THE DIVISIONS OF PROTESTANTISM

13%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Jun 5, 1888

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 65, No. 23.

Read the full edition

THE DIVISIONS OF PROTESTANTISM.

The Northern Presbyterians are holding their General Assembly at Philadelphia, and the Southern Presbyterians are in General Assembly at Baltimore. The Southern Baptists have just closed their Annual Convention at Richmond, and the Northern Baptists have opened their anniversary meetings at Washington.
In both of these great denominations the sectional divisions do not represent any differences as to doctrine and order, and the fraternity of feeling between them seems to be complete. On Tuesday the attendance at the Baptist Convention at Richmond was small, because so many of the delegates had gone to Washington to participate in the meetings of their Northern brethren. Next Thursday the Southern General Assembly at Baltimore will go to Philadelphia, as a body, to unite with the Northern General Assembly in celebrating the Presbyterian centenary.
Yet the present indications are that the attempts in each of these denominations to bring about organic unity by the obliteration of sectional lines of separation, will not prove successful. It was the slavery question that provoked the division, and now it is the race question that keeps it up. The Northern and Southern Presbyterians seem to disagree only so far as concerns the organization of an independent African Church. The Southern Baptists provided for the appointment of a committee to meet a like committee of Northern missionary societies to arrange for co-operation in missionary work, but they expressly declared that it was “not with a view to organic union;” and when a motion was made to strike out that conditional clause, it was defeated by an overwhelming vote. All that is to be considered, is the adjustment of the “several fields and agencies, so as not to have a conflict” between the sectional divisions of the denomination. Here, too, difference of opinion as to the colored brethren and churches undoubtedly prevails, according to geographical lines.
Such lack of harmony of course involves greater expense of effort and money than would be required if there was organic union. Two sets of organizations for missionary and other church purposes are kept up when one could accomplish the work, with a saving in salaries and the general cost of running the machinery. As so great a part of the money collected for these purposes goes to pay collecting agents and society officers, the practical argument for consolidation is therefore of the strongest sort. But sentimental considerations stand in the way of the unity which is so desirable as a measure of economy, and of course if the Northern and Southern members of the denominations are willing to pay in hard cash for the privilege of holding their respective prejudices, they have an undoubted right to do it. It is their money, and they can do what they please with it, though in the world of secular affairs such sacrifice of substantial benefit to mere sentiment is more and more regarded as childish short-sightedness and obstinacy.
But throughout the field of Protestant missionary effort we find analogous conflicts and division. Even in denominations which are so closely akin in creed and order that their ministers pass from one to the other, there are separate organizations for such work, and others whose differences concern more forms of church government and do not affect their theological standards, maintain distinct societies for the propagation of a common faith, as if they were radically and intrinsically at variance.
There are, for instance, eleven different kinds of Baptists, fourteen of Methodists, nine of Presbyterians, and five of Lutherans. The Congregationalists are separated from the Presbyterians only in church government, and the clergy of one satisfy the doctrinal requirements of the other; and yet they continue to work independently for religious ends. Of course, heathendom and Christendom both are confused by such a state of things, and the more so, inasmuch as all the Protestant churches known as orthodox and evangelical are substantially in agreement on their fundamental theology. The difference between the dish served up is in its form and garniture, and not in its ingredients.
The partisan spirit, in fine, is strong in all of them, and it seems that even the sectional spirit, a relic of the old days of slavery, is still unconquerable. The day of organic Christian union, of which we have heard so much of late years, seems, therefore, to be far in the future. It is among the enemies of faith that we see ranks unbroken by partisan division, while Christendom is split up into innumerable varieties of faith, each more or less at war with the rest.—N. Y. Sun.