MUNSEY ON THE LAW

6%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · May 15, 1888

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 65, No. 20.

Read the full edition

MUNSEY ON THE LAW.

(Concluded.)
Mr. Fletcher says the law which he styles throughout his writings as “Adamic law,” cannot be violated without certainly bringing the violator under its curse; therefore we are not under it, but under the law of Christ, the evangelical law of liberty, by which he says in another place we will be judged. But what is fatal to his assigned reason is, that the law cannot be violated now without bringing the offender under its curse as surely and to the same degree as it brought Adam, and that though Adam did violate it, he was not brought under its final curse, and away goes his conclusion. That the law given to Adam is still binding, requiring holiness of heart and life, and threatening sinners because they are wicked, is clear from its origin, nature, immutability, requirements, unpardoning character, universality, and also from the Holy Scriptures. Read Romans, that profound disquisition upon law, and exposition of the gospel, where they are presented in their distinct yet relative properties and offices. “For until the law sin was in the world; but sin is not imputed when there is no law. Nevertheless death reigned from Adam to Moses, even over them that had not sinned after the similitude of Adam’s transgression, who is the figure of Him that was to come.”
Dr. Taylor, in his comment on the last verse, which is quoted and indorsed by Dr. Clarke, says: 1. “Sin was in the world from Adam to Moses, during the space of about two thousand five hundred years; for after Adam’s transgression that law was abrogated.” The comment is self contradictory: 1. “Sin was in the world from Adam to Moses; 2. Law was not in the world from Adam to Moses.” How sin can exist for two thousand five hundred years from Adam to Moses, without law, I cannot divine; for Paul says expressly, “For where no law is, there is no transgression.” And again he says, “I had not known sin, but by the law.” And he enters into a long argument to prove that sin owes its existence to the law.
The conclusion is the precise converse of Mr. Taylor’s proposition; law was in the world between Adam and Moses, and law after man’s transgression was not abrogated. The comment contradicts the preceding verse, yea one of the verses of which it professes to be the exposition: “For until the law [i. e., the law given through Moses] sin was in the world; but sin is not imputed when there is no law.” The conclusion is irresistible: if sin was in the world before the law which was given through Moses, and cannot be imputed without law, there was a law existing as obligatory, prior to the one given on Mount Sinai.
The very fact that the Bible makes distinctions in moral character before the days of Moses, pronouncing threatenings upon the wicked, and offering rewards to the good, is demonstrative that in those days men were under law; for the moral character of all actions is determined by the law. If they were under a law, we must be under the same law. Their circumstances and ours were similar: they were fallen, so are we; indeed, if they were not fallen, and we were, it would make no difference; there can be no possible reason discovered why they should be under one law and we under another. If the pre-Mosaic and post-Mosaic worlds were under different laws, everything being the same between them, one law must have something that the other has not, or there is no distinction. If one has something the other has not, one of them is imperfect,—and an imperfect law in a perfect government, ruled by a perfect Governor, a perfect Lawgiver, is too absurd to be entertained for a moment.
What was the law of the pre-Mosaic ages?—The moral law given to Adam, or none. What, then, would be the law under which we are placed?—The moral law given to Adam, or none. Before Moses, men’s bodies died, and the death of man’s body is a philosophic consequence of the penalty of moral law—the law given to Adam. Our bodies die [Why not say we die?]—the same penalty. The infliction of bodily death upon us is a standing monument that the moral law, the law given to Adam, is not abrogated, or that we are not released from its claims. . . . The existence of death and tombs while under the gospel, is evidence that the law is not made void by faith.
[We now come to discourse No. 3. Under the text, “Do we then make void the law through faith? God forbid; yea, we establish the law” (Rom. 3:31), Mr. Munsey continues his reasoning on the law and the gospel, as follows:—]
In my first discourse I showed you the origin, nature, and immutability of the moral law. In the second, I showed you that law was unpardoning and universal—that Adam, Moses, and we, as well as angels, were all under the same law; that the gospel did not take the law’s place; that it was not made void through faith. I will resume the Scriptural testimony where I left off.
[He then quotes Rom. 8:1–4, and says:—]
The doctrine of Paul here is, that the law being weak through the flesh, i. e., the flesh being contrary to the perfection required by the law, in subjecting the sinner to the awful penalties of the law, the law could not pardon, sanctify, and save him. And for this reason Christ came to condemn sin in the flesh, to destroy that through which the law inflicted its penalty, “that the righteousness of the law might be fulfilled in us.” It seems to be the sole purpose of the gospel to establish the law. Does this look like abrogation?
