A DEFINITION, EX CATHEDRA.
SPIRITUALISM claims its mission to be, to demonstrate to the world the truthfulness of the doctrine of the immortality of the soul. This not being sufficiently proved by the Bible, it steps forth to supply a long-existing and keenly-felt want, and show to the world by indisputable phenomena and striking manifestations, that the soul lives on in the spirit world after the death of the body; for, behold, what pretend to be departed souls come back and exclaim, “Here we are! to speak for ourselves.” But the followers of this ism, like other mortals, fall into some perplexity over the definitions of “soul” and “spirit,” and wonder what the difference is between them. Of course this self-constituted teacher, this divine (?) exponent, this sublime demonstrator, of the soul’s immortality, must solve these doubts, and enlighten the benighted minds of men on this question. If we accept the doctrine of the immortality of the soul as true, we must accept the definitions which its only teacher attaches to the terms connected with it. And here we have it in the Banner of Light, of Feb. 25, 1888. Among the questions and answers in the “spirit message” department, we find the following:— Q.—Is there a difference between soul and spirit? If so, what; and can one exist without the other? A.—We have considered the terms “soul” and “spirit” on other occasions, but we find a confusion existing in the minds of many inquirers in relation to those terms, and we also find that spirits, as well as speakers, are apt to make use of the terms interchangeably, giving the same definition to both. But there is a difference between the two words. To our mind, the soul is really the man, as it is the life-principle, springing from the great fountain-source of all life, power, intelligence, or being. This life-principle, the motor power which sets in operation all that it comes in contact with, we do not consider in the abstract, because in its connection with human life we find it individualized, and yet it is a principle, an active power operating upon and throughout the human structure. To us the soul is a part of infinitude, that which is in the likeness of God, the great Creator of all life and law. What, then, is spirit? Spirit to us is the structure operated upon by the soul, or life-principle. This spiritual being has its parts and its functions, every one of which is permeated and fulfilled by the great electrical life-principle which we call the soul. Can the spirit exist without the soul? To our mind, no; because without that great moving, animating power or principle the spirit would fall into disuse, and would be as senseless and cold as inanimate matter could possibly be; but when thrilled and acted upon by this great electrical power and individualized force, it becomes sentient, conscious, active, full of vitality. Can the soul exist without the spiritual structure?—Only in the abstract, because there must be a manifestation of all law, all power, all activity—else this law, power, and activity would be diffused throughout the atmosphere or the universe, and be unable to perform its work; but when it can create and devise means for its manifestation in useful ways, then it shows a purpose for its existence; and this is what we find in regard to the soul as connected with the spirit; and this is what we find in regard to the soul and spirit as connected with matter, the one and the other devising ways and means and manifestations for the expression of their great force, power, and consciousness. All that shows intelligence, intellectuality, power of being or of development, belongs to the soul, and yet all this is manifested throughout the spirit of man, and made to create as well as to sustain forms of order, even laws and systems. We believe that man is ever a dual being, but in connection with physical life a trine being, inasmuch as when endowed with the outward form of flesh there is not only the soul-principle, the great moving, electrical force which sets the entire machine, the entire universe in motion, but there is a grand structure filled with magnetic and electric power, which we may properly call the spirit of man. We have also the physical form, acted upon by this dual force of magnetism and electricity which makes up the soul and spirit, the positive and negative principles of life and being, of which we must believe the Great Father of all is composed. This, it strikes us, makes confusion worse confounded. The spirits themselves make mistakes, it seems, concerning the soul and spirit. If they know anything about the question, from their stand-point of acquaintance they ought to know all about it, and make no mistakes. The communicating spirit says, “To our mind.” How is this? Is it with the spirits merely a matter of opinion and not of knowledge? If so, they are no better teachers of the immortality of the soul, than men still in the flesh. But when we come to the definitions, the subject seems to be more mixed than ever. According to the answer, it takes both the soul and spirit to make the immortal part, and neither of them can exist separated from, and independent of, the other. Hence we cannot speak about the “disembodied soul,” or “disembodied spirit.” But what the connection these have with the body at any time, it is hard to conceive. If the spirit is the “structure” and the soul is the “animating principle,” what more is needed, or what more can be used? Why have another structure called the body? And where can this come in? and what is its office? We have the soul acting upon a structure called the spirit, and this structure acting upon another and useless structure, like the fifth wheel in a coach, called the body. The foregoing spirit evidently got into trouble345 when he came to this part of the program; for when the “physical form” is brought in, lo! the soul and spirit turn out to be merely a “dual force of magnetism and electricity,” or “the positive and negative principles of life and being.” From the very nature of the case, Spiritualism must get as far from the Bible, and as opposite to the truth, as possible, for the being who is pulling the wires in that movement, is the father of falsehood and the embodiment of unrighteousness. So in this case, if the terms were reversed, it would be nearer to the truth taught by the Bible on this question.