SUNDAY CHAMPIONS ON THE RETREAT.
By W. A. Colcord
It is a grand thing to be on the side of truth, for that is the side of victory. No matter in what obscurity it may arise, or how much opposition it may have, it will struggle along until it vindicates itself, and vanquishes its foes. To be on the side of error is to be on the side of chagrin, retreat, and final defeat. To advocate the observance of the first day of the week is to be on that side. Everything points that way. For over forty years the struggle has been going on. But at each renewed contest, the power of truth has been felt, and the weakness of error made more manifest. The time was when ministers would fearlessly enter the conflict, and affirm that Christ changed the Sabbath. Others would meet the issue upon the seventh-part-of-time hypothesis. Still others would brave the consequences upon the conjecture that Sunday is the seventh day. But nearly all these champions have retired from the field. Few now undertake to fight the battle with any of these old, shattered weapons. The majority of the Protestant denominations have learned that the best way to preserve the Sunday is to say nothing about it. Of later years, the antinomian view has been adopted by some, as a last resort to dispose of the troublesome question. Its advocates entered the field with a high hand, confident of certain victory. But that theory, after striking out, not simply one, but all of God's ten words, which, in the language of Alexander Campbell, “not only in the Old Testament, but in all revelation, are the most emphatically regarded as the synopsis of all religion and morality,” has also failed to sustain the Sunday, and to find the long-looked-for text. Consequently, as might be expected, they, too, are becoming weary of the unequal contest. This is quite plainly confessed by one of its heretofore prominent advocates, Eld. D. R. Lucas, of the Christian Oracle, to whom reference has several times been made in the columns of the REVIEW. About a year ago, in that paper, under the heading, “Deacon Frater’s Wisdom,” he said:— The Seventh-day Adventists are so persistent about the question of the Sabbath, or a rest, that the Deacon is tempted to ask them to “give us a rest.” Their wearisome pettifogging on the question makes him weary. This is quite suggestive. But later developments show that the “Deacon” has indeed become exceedingly “weary” of trying to show up Sunday sacredness. Not long before this, he had a discussion with the youngest Seventh-day Adventist minister in the State of Iowa; but he left one session short. Since then he has engaged in a discussion with Eld. J. H. Morrison, at Abingdon, Ia. In this, he stopped two sessions short on the Sunday side. Not liking the impression that went out from this course on his part, he challenged for another discussion, eight sessions in length, at any time and place, agreeing in this one to “debate just as long as the Adventist may wish.” The challenge was accepted, time and place selected, and, lo and behold, this time Eld. Lucas fails to appear at all. However others may look upon it, we think it is a sure indication that this first-day champion has surely become weary of the contest, and is retiring from the field. It is only another evidence that no position or arguments can be successfully used against the Sabbath of the Lord, or in favor of a day of only human origin, simply because one is founded upon truth, and the other upon error. In trying to excuse himself for his last failure, Eld. Lucas complains that the time selected by Eld. Morrison was not when he expected it to be. He says, “We published a challenge to meet him at once, at any time and place, supposing, of course, that he was ready. This was in July.”—Oracle, Dec. 13. This, indeed, is a very strange phraseology of the challenge, as well as a remarkable combination of words in the English language. The challenge was to “meet Mr. Morrison at any time and place he may select.”—Oracle, July 12. He now has tucked in the words “at once.” But that makes a very strange expression of it: “at once at any time.” What does that mean? We are unable to combine the two thoughts into one, if Eld. Lucas has the two expressions. If he meant at once, why did he not say so? But after saying “at any time,” why did he not let it be at any time? According to his version, “at any time” means at once, and for Eld. Morrison to select the time, is for him to select it. That this excuse is not a valid one, and that Eld. Lucas did not expect, when he made the challenge, that the discussion was necessarily to come off at once, or even in the month of July, is apparent from the fact that in the challenge itself he passed over into the month of August, and exempted a certain amount of time. It is a very difficult matter to suit a man who does not wish to be suited. The very evident fact is that Eld. Lucas was not anxious to discuss the question with Eld. Morrison again, especially at his own home, and at a time when the Drake University was in session. There was too much interest at stake, and the liabilities were not in his favor. The false statements and untruthful accusations which he had made through the Oracle, he evidently did not care to meet before his own people and fellow-citizens. At the close of the Abingdon discussion last March, Eld. Morrison predicted that Eld. Lucas would never meet any of our people again upon the same terms and propositions; and though he has since had an opportunity to do so, and even thrown out a challenge stating that he would do so, he never has, and likely never will. But Eld. Lucas is not so much to be blamed for it, after all. We should not want to either, if we had to take his side of the question. He is simply on the wrong side. The conflict is not between men, but between truth and error. Men choose their principles, and are responsible for their choice. But the most learned men and the most gifted mortals cannot successfully demonstrate error to be truth.