A TRANSPARENT EVASION

5%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Jun 5, 1888

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 65, No. 23.

Read the full edition

A TRANSPARENT EVASION.

A brother has sent us a leaflet from the W. C. T. U., containing a “Concert Exercise” on the Sabbath question, by the national superintendent, Mrs. J. C. Bateham. The subject is “The Fourth Commandment.” “Lesson text: Remember the Sabbath day, to keep it holy.” The question is asked, where those words are found; and the answer is given, “In Ex. 20:8.” Ques. 2.—Was it a new command? Ans.—It was not . . . Ques. 3.—Where do we learn this? Ans.—In Gen. 2:3, where it says, “God blessed the seventh day and sanctified it because that in it he had rested from all his work which God created.” . . . Ques. 4.—What does it mean to sanctify, to bless, and to hallow a day? Ans.—To sanctify is to set apart; to hallow is to make sacred; to bless is to make it a blessing. The meaning is, that God set apart the seventh or Sabbath day to be a sacred day, and when so observed it would always be a blessing.
We have quoted thus fully to show how definite the reference to the fourth commandment is, and how well the institution and nature of the Sabbath are understood. We wish the reader to note these points, that he may share with us in our surprise at what follows, which is the particular point we have to notice.
Thus question 5 reads: “Why do we not still keep the seventh day for our Sabbath, instead of the first, or Sunday?” This question is directly to the point. It is the great question which the religious world have long been trying to answer, and are growing frantic because they succeed no better. Cautious or experienced writers who have undertaken to answer this question, are careful not to make the admissions given above. When a person admits, as this leaflet does, that the Sabbath was instituted at creation; that it was then sanctified, hallowed, and blessed; that these terms are specific and apply to a particular day; and that by the terms of the fourth commandment they are inseparably confined to one specific day, he throws up a breastwork around the Sabbath, which he can neither throw down nor climb over.
Let us now look at the answer which this leaflet gives to the question, “Why do we not still keep the seventh day for our Sabbath, instead of the first, or Sunday?” The answer is, “We still keep one day of rest after six of work, thus imitating God’s example at creation, and at the same time we honor and keep in memory the resurrection of Jesus Christ, who on the first day of the week rose from the dead and thus completed our redemption.”
A few questions will serve to analyze this singular answer. It is admitted in the question that the day now kept is the first day, not the seventh. It is therefore a different day from the one on which God rested at the creation, which was then hallowed and blessed, and which the fourth commandment enjoins. But—
  1. Was it not a particular day on which God rested?
  2. Was not one specific day sanctified or set apart?
  3. Does not the commandment confine the duty of Sabbatizing to the very day on which God rested, the very day which was sanctified?
  4. Can the commandment possibly be obeyed in the use of any other day?
  5. Should not the question therefore read, “Why do we not still keep the fourth commandment?” for this is the real issue.
  6. How dare any one assert that we keep the commandment by simply “imitating” God’s example? Is this what the commandment requires? Was not his example definite? Was not the sanctification specific? And does not the commandment require that our rest be on the very day of the weekly cycle, the seventh, on which he rested? The very day he sanctified and blessed? When God, the judge of all, the one who instituted the Sabbath, and who framed the commandment, shall ask the Sunday-keeper, “Why did you not keep the seventh day instead of the first?” what will be his answer? Will he dare say, as here instructed to do, “I know I did not keep your commandment, but I imitated your example, which I thought would do just as well!”
  1. Where are we commanded to honor Christ by keeping the first day of the week, or where is it revealed that this would honor him?
  2. Where is it said that our redemption was completed on the first day of the week? It is strange that so groundless an assertion should ever have become such a staple commodity in popular theology. Whoever will bestow a moment’s thought upon what the Scriptures say on this subject, will see that redemption cannot be completed till the future “restitution of all things,” spoken of by Peter in Acts 3:21.
We come now to the next question and answer, which, if possible, are more singular still:—
Ques. 6.—If Jesus wished the day changed, why did he not command it? Ans.—A command to celebrate the resurrection could not wisely be made before the resurrection occurred. He probably gave his own disciples such directions afterward, when, “speaking of the things pertaining to the kingdom of God” (Acts 1:3), as the disciples seem to have always after that time observed the first day of the week as Sabbath (see narrative in Acts); and every time Jesus appeared to his disciples after the resurrection, was, so far as recorded, on that day. Finally, it was wiser to make the change quietly and gradually, as it was done, so as not to frighten away Jewish converts or bring persecution on themselves from the Jews.