Again, Paul in the third chapter of Romans, after proving that a sinner cannot be justified by the law, for fear that some one might be led by this fact to believe that the gospel supplanted the law, and it seems there are a good many, he winds up his masterly argument in this chapter, in the words of the text: “Do we then make void the law through faith? God forbid; yea, we establish the law.” Of what law was he speaking?—The great moral law; because he says it was given to both Jews and Gentiles, in the preceding chapter. A peculiar edition of it given to the Jews by revelation, adapted to their commonwealth; and given to the Gentiles by the inspiration of the Holy Ghost. . . .
Here we have the office of the gospel, by which we mean all the remedial principles and instrumentalities of the system of grace, as distinguished from law—and nothing more—distinctly and relatively considered with reference to law. The moral law, from its nature, required holiness, justice, goodness, and truth, all actuated and working in obedience to that which constituted its essence—actuated and working by love. Man transgressed this law, and fell under its curse. The law could not forgive him; God could not forgive him; the law could not be abrogated—it was still binding; man could not be released from its claims; for he sustained the same relations to God after the fall as before; he could not recall his sin; he could not balance it by future obedience. The gospel stepped in as a remedy, meeting all these conditions, and established the law.
To suppose man even pardoned, the law required perfect obedience as the ground of continued justification, and man became incapable of rendering that. Every capability and power of man’s being might shine in the meridian glories of intellectual and moral truth; but to attempt obedience with nothing more than the pardon of the past, would be a cold, sad, arduous work, oppressive and slavish in Paul’s highest sense of bondage. Man must have an inspiration, a spontaneous impulse of power—he must have life. He must be free, and act from the will, the point of liberty. The law to him must be a “law of liberty,” not by any change in the law, but by a change in himself; and this is all that the apostle ever meant by a law of liberty. He never meant by the expression a milder law of the gospel. Man must have the inspiration of love—love, the essence of God’s moral nature, copied and ingrained into his own nature as the ruling and actuating principle of his obedient life. . . . The essence of God’s nature and the essence of his law must drive the whole machinery of redemption—LOVE. . . . Love is the fulfillment of the law, and holiness is its end; but man fell and lost both.
Now, the gospel as a remedial agent, by conversion removes enmity from man’s heart, and implants love, the principle of obedience, and places him immediately under law that he might be holy; in fact, giving him supernatural powers to keep it, and a sacrifice of sufficient merit to atone for all his delinquencies and errors. This is the whole office and work of the gospel in miniature. Love is the essence of God, the essence of his law, the essence of the gospel. Holiness is the totality of God’s moral nature, the end of his law, the end of the gospel. . . . To make a man obey the law you must make him love it, and religion is love; and to make him holy the gospel converts him, and places him entirely under law, supplying him with strength, and atoning for his defects all the while. Do you not see that law—the original law—is not made void by faith, the condition of pardon in the gospel—not made void by the gospel?
The very existence of the atonement is an evidence of the continued authority of the law. The gospel being a plan to meet in certain and different senses, the preceptive and penal claims of the law, supposes the law’s continued existence. Indeed, if the law is not in full authority, we have no use for the gospel. The very idea of pardon shows the existing obligation of law. To establish the law the whole machinery of redemption was put in motion. To establish the law as well as to save the offender, Jesus died. The gospel is not law. The law commands, the law threatens, the law curses; the gospel invites, the gospel promises, the gospel blesses. Gospel means “good news,” and it is contrary to the idea of good news that it should be condemnatory. It is a perpetually applying remedy, commensurate with all our sins. Every hour in virtue for us the Saviour dies:—
“Thy offering still continues new; Thy virtue keeps its bloody hue.”
No necessity for removing the law with such a remedy. This view sustains the authority and majesty of the law, and imparts an infinite grandeur to the gospel. An immutable and eternal law—a commensurate remedy. The law is as high as heaven; the gospel is as high as heaven. The demands of the law are infinite; the remedy of the gospel is infinite. The law is the transcript of the nature of God; so is the gospel. Both magnificent pictures,—the first of inexorable holiness, the second of holiness tempered with mercy. The first is the front of the storm with its lightnings, the second is the rear of the storm with its beautiful rainbow.