IS IT CONSISTENT.?

17%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · May 29, 1888

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 65, No. 22.

Read the full edition

IS IT CONSISTENT.?

We have received a circular from the Western Women's Christian Temperance Union of Detroit, asking us to publish six reasons why temperance unions should support the Detroit Journal. The first reason given is that “the Journal is the only daily paper published in the city that advocates the proper observance of the Sabbath.”
To this we demur at the very outset, on the ground of fact and Scripture. By the term “Sabbath,” of course Sunday is referred to. But Sunday is not the Sabbath. So far, therefore, from the Journal’s advocating the proper observance of the Sabbath, it does not advocate the Sabbath at all.
There is but one Sabbath, and there can be no other unless God shall see fit to institute another. But the only one he has given us is the original, Edenic, seventh-day Sabbath of the Lord our Creator. Men may try to set up another; but it will be in no sense divine, nothing but a gross idol. The stolid obliviousness which the church and the world persist in manifesting to the true distinction, and the real issue, in this matter, is indeed marvelous.
We are in favor of the “proper observance” of all days so far as the liquor traffic is concerned; and that is to prohibit such traffic on all days; not on Sunday only, but on every day of the week. Now, if a sentiment can be aroused sufficiently strong to secure and enforce a law closing the saloon on Sunday, cannot the same power just as easily close the saloon on all days of the week?—It assuredly can. Then why is this not done?—Simply because the preponderating influence in this sentiment is not for temperance, but for the Sunday!
But the plea is urged, “Wouldn’t you be glad to secure prohibition as far as possible, if it cannot be secured wholly? Wouldn’t it be best to prohibit the liquor traffic on Sunday, even if this prohibition cannot be secured on other days?” But this is putting the question in a false light. This is not the true alternative. The real question is this: Is it true temperance reform to work for the Sunday closing, and be content to stop with that, when the same power which accomplished that, could just as easily close the saloon on every day of the week? A true temperance sentiment seeks to do this, that is, shut the saloon upon all days; and just so far as it fails to do this, so far the temperance principle is lacking. And when all that can be secured is a closing of the saloons on Sunday alone, evidently it is not because they love intemperance less, but because they love the Sunday more. It is Sunday legislation pure and simple. It is bringing in a religious project under a false issue. We are for temperance always and everywhere, in its broadest, fullest, completest sense. But to the slipping in of religious legislation, and that, too, in behalf of an unscriptural institution, under the cloak of temperance, we have been, are, and ever shall be opposed.