IOWA

10%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Nov 20, 1888

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 65, No. 46.

Read the full edition

IOWA

ST. CHARLES.—A series of tent-meetings was recently held here. This village is situated in the midst of an intelligent and thriving farming community. Bro. W. A. Colcord, assisted by Bro. M. K. Howe, conducted the meetings. The attendance and interest from the village and community were large and general. Our books sold well. The zeal shown by the people in rendering aid in support of the work was truly commendable. Ten or twelve signified their willingness, by the help of the Saviour, to show a godly respect for the “commandments of God and the faith of Jesus.” Rev. 14:12.
It was my privilege to visit this place three times during the meetings. An incident during my last visit should be mentioned; viz., Prof. Dungan’s effort to refute our positions on the Sabbath question. Some of the people of St. Charles evidently hoped that the Bible did sustain Sunday-keeping, and they thought that Prof. Dungan, of Drake University, Des Moines, could make it so appear. They accordingly entered into negotiations with him, and for twenty dollars he agreed to go to that place and make his effort. On his arrival, Oct. 6, his contractors required him to present his positions in our tent, and also to divide time with Bro. Colcord. This was a surprise to the Professor, and he expressed his sore disappointment when he came to speak.
Arrangements were made for five sessions of two hours each, the Professor to occupy the first hour of each service, and Bro. Colcord the second, in reply. Two meetings were held on Sabbath and three on Sunday, the services closing Sunday night, Oct. 7. The Professor followed the line of argument given in his book. Scarcely anything new was presented, and his old positions surely never appeared to greater disadvantage. To illustrate: On page 27 of his work, “Sabbath or Lord’s Day? Which?” Prof. Dungan says, “The average Advent lecturer hangs his chart on the wall, and every time he can find the word ‘command’ or ‘commandment,’ he points to the chart, as if to impress it upon the minds of his hearers that they are being spoken of. With them, for a man to sin, he must absolutely violate law; and that he cannot do where there is no law.”
Bro. Colcord called his attention to this, and wished to know if it was a thing peculiar to the Adventists to require the existence of a law in order to commit sin. He wished to know if, in the face of God’s definite statements that “where no law is there is no transgression,” and “sin is the transgression of the law,” the Professor claimed that he and his people could sin without transgressing law? On being pressed for an answer, he stated that he did not, and that there could be no sin without law, thus virtually admitting that this was not a matter peculiar to the Adventist people, and that the statement in his book was calculated to mislead and prejudice, without cause.
The Professor, in his greatest extremity, appealed to history for support of his positions, when Bro. Colcord made the bold charge that Prof. Dungan was unreliable as a historian. Bro. Colcord’s evidence: 1. Prof. Dungan stated in his debate with Eld. Pegg at Winterset, that Eld. J. N. Andrews had given a quotation from Neander that no dead man had ever seen, neither any living man would see. Eld. Pegg then produced the original work containing the identical quotation. 2. On page 62 of Prof. Dungan’s “Sabbath or Lord’s Day? Which?” he gives a quotation purporting to be from Tertullian, which he claims Eld. Andrews suppressed in his “History of the Sabbath.” He quotes it, however, without giving any reference. Bro. Colcord earnestly urged him to produce it from any of Tertullian’s writings, or to give the reference to it. He finally, in his last speech, admitted that it was not to be found in the writings of that author. Bro. Colcord then asked how such a man and such a book could be considered as authority among the people, and, further, what weight his criticisms of Eld. Andrews’ “History of the Sabbath” could have?
Eld. Dungan, in “Sabbath or Lord’s Day? Which?” says of Eld. Andrews, “I know of no work more deserving of censure for unfairness than the ‘History of the Sabbath’ by J. N. Andrews, . . . he finds history which other men cannot find.” —page 67. On page 8, he says of him, “It is a strain on my charity not to think of him as deliberately falsifying history.” The Professor was asked to show where in the Bible the ten commandments are once called the first or old covenant; to show that they are a set of “commandments contained in ordinances;” that any of them are “against us;” that it is a sin to labor on the first day of the week; that if the fourth commandment had always been kept by all for the purpose it was designed,—a memorial of the true God, the Creator, and his works,—there could ever have been an atheist, a heathen, or an idolater; and that, if such good results would have followed its observance, how it can be a bad commandment. To none of these did he even attempt an answer.
At the last meeting, immediately after the close of Bro. Colcord’s address, the discussion then being ended as per arrangements before it began, an effort was made to vote Prof. Dungan an extra half hour to review Bro. Colcord. The people, twenty to one, voted the measure in the quickest possible time. It was afterward developed that Prof. Dungan knew of such a plan being set on foot by some of his friends before the final meeting began, and his evident expectation of having the opportunity of making a closing address caused him to make his weakest and most fragmentary effort at the last.
The interest in the investigation was intense. Hundreds were unable at the last session to gain admittance to our tent. The Professor’s effort was a disappointment to many. It aided materially in the establishment of our work at that place.
L. T. NICOLA.