Sanctuary. There hardly seems to be any excuse for one to charge us so falsely. There is a distinction between “forgiving” sin and “blotting out” sin, which he carelessly overlooks. Sins are pardoned and forgiven, when confessed and forsaken; but the time does not come for those sins to be blotted out till the conclusion of Christ’s work as priest in the heavenly Sanctuary. Men repent and are converted and pardoned; but their sins are not blotted out till the times of refreshing come from the presence of the Lord. So Peter expressly testifies. He says: “Repent ye therefore, and be converted, that your sins may be blotted out, when the times of refreshing shall come from the presence of the Lord.” Acts 3:19.
These instances will be sufficient to show how he treats our views. He concludes by saying, “I know of no doctrine drawn from the Scriptures which they hold in common with the orthodox churches.” To which we might respond that if we should treat the views of other denominations as he treats ours, we might make the same charge against every one of them.