AdventAI

A SENATOR’S OPINION.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 66, No. 3., January 15, 1889

The same question which is now before Congress, respecting a restrictive law concerning the observance of the first day of the week, was up in 1885, as it had also been in former years. In the St. Louis Globe-Democrat of March 11, of 1885, there was published an interesting address by Senator McGinnis, of Jefferson, Mo., from which we quote the following paragraphs:—

“Attempts have been made from time to time, ever since the Government was established, to induce Congress to repeal the regulations under which the mails are carried on Sunday. The State papers of the Post-office Department include many petitions from grave religious bodies and others in all parts of the country, asking for such legislation. Many of these petitions have been reported on by committees of Congress, and these reports, as well as many remonstrances against the prayer of the petitioners, are also to be found among the State papers of the Post-office Department. Some of these reports, as well as some of the remonstrances, contain such elevated sentiments of patriotism and such sound measures of statesmanship that their perusal will well repay every student of political science. Their sentiments find a ready response in the heart of every one jealous of any attempted encroachment upon the liberties of the people.

“On the 5th of March, 1830, Col. R. M. Johnson, of Kentucky (a name famous in the annals of Democracy), Chairman of the House Committee on Post-offices and Post Roads, to whom had been referred many of the memorials and remonstrances referred to, made a report from which I will read some extracts, which I recommend to the careful consideration of the Senate:—

“The memorialists regard the first day of the week as a day set apart by the Creator for religious exercises, and consider the transportation of the mails and the opening of post-offices on that day the violation of a religious duty, and call for a suppression of the practice. Others, by counter-memorials, are known to entertain a different sentiment, believing that no one day of the week is holier than another. Others, holding the universality and immutability of the Jewish decalogue, believe in the sanctity of the seventh day of the week as a day of religious devotion, and by their memorial now before the committee, they also request that it may be set apart for religious purposes. Each has hitherto been left to the exercise of his own opinion, and it has been regarded as the proper business of the Government to protect all, and determine for none. But the attempt is now made to bring about a greater uniformity, at least in practice; and as argument has failed, the Government has been called upon to interpose its authority to settle the controversy. Congress acts under a Constitution of delegated and limited powers. The committee look in vain to that instrument for a delegation of powers authorizing this body to inquire and determine what part of time, or whether any, has been set apart by the Almighty for exercises. On the contrary, among the few prohibitions which it contains, is one that prohibits a religious test, and another which declares that Congress shall pass no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof. The committee might here rest the argument, upon the ground that the question referred to them does not come within the cognizance of Congress, but the perseverance and zeal with which the memorialists pursue their object, seem to require a further elucidation of the subject; and as the opposers of Sunday mails disclaim all intention to unite church and state, the committee do not feel disposed to impugn their motives; and whatever may be advanced in opposition to the measure will arise from the fears entertained of its fatal tendency to the peace and happiness of the nation.”

“The catastrophies of other nations furnished the framers of the Constitution a beacon of awful warning, and they have evinced the greatest possible care in guarding against the same evil. . . . If Congress shall, by the authority of law, sanction the measure recommended, it would constitute a legislative decision of a religious controversy in which even Christians themselves are at issue. However suited such decisions may be to an unchastened council, it is incompatible with a republican legislature, which is purely for political and not religious purposes. In our individual character, we all entertain opinions, and pursue a corresponding practice upon the subject of religion. However diversified these may be, we all harmonize as citizens, while each is willing that the other shall enjoy the same liberty which he claims for himself. But, in our representative character, our individual character is lost. The individual acts for himself, the representative for his constituents. He is chosen to represent their political and not their religious views; to guard the rights of man, not to restrict the rights of conscience. Despots may regard their subjects as their property, and usurp the divine prerogative of prescribing their religious faith; but the history of the world furnishes the melancholy demonstration that the disposition of one man to coerce the religious homage of another, springs from an unchastened ambition, rather than a sincere devotion to any religion.”

“The principles of our Government do not recognize in the majority any authority over the minority, except in matters which regard the conduct of man to his fellow-man. A Jewish monarch, by grasping the holy censer, lost both his scepter and his freedom. A destiny as little to be envied may be the lot of the American people, who hold sovereignty of power, if they, in the person of their representatives, shall attempt to unite, in the remotest degree, church and state. From the earliest period of time, religious teachers have attained great ascendancy over the minds of the people, and in every nation, ancient or modern, whether pagan, Mohammedan, or Christian, have succeeded in the incorporation of their religious tenets with the political institutions of their country. The Persian idols, the Grecian oracles, the Roman auguries and the modern priesthood of Europe have all, in their turn, been the subject of popular adulation and the agents of political deception. If the measure recommended should be adopted, it would be difficult for human sagacity to foresee how rapid would be the succession, or how numerous the train of measures which might follow, involving the dearest rights of all—the rights of conscience. It is perhaps fortunate for our country that the proposition should have been made at this early period, while the spirit of the Revolution yet exists in full vigor. Religious zeal enlists the strongest prejudices of the human mind, and, when misdirected, excites the worst passions of our nature, under the delusive pretext of doing God’s service. Nothing so influences the heart to deeds of rapine and blood, nothing is so incessant in its toils, so persevering in its determinations, so appalling in its course, so dangerous in its consequences. The equality of rights secured by the Constitution may bid defiance to mere political tyrants, but the robe of sanctity too often glitters to deceive. The Constitution regards the conscience of the Jew as sacred as that of the Christian, and gives no more authority to adopt a measure affecting the conscience of a solitary individual than that of a whole community. That representative who would violate this principle would lose his delegated character, and forfeit the confidence of his constituents. If Congress shall declare the first day of the week holy, it will not convince the Jew nor the Sabbatarian. It will dissatisfy both, and consequently convert neither. Human power may extort vain sacrifices, but the Deity alone can command the affections of the heart.”

  • *

“Your memorialists confess themselves incapable of conceiving any method of establishing a religion, unless it be by the establishment of its tenets; nor are they able to discover any principle which authorizes your honorable bodies to make one dogma of Christians part and parcel of the law of the land, which does not also justify the transposition of their entire creed into the civil code. A religion thus taken into special favor of the legislature, and its doctrines, rights, and ceremonies ratified and promulgated by act of legislation, would constitute an establishment as firm and as perfect as the most zealous bigot could well desire. It would require but an additional act, enforcing conformity upon the citizen under pains and penalties, to vie with the corrupt establishments of Europe during the darkest periods of ecclesiastical tyranny. Such are the theoretical results of the principle assumed by the petitioners, and such might be its practical consequences. Your memorialists are, therefore, constrained to believe that the proposed measure may justly be classed under that species of pernicious legislation against which the prohibitory clause of the Constitution just mentioned is specially directed.”

“As before stated, the example of the old Virginia statute ‘against profaning the holy Sabbath day,’ illustrates the purpose of all these Sunday laws. Their object, one and all, is to enforce the religious observance of Sunday. This certainly cannot be justified by the word of God, for the command in the decalogue to ‘remember the Sabbath day, to keep it holy,’ had reference to the seventh day only. And I challenge the Evangelical Alliance to find a line in the Bible authorizing the transfer of the force of this divine command from the seventh to the first day of the week. . . . Laws to enforce the religious observance of the Sabbath or Sunday cannot be justified under our form of government, where there is a complete disseverance of church and state. The state has as much power to declare by law that a citizen shall go to church on Sunday, for moral or religious reasons, as to enact that he shall abstain from his usual avocations on that day, for the same reasons. Once admit the right of the state to legislate upon the subject at all, and, logically, there can be no limit to the exercise of that right. Let legislation begin by providing that the citizen shall cease from labor, traffic, and travel on Sunday, and it may logically proceed to the enactment of a law that he shall go to church on Sunday, then of one that he shall aid in building the church, and of another that he shall help to support the minister, and so on, until the regulation shall extend so far as to point out the particular faith he shall subscribe to, and the special church he shall attend and support.”

  • *

“When those arrogant pretenders to the estate and sanctity of followers of the meek and lowly Jesus abandon all attempts to make men moral by the futile experiment of legal enactments, and return to the course pointed out in the gospel, they may hope to receive, as they will then merit, the good opinion of all good men; whereas now they are looked upon with just suspicion, at least by all those who are jealous of every attempt at ecclesiastical interference with the civil authority.”