HOW DOES HE KNOW!

7%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Aug 7, 1888

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 65, No. 32.

Read the full edition

HOW DOES HE KNOW!

The New York Evangelist sometime ago reported a sermon delivered by Prof. W. W. Prescott, the president of Battle Creek College, on the subject of education. A writer in the Vermont Chronicle, in referring to the report, takes occasion to offer some criticisms on the faith and methods of Seventh-day Adventists, to which it may not be out of place to call attention.
The writer in the Chronicle thinks that the denominational teaching of the Seventh-day Adventists “is as inconsistent with what they hold in common with the Christian church, as it is denominational.” Some may be curious to know on what such a singular statement is based; but he does not leave his readers in ignorance as to what he means to say, even though he may not support his statement by a single iota of proof. He says that “they [Adventists] allow, as do all others, that the mode of worship prescribed for one time and so obligatory then, has been changed.”
But wherein lies the inconsistency? Simply in this: that while admitting a change in the mode of worship since the old dispensation, the Adventists will not admit a change of the day of worship. Then, as though it were a matter that only need to be stated, for all to believe it, he says: “The obligation to worship God has not changed. This is continuous and perpetual, ever binding. But the mode, or manner, has been changed by the Lord of worship. So the time, at first the seventh day, has been changed to the first day by the Lord of time, who is also the Lord of the Sabbath.”
This is a very pretty statement, but it lacks the only essential to make it current, and that is the proof of its truthfulness. One might say the full moon is a green cheese, but the statement does not prove it, though such a theory is just as susceptible of proof as the one advanced in the foregoing quotation. It costs little effort to say a thing is as one would like to have it, but it is quite another thing to make such statements appear probable to the honest seeker after truth.
To show where the inconsistency really lies, let us quote a little further, and then compare that with another sentiment in the same paragraph. “The seventh day was set apart and observed, not because of the command from Sinai, for the seventh day was observed before this command. It was observed because of the example of the Creator, who finished his work, and rested on the seventh day.” Accepting this statement, we ask, If the Sabbath was kept before its proclamation on Sinai, and it was the same day, prior to the existence of the Jewish nation and the making of the old covenant, that it was after that covenant was made with the Jews, how does our contemporary account for that? When the new order of things came about, through the establishment of the Levitical priesthood, and the law regulating the sacrifices and the services of the sanctuary, why, we ask, in that change of worship, was not the day of the Sabbath changed, if such a change of the day must follow the change of worship instituted at the first advent of Christ? Let those answer who can.
Did not the Lord himself order the change in the form of worship? Is it not plainly written that the priesthood of those days was to be changed? Heb. 7: 12. Did not the Saviour tell the woman at the well, that the time was coming when Jerusalem would no longer be the particular place of worship? John 4: 21. Did not the apostle state that Christ himself had become our high priest in the courts of heaven? Heb. 8: 1-6. Is it not clearly taught that now “circumcision is nothing”? 1 Cor. 7: 19. But where, in all the sayings of Christ, or the writings of his inspired apostles, is it once said that the Sabbath was to be changed to the first day of the week? Why does not some evangelical critic put his finger on such a text, when offering strictures upon the teaching of Seventh-day Adventists? He who would only do so, instead of dealing in glittering generalities, would soon overthrow the work of Seventh-day Adventists. But until that is done, their work and influence will continue to enlarge, despite the unfavorable criticisms of the opposition.
But how much of the form of worship was changed at the first advent? One would almost think from the way some talk and write, that because a new dispensation was there ushered in, another entire plan of salvation was instituted, requiring less of the sinner than before. It is, however, to be presumed that our critic believes that the same God rules now, that controlled affairs then. Prayer is an essential form of worship; probably he believes it just as necessary to pray now, as in the old dispensation. Those who are so sure that all the forms of worship were changed at the first advent, and still keep up that antiquated custom, surely have somewhat to reform before charging others with inconsistency.
It is true that in the days before Christ, men offered the blood of victims to show their sorrow for sin, and their faith in the blood of Him who was to come. To-day the sinner pleads the blood of the real victim,—the Son of God,—for the same purpose. In this matter there was a change in the form of worship, simply because they looked forward to Christ yet to die, while we look back to the actual spilling of his blood. Each form of worship has to do only with the manifestation of one's faith in Christ, after his sins have been pointed out by the moral law, which is unalterable for all time. These changes have been referred to in foregoing quotations; but the Bible says nothing of a change on other points not directly connected with the ceremonies that pointed to the work of Christ.
How, then, came the time of the Sabbath to be changed? O, says our critic, by virtue of example. As the seventh day was observed because of God's example of resting on that day after finishing the work of creation, so Christ completed his work on the first day, leaving us an example to follow by observing that day. How strange that full-grown men can be found who will repeat such twaddle! Do such read their Bibles at all? It would hardly seem so; for if they did, they ought to know better than to make such statements. The merest novice in divine things knows that the work of Christ for sinners is not yet completed. For eighteen hundred years he has, as an advocate, pleaded the cases of repentant sinners before God, and will continue to do so until the last case that will ever be saved, has been presented there.
In what sense, then, was Christ's work finished on that first day that saw him leave the tomb? It may be said, in the sense of having finished his sufferings here on the earth. But even with that view, the statement is not correct. If it were, then what mean those significant words of the Son of God, “It is finished,” which he uttered amid the darkness and gloom of that day, in which on the cross he bowed his head in death? John 19: 30. That was the point of time at which his earthly sufferings ceased, and not upon the first day of the week.
Why do not those first-day advocates, who rest their theory on such assumptions, look up this matter; and if they still believe their own statements, commence the observance of that day on which the Saviour announced, “It is finished”? One imagines the response to such a question would be best met by saying, What folly to talk thus! So it is, but the only way to make such folly apparent to those who oppose the seventh-day rest, is to carry out their own deductions to a legitimate end; and they themselves can then see how senseless have been their inferences.
Once more. The author of the article under review says that we now have “the same example and authority for keeping the first day of the week as the day of rest and worship, that the Israelites of old had for observing the seventh—the example of the Lord in both cases.” But we challenge the truthfulness of the statement. Let any one point to a text that even hints such an example as our Lord's resting on the first day, and the point will be at once conceded. But such a thing cannot be done. After the Saviour said in his dying breath, “It is finished,” he did quietly rest on the Sabbath, in imitation of God's rest after finishing the work of creation. But on the first day, and early, too, in the morning, he arose and went about his Father's business. The Sabbath is the only day on which it is recorded that our Saviour ever rested.
But even if he had rested on the first day, without commanding his followers to do the same; what would that signify? The simple example of God's rest on the Sabbath was not enough to set it apart for man's observance. It was necessary to pronounce a blessing on the day, and then command its observance. But how far different was this from the way our critic states the matter, as before quoted. But in referring to that, we will have charity enough for the man to suppose he knew no better. And yet because such glaring statements are made by prominent men, they are accepted without question by a too credulous public.
J. O. CORLISS.