A LITTLE CHRISTIAN HISTORY.
By H. C. Giles
“Then the same day at evening, being the first day of the week, when the doors were shut where the disciples were assembled for fear of the Jews, came Jesus and stood in the midst, and saith unto them, Peace be unto you.” John 20:19. Some who attempt to controvert the arguments presented by Sabbatarians, in behalf of the observance of the seventh-day Sabbath, as being obligatory upon Christians in this dispensation, claim that it was a Jewish institution, peculiar to that age, and like all Mosaic rites and ceremonies, was to be in force only to the cross, at which time it was rendered void by the death of Christ, by whom, after his resurrection, the Christian Sabbath (Sunday) was instituted. In proof of this assertion, our opponents confidently refer us to the scripture just quoted. As a preface to their arguments on this text, they draw the following inferences: 1. The disciples were assembled at a regular place of worship; 2. They were engaged in religious services; 3. They were commemorating the resurrection of their Lord; 4. To add to the solemnity of the occasion, Christ himself appeared in their midst, thus showing his approval of their course, and placing the sanctity of the Sunday Sabbath on a divine and immutable basis. Although from the exterior the structure reared on this foundation may look to them very pleasing, yet when tested by the Scriptures, it will crumble as did the walls of Jericho when compassed by the sacred ark of God. Let us briefly examine from the word of God these inferential pillars which form the support of this widely-cherished Sunday institution, and determine whether they will endure the pressure thus brought to bear upon them. When our Lord had chosen the twelve apostles to be his immediate followers, the record states that “they went into a home.” Mark 3:19, margin. Greenfield defines the original word oikos, rendered “home” by our translators, “house,” “home,” “place of abode;” by metonymy, household, family. From this we learn that when the apostles of our Lord “left all” to follow their Master, they took up a common abode; i. e., formed one family or household. And again, the fact that the disciples did possess a common abode is positively asserted in Acts 1:13. Therefore, because we find the disciples together at any time, the inference that they were assembled at a place of worship is too “far-fetched” to have any weight whatever. “But,” says the objector, “was not this a special meeting of the apostles for some particular object, and is it not for this reason that the sacred writer is so careful to record it?” Before concluding thus, let us examine the facts in the case. In recording the chief events in the work of Christ subsequent to his resurrection, Mark speaks concerning276 the same meeting (?) in the following language: “Afterward he appeared unto the eleven as they sat at meat, and upbraided them with their unbelief and hardness of heart, because they believed not them which had seen him after he had risen.” Chap. 16:14. Were they holding religious services?—Not at all. They simply sat at meat. Even more pointed testimony than this is afforded by St. Luke. Describing the same event, and the manner of Jesus’ appearing to his disciples on this occasion, the inspired penman speaks of the fears which filled their minds as he first spoke to them, and tells how he endeavored to dispel their doubts by showing them his hands and his feet, and then continues: “And while they yet believed not for joy, and wondered, he said unto them, Have ye here any meat? And they gave him a piece of a broiled fish and of an honey-comb. And he took it and did eat before them.” Chap. 24:41-43. How would this do for a church scene in which Christ and his disciples were the actors? Possibly it might be appreciated by some of our modern religious circles that have their magnificent and costly edifices, richly furnished with all the conveniences for eating and drinking; but I fear that our meek and lowly Saviour and his humble followers could hardly have accommodated themselves to such surroundings. So the would-be religious service undergoes a sort of metamorphosis, and, lo! as the Saviour enters their midst, he finds them collected around their family board, sharing their evening meal. “But,” queries the objector, “since the disciples possessed a common place of abode, is it not probable that they were quietly observing the day to commemorate the resurrection of their Lord from the dead?” Let us see; what saith the Scriptures? In Mark 16:9-14, we have a very brief but comprehensive account of the manner in which the news of the resurrection spread among the disciples: “Now when Jesus was risen early the first day of the week, he appeared first to Mary Magdalene, out of whom he had cast seven devils. And she went and told them that had been with him, as they mourned and wept. And they, when they had heard that he was alive, and had been seen of her, believed not. After that he appeared in another form unto two of them, as they walked, and went into the country. And they went and told it unto the residue: neither believed they them. Afterward he appeared unto the eleven as they sat at meat,” etc. From this we learn that Jesus first appeared to Mary Magdalene, who went and told the disciples she had seen the Lord; but they believed not. After that, he appeared to the two disciples as they journeyed to Emmaus. (Compare verses 12, 13, with Luke 24:13-35.) They quickly returned (Luke 24:33) and related their story to the ten who remained at Jerusalem; but they did not believe even them. What, then, was their faith in the resurrection of Christ when we find them assembled on this occasion?—Nothing at all. Further, Luke furnishes a more minute account of his consecutive appearances on the day of his resurrection, and having described the manner of his reception by the disciples at the time in question, continues the narrative as follows: “And while they yet believed not for joy, and wondered, he said unto them, Have ye here any meat?” From this it must appear that not only did the nine disciples disbelieve the report of the two from Emmaus, but more than that, when we find them together on the evening of the resurrection day, it was with a firm and unshaken belief that their crucified Lord was still in the tomb, whither they had seen him conveyed. Therefore we must conclude that the disciples were celebrating an event for the occurrence of which the first ray of probability, or even possibility, had not dawned upon their minds, or abandon the inference as unwarrantable and directly opposed to the facts in the case as gathered from the sacred record. It certainly requires no great discernment to determine which alternative is preferable. The objector continues: “Did not Christ’s appearance in their midst on the first day of the week sanctify Sunday? and are we not warranted in concluding that he wished the day to be sacredly observed by Christians ever after?” If this be true, as our opponents seem so confidently to assert, it must follow that whenever we find Christ with his disciples subsequently to his resurrection, it was holy time. Seeing that this conclusion is unavoidable, some non-Sabbatarians readily assume the position that Christ met with his disciples after the resurrection only on the first day of the week. But in order to maintain their arguments, they are compelled to prove (1.) that the ascension occurred on Sunday; (2.) that in apostolic times, “after eight days” (John 20:26) meant just seven; and (3.) that the disciples observed the Sabbath with all the solemnity attendant upon a grand fishing tour! John 21:1-3. And more than this, when Christ meets with them on this holy (?) day, he does not accuse them of Sabbath desecration, but commends their course by crowning their efforts with marked success. See verses 6-14. Let us briefly examine these points: 1. In Acts 1:3, we learn that Christ was with his disciples forty days after his resurrection; the end of which period fixes the ascension day unmistakably on Thursday, as all authorities agree. 2. Any child who has learned to count ten, would know that “after eight days” from any first-day must overreach the next Sunday by at least one day. 3. If our opponents wish the meeting recorded in John 21:1-3 as a dividend with which to crown their Sunday Sabbath, they are very welcome to it; but we would blush to place so low an estimate upon the piety of the disciples of our beloved Lord. However, those who complain so grievously because Seventh-day Adventists pursue their usual vocations on the first day of the week, better first call the Saviour to account; for certainly we have a better example for working on that day, provided that their own grounds are fairly taken, than they can secure for refraining from labor thereon. If Christ’s meeting with his disciples on this occasion was not to sanctify the day, what was its object? We have already seen that after the resurrection, Christ first appeared to Mary Magdalene, who, when she told the disciples that the Lord was alive and had been seen of her, was not believed by them. Afterward he appeared to the two disciples as they journeyed, sorrowing, to Emmaus. They “trusted that it had been He which should have redeemed Israel.” Luke 24:21. But he was ruthlessly torn from them by the infuriated mob, and they soon saw the form of him whom they had learned to love, suspended on the cruel cross, pierced and bleeding. Death laid his icy touch upon him, and the grave closed upon him as its victim. As the cheerless portals of the tomb inclosed the form of their beloved Lord, and the stone was rolled against the door of the sepulcher, within was buried all their hope; and, disappointed and mourning at their bitter bereavement, after a short lapse of time they even resolved to return to their former occupation. And as the Saviour rose from the dead, his first object was to comfort his grief-stricken followers, and give them an experience that would qualify them for future usefulness in carrying forward the great work of salvation, to be intrusted to their charge. So when they had heard the story of the women and of the two disciples from Emmaus, and were still doubting, he presented himself “to the eleven as they sat at meat, and upbraided them with their unbelief and hardness of heart, because they believed not them which had seen him after he was risen.” Mark 16:14. Anything said about a new Sabbath institution?—Not a word; his sole mission at this time was to prove to them that their crucified Lord had burst asunder the bands of death and the grave, and that they might lean their tottering hopes on a risen Saviour. But to any change in the Sabbath, he makes not even the slightest allusion. We must, therefore, either accuse the Saviour of culpable neglect, or forever abandon the claim of divine authority for the change of the Sabbath as based wholly on unsupportable inference; for here, if anywhere, the change must belong. But why seek for a change in the Sabbath, the seal of God’s immutable law (see Eze. 20:12, sign and seal being used interchangeably in the Scriptures), on the authority of Christ? Was the holy seer misinformed in regard to the matter, when he said that Christ’s work would be to “magnify the law, and make it honorable” (not to change it)? Isa. 42:21. Did the Son of God, the creator of all things (Col. 1:16; Heb. 1:2), the Lord of the Sabbath (Mark 2:28), labor under a misapprehension of the facts in the case when he declared, “Till heaven and earth pass, one jot or one tittle shall in no wise pass from the law till all be fulfilled!” Matt. 5:18. Were his words devoid of meaning when he admonished his disciples to pray that their flight from the fated city which was destroyed about forty years after the resurrection, “be not in the winter, neither on the Sabbath day”? Matt. 24:20. But our opponents attempt to subvert the evidence drawn from this text, by alleging that it no more proves the sanctity of the Sabbath than of the winter; and that by the term “Sabbath day,” he meant the Jewish Sabbath. But let the reader bear in mind that the sanctity of the Sabbath is by no means the point at issue. When God blessed and sanctified the Sabbath day, after he had rested thereon from creation’s work, it must retain its sanctity till, by divine authority, it is abolished or changed. Therefore, if the Sabbath as it was before the resurrection, at the time when this divine injunction was uttered, was to exist unchanged forty years subsequently to the same event, let the intelligent reader decide if the text does not prove conclusively the impossibility of either abolition or change at the cross. And to presume that the Saviour misapplies himself in making the above declaration,—designating by the expression, “the Sabbath day,” an abolished institution, which, therefore, could not have borne this sacred title, having been “blotted out” of existence forty years previous,—would be to attribute to the Son of God inability to choose language to express properly the ideas intended to be conveyed. But is it not strange that men will cavil with the solemn and all-important truths contained in God’s holy word, when their eternal interests are at stake? We are to be sanctified and prepared to share the unending joys of the saved, through obedience to divine truth, not by following the “cunningly devised fables” of man. These Satan has always employed in his endeavors to defeat the plan of salvation, as devices through which to ensnare and destroy souls; and those who have trusted in them, have finally been led away captive by the arch-deceiver. We learn from Inspiration that the last great deception is to be so powerful in its effects that, if it were possible, the elect of God will be deceived. May God help his professed people to realize their danger; to have their loins girt about with truth, and have on the breastplate of righteousness (Eph. 6:14), which is the keeping, in letter and in spirit, of God’s holy law (Isa. 51:7; Ps. 119:172), the fourth command of which is, “Remember the Sabbath day, to keep it holy. Six days shalt thou labor and do all thy work: but the seventh day is the Sabbath of the Lord thy God.” Ex. 20:8-11. Reader, in obedience lies your only hope. Isa. 1:19; 1 Sam. 15:22.