DEATH BY ELECTRICITY

50%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Jan 29, 1889

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 66, No. 5.

Read the full edition

DEATH BY ELECTRICITY.

The new law of the State of New York, ordering death by electricity as the punishment for capital offenses, went into effect January 1. So radical a change in the administration of the ultimate penalty will probably give rise to delays in the administration of justice. Certain clauses in its constitution will afford the counsel of criminals on trial for murder, a pretext for holding the law unconstitutional. Assuming the constitutionality of the law to be perfect and proved, are the sheriffs and prison officials of the State prepared to inflict the punishment? The very crudeness of hanging brought it within the scope of the commonest type of executioner. But the new method deals with one of the most refined and least understood sciences. Experiments have already been made upon dogs and other animals. A wide variation in personal coefficients of resistance and susceptibility to the current has been found to exist in them. The condition of the skin is the predominating cause of the first variation. A man whose body is warm from exercise, and who has a strong perspiratory action, will be of lower resistance than when the skin is dry. Again, the effect of the current will vary according to the nervous condition of the subject. This is an element which cannot be included in experiments on the lower animals. A criminal led to execution may be in a state of nervous tension that will very seriously modify the operation of electric shock. A perfect and certain method for the electrical slaying of human beings has not yet been evolved. Every prison where the law is carried out must be supplied with the most perfect electrical plant. Every connection must be of the best, and all must be kept in perfect order. The effects of disuse, the hardest of all deteriorating causes to combat in their influence upon machinery, must be guarded against. All this apparatus may stand idle from year to year, only to be used on the rare occasions of an execution. To apply and run the apparatus and to inspect every detail, a skilled electrician will be required. The voltage must be accurately determined, the number of alternations of current per second must be known, if the alternating current is to be used, and the resistance of the person to be killed should be determined. There should be no chance of a failure, and all must be definite and known. It remains to be seen whether a competent person will undertake a duty to which some measure of odium will inevitably attach. The successor of the present hangman can be depended on to make the fatal contact, but that is all. The electrodes must be attached to the person by or directly under the superintendence of the electrician. The struggles of the prisoner, by disturbing the position of the electrodes, may bring about the most deplorable results. As it is now, far too many executions by hanging fail, in the end, of quickly killing with little suffering. But where the vastly more complicated mechanism of an electric plant is depended on, the possibilities of a failure are largely multiplied. Death has been administered to dogs by suffocation in coal-gas, with perfect success. This death, as far as can be known, is absolutely painless. The writer has several times been rendered totally insensible by inhaling gas, and can testify to the efficacy of the anaesthesia produced. Under its influence a perfectly quiet relapse into unconsciousness ensues, the last memory of events being clear and unclouded. Some such method of inflicting the death penalty would seem far in advance of the electric process. There would be a quick and painless unconsciousness, and the exposure could be so long as to insure a fatal result. It could be applied in an ordinary cell, with no special apparatus, and could even be applied to the criminal while sleeping. It would, above all, be infallible and certain, and would not mar or deface the body. The latter is always liable to happen with electricity. But the law has been passed, and no provision has been made to carry it out. Apparatus is not provided, no competent specialists have been appointed to superintend its administration, and in the present state of affairs, the new law appears to amount to little more than an indefinite suspension of the death penalty for murder.—Scientific American.