Enthusiasm vs. Fanaticism

25%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Nov 27, 1888

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 65, No. 47.

Read the full edition

Enthusiasm vs. Fanaticism.

Public speakers often imagine that it is impossible to produce enthusiasm except by extravagance. But herein they err. Extravagance always reacts unfavorably, as respects both the speaker and the cause which he advocates. Perception of the situation, and a vivid delineation of it, with all the interest and sympathy which the case admits of, without the loss of rational coherence and accurate statement, will kindle enthusiasm while the speaker is on the floor, and will send the people away with grim determination to work for the cause, and a clear perception of how to do it. It is not the highest function of oratory to make a concourse already greatly excited, and of the speaker’s way of thinking, wild; but its highest achievement is, without destroying the fervor of the hearers, to guide them into right ideas of what is to be done, to convince those of a different opinion, and to send them away prepared to convince others. Speakers who utter what will not bear inspection lose the confidence of those whom they deceive; and those who use language which the case does not demand, especially personal language, excite sympathy for the cause or men traduced, never convince others, and delight only the less influential, the more ignorant and boisterous of their own adherents. There is not a party in the United States lately contending for the suffrages of the people, which has not been injured by the violence and rant of its advocates.
Just prior to the late war, a conversation occurred between two ministers. One said to the other: “You and I agree in our sentiments; and if I am correctly informed, you utter your sentiments unequivocally, and still you keep the peace with your congregation. Even if they don’t agree with you, they come to hear you. You preach abolition, don’t you?” “O yes, everybody who hears me knows that I am in favor of the abolition of slavery.” “Well, I can’t keep the peace with my people. They are nearly all down upon me now, and they say that as soon as the time comes around to vote, they will vote me out of my place; and I cannot understand it.” “Well,” said the minister first addressed, “I will come around sometime and hear you, and if I can see anything which accounts for the general dislike which all parties have of your preaching, I will frankly tell you.”
When a suitable occasion came, the visit was paid, the visiting brother arriving during the first prayer. After the usual appropriate supplications for a public congregation, the pastor said, “And, now, we commend unto thee the condition of four millions of our fellow-creatures ground down under the iron heel of slavery. We know, O Lord, that there are some people, even in this congregation, so low, base, and mean, that they don’t like to hear thy servant pray for the slaves; but, O Lord, all the powers of hell, much less such mean, tyrannical spirits as those which we have to contend with here, can’t close thy servant’s lips. He will pray for the slave, if he dies on his knees,” and much more of the same kind. He was taking advantage of a prayer addressed to the Deity, to use billingsgate against the people who were there, and who were unable to reply or defend themselves. Afterward, his friend told him that though he was an abolitionist, during that prayer he almost sympathized with the other side. The peculiarity in this brother was constitutional. Everywhere he went, he broke up congregations, though he had great natural abilities. He denounced all offenses, whether against God’s law or simple propriety, in the unvarying tone of harsh malediction. It was said of him by a worthy brother that all that preceded the last utterance of the service was malediction, but the discourses were invariably closed with the benediction. He has long since retired from the ministry, but every generation has representatives of that class. Yet this man could have uttered the same ideas with moderation and candor, and carried his congregation with him. Force is not the equivalent of violence, nor are earnestness and maniacal excitement convertible terms; fidelity is not bitterness, nor hurling epithets from a pulpit a manifestation of courage. “Enthusiasm, does it; fanaticism overdoes it.”—Religious Intelligencer.