People seem to have lost sight of the fact that there is a judgment coming in which they must give an account of their course of action here. We have tried to imagine a poor soul appearing before the great tribunal, and giving such an answer as the above for Sunday-keeping. When the Judge shall demand why he took another day for the Sabbath than the one commanded, and thus by his tradition made void an important portion of the law of God, would it be sufficient for him to say, “I know that the Lord, before his ascension from earth, spoke to his disciples of the things pertaining to the kingdom of God, and I thought that very probably (1) at this time he commanded them to celebrate the resurrection by keeping Sunday; and therefore I discard the Sabbath and keep Sunday.”
With infants and idiots we have no doubt the Lord will be very lenient; but we do not imagine that such a plea as this on the part of any intelligent person will be of much avail.
It is further claimed that every time Jesus appeared after the resurrection, so far as recorded, was upon the first day of the week! So far from this being the case, there was only one first day mentioned on which he met with them; and that was the day of his resurrection. The second meeting was “after eight days,” which would throw it over to the next Monday or Tuesday. The third meeting is recorded in John 21, when the disciples were out fishing. They certainly ought to have known by this time that Sunday was the Sabbath, if it had become such, and if this was the first day of the week, as is claimed; and they should not, in that case, have been out fishing. But if they had so far forgotten themselves, Christ should have reproved them. But instead of this, he helps them on in their work, telling them how to cast the net, and giving them a miraculous draft of fishes.
It is further “recorded” that Christ was seen of his disciples, forty days, which would bring the ascension on Thursday, on which day all agree that it occurred. He certainly “appeared” to them at this time. Why, then, does our author say that “every time Jesus appeared to his disciples after the resurrection, was, so far as recorded, on that [the first] day.” What is the matter with persons when they try to support Sunday as the Sabbath? Do they lose their memory? Do they lose their power to discern facts? Do they lose their capability of weighing evidence? Or what is the matter? Who can account for such a statement as the above?
Let us suppose that the ascension had occurred on the first day of the week, as might have been the case, and doubtless would have been, had Christ designed by any post-resurrection action to confer honor on that day; would the time and event have been then so quietly ignored?—By no means. Every pulpit would have resounded with the importance of that event, and the evidence that Christ thereby designed to confer honor on the Sunday, and establish that day as the Sabbath. As it is, is it any evidence that Thursday ought to be observed? Neither would it have been, even if it had occurred on Sunday.
If Christ had only said somewhere that he was Lord of the first day of the week, how the land would have rung with that evidence, iterated, and reiterated that the first day of the week is the Lord’s day. But because Christ made that statement of the Sabbath, the fact is passed over in silence, or referred to only to say that he was Lord of the Sabbath, only to abolish it. We leave the candid reader to judge how much consistency or honesty there is in such treatment of the subject.
We are referred to the record in Acts as proof that “the disciples seem to have always after that time [the resurrection of Christ] observed the first day of the week as the Sabbath.” The Sabbath is often mentioned in the Acts, and also the frequent meetings held on that day by the apostles, both with Jews and Gentiles; but will any one claim that the day there so often called the Sabbath, was the first day of the week?—No one. The first day is mentioned only once in the Acts, and that is in connection with Paul’s meeting at Troas (Acts 20:7); but the record, by showing that Paul traveled on the light part of the day, on foot, nineteen and a half miles from Troas to Assos, proves that the apostles regarded it as a secular, not as a sacred, day. See Conybeare and Howson. So much for the record in Acts.
Before laying aside this leaflet, we must call the reader’s attention to two more questions and answers, which read as follows:—
Ques. 17.—Did Jesus teach that we must obey [italics as we find them] the fourth command? Ans.—He did. He says, “I came not to destroy the law (of which the fourth commandment is part) but to fulfill it;” not to say we will have no Sabbath, but that we must keep it holy. He says he is “Lord of the Sabbath” just as much as he is of man, for whom the Sabbath was made, and so certainly he has a right to say how it shall be observed.
We turn back now to a previous question, and find the following:—
Ques. 18.—Would there be any stores or shops open on Sunday if this commandment were obeyed? Ans.—There would not.
This time the italics are ours; and we need offer no further comments upon it. Such another instance where one has first shown the clear distinction between two days, and then proceeded deliberately to interchange, confuse, and mix them up, we think it would be hard to find. As a specimen of self-destructive logic and self-contradictory assertions, this leaflet bears away the palm.