What Does Paul here Say Was Abolished?
(Continued.)
We affirm that no man can argue the abolition of the law of God, from 2 Corinthians 3, without doing violence to the grammar of the chapter, misconstruing the language, and perverting its meaning.
To prove this, let us briefly review the chapter from the beginning, that we may make the standpoint of the apostle our own, may enter into the spirit of his letter, and grasp the object of his argument. By keeping his object steadily in view, and treating his subject as a whole, with all its parts duly related, instead of building up theories on separate and isolated clauses, one may be able, we believe, to arrive at a clear perception, and a correct understanding, of this much-mooted portion of Scripture.
In the first verse he says: “Do we begin again to commend ourselves? or need we, as some others, epistles of commendation to you, or letters of commendation from you? Ye are our epistle written in our hearts, known and read of all men.” This language clearly introduces the questions which he seems to be aware were agitating the minds of the Corinthian brethren; namely, “Has Paul been intrusted with a divine mission? and if so, what proof is he able to give of his calling?”
In answer, the apostle appeals to his own work, to the results of his ministry, as the proof which he has to give. The Corinthian church was itself a monument of his labors, and a sufficient evidence that he had received his commission from the Lord. He virtually said to them, “Behold my work; and when you consider that, I do not need to commend myself to you, nor do I need letters from others to you, nor letters from you to others, to recommend me to their confidence. There are the fruits of my labors; they are my credentials.”
He then proceeds to set forