ERRONEOUS VIEWS OF LIBERTY

8%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Dec 4, 1888

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 65, No. 48.

Read the full edition

ERRONEOUS VIEWS OF LIBERTY.

BY W. A. BLAKELY.
Liberty of conscience is the most sacred right of man. History proves, by almost innumerable instances, that there are those who will give up every other right—yes, even the right of life itself—rather than surrender the right of religious liberty, and submit to what their conscience condemns as wrong. The reason is plain: the conscience, according to Webster, is “the faculty, power, or principle which decides on the lawfulness or unlawfulness of our actions and affections, and approves or condemns them; the moral faculty; the moral sense.” Hence, what an individual’s conscience approves is believed by him to be the will of God; and every conscientious person believes that the will of God must be obeyed—and with good reason,—let the consequences be what they may. The Christian’s duty, when religious rights are infringed upon by any human requirement, was plainly expressed by inspiration before the Jewish Sanhedrin, nearly two thousand years ago, in these words: “We ought to obey God rather than men;” and it is a truth fixed more firmly in the catalogue of human rights than is the mighty rock of Gibraltar on the solid structure of terra firma. In fact, it is held to be a self-evident truth by the American people, and has been a characteristic of this Government ever since its formation. It is denied only by bigoted religionists, who have a zeal of God, but not according to knowledge.
The immortal Declaration of Independence states this truth in a plain and forcible manner: “We hold these truths to be self-evident—that all men are created equal; that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable rights; that among these are life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness.” Yet, notwithstanding the manifest right of each individual to worship his Creator according to the dictates of his own conscience, that very right has been trampled under foot and disregarded more by earthly governments than any other right whatever. There are two reasons for this. One is, there are a great many persons in this world who have no care for the rights of others, and who are so completely wrapped up in self that they are determined to accomplish their objects, no matter how much they trample upon the rights of others: the other reason, which, charitably speaking, is much more general, is that the public mind has always entertained erroneous views (when it has given thought enough to the subject to entertain views at all) in regard to what the real rights of conscience are.
The first class are bigoted, self-conceited individuals, who are at all times very conspicuous for their supreme love of self, and for their utter disregard for the rights and opinions of others; they consider their own ideas the infallible standard of right. If any one differs with them in the meaning of scriptures which they deem important, they can hardly find words to express their condemnation of such an individual; and if any one dare go so far as to oppose them or their work, or make their errors manifest, no matter if that person be a Christian in every sense of the word, they will immediately denounce him as an “atheist,” “infidel,” or “heretic;” and if the daring individual is not summarily punished by some law at their hands, it is because the law cannot be made to reach him. In such cases, they will then do all in their power to have laws enacted which will reach him. According to the ideas of these persons, those whom they consider infidels or atheists have no rights under the sun. These persons seldom reason soundly, and hence they always remain bigoted, never being satisfied unless they are persecuting their opponents—and very seldom then. Bigoted they are, and bigoted they will remain; for no one else can help them, and they will not help themselves.
The second class entertain wrong views as a result of early impressions received, and sometimes from having obtained an erroneous education by reading largely from European writers on civil government, who have never fully extricated themselves from the dense labyrinth of the false views on this subject which have become so firmly implanted in the mind of the European world in general. In a work entitled, “The Liberties of America,” by H. H. Warner, Esq., of New York, are a few expressions which might be used to illustrate. Speaking of differences in religious views, he says:—
If private views run counter to the general mind in a matter of principle, common sense teaches what the result must be. The laws then go with the prevailing sentiment. Order demands it. The genius of free government demands it. Men, indeed, are not to be enforced in their religious activities; but there are things in plenty which they may be required at their peril to refrain from doing, because incompatible with the economy which a Christian people think proper to maintain.
This argument, however, is a fallacy; for rights are infringed upon just as much when one is compelled “to refrain from doing” what his conscience tells him it is his duty to do, as when he is compelled to do what he considers to be wrong. According to the rule Mr. Warner lays down, individuals should not be compelled to worship one in whom they do not believe; but they may be compelled to refrain from worshiping one in whom they do believe. To illustrate: if a Christian lived where Jews had control of the government, the Christian, according to his argument, could not be compelled to worship contrary to his will; but if his views taught him to worship Christ—then what? His “views run counter to the general mind in a matter of principle,—common sense teaches what the result must be. The laws then go with the prevailing sentiment.” What a grand view of religious liberty! The stoning of Stephen is justified, and Saul was a means of carrying out what “order” and “the genius of a free government demanded?” Saul was given authority, not to enforce any one in their “religious activities,” but he “required them at their peril to refrain from doing” that which ran counter to the general mind. Such doctrine is not religious liberty—far from it—it can only be termed religious despotism; for to a greater or less extent, it endeavors to compel the minority to worship as the majority worship, whether right or not. An individual’s religious rights allow him, whether he stand alone or with the whole nation, to worship whom he pleases, when he pleases, and where he pleases; and to be protected in this worship—as long as he does not trespass upon the rights of another; for no one has a right to interfere with, or in any way abridge, the rights of another.
In illustrating his position, Mr. Warner mentions the Sunday question, maintaining that Sabbatarians may not be compelled to work on the seventh-day, but that they may be compelled to refrain from labor on the first day; and that this is compatible with justice, and with the spirit of religious freedom as laid down in American institutions.
But this is not true. Reason teaches that one individual has just as much right to his opinion as another has to his; and if opinions differ in matters pertaining only to religion, no laws should be made to compel either individual to do or to refrain from doing. The one is compelling as much as the other. As previously quoted, the Declaration of Independence, the very foundation-stone of American liberty, says that “all men are created equal; that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable rights; that among these are life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness; that to secure these rights governments are instituted among men.” Surely, then, an individual’s unalienable rights cannot be taken from him because he belongs to the minority. If I have a religious right to work six days, and then rest one, it is evident that all others have the same religious right; and if I choose the first day on which to rest, no one has a right to molest me; and if my friend chooses the seventh day as his day of rest and worship, no one has a right to molest him. And if I work on his day of worship without molesting him, no one has a right to stop or hinder me in my work; nor has any one a right to stop or hinder him if he works on my day of worship. This is equality and justice. But it is neither justice nor equality to say that because I choose the first day of the week on which to rest, that I may have the other six days on which to work, while my friend who chooses the seventh day, on account of conscience, must rest on the first also—thus giving him only five days in which he can work for a livelihood.
The principle is this: all citizens of this country are on an equality; all have the same rights; all are entitled to the same privileges; the Sabbatarian observes the seventh day as a religious act in accordance with what he believes to be the commandment of God; the Sunday-keeper observes the first day for the same reason; civil government is not to decide which is right, and then say that the party in the wrong must also observe the day of the party that is in the right; but the civil government must protect both parties in their religious meetings on whatever day, the same as it should any public assembly, religious or secular. Thus all are on an equality before the law. All have their rights—the rights of none are abridged.
But if the majority make laws compelling the minority to rest or to worship on another rest day besides their own, that very moment the rights of the minority are abridged, and the principles of liberty are set aside. “But,” says one, “the minority are not compelled to work on their Sabbath, but simply to refrain from working on our Sabbath.” And so argues Mr. Warner. But how far may this argument be carried? If the Sabbatarians in question may be compelled to “refrain from working” one day, why not two? and if two, why not three? and if three, why not six? How much time is there to which he has a right? or has he no rights? If he does have rights, where do they come in?
Rights never conflict. Hence, a nation, or a majority of persons in a nation, never has the right to interfere in the least degree with the rights of a single individual. Every one is entitled to “life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness.” So if laws be made which abridge the rights of the minority, no matter how small or how weak that minority may be, those laws are unjust, and incompatible with the principles of just government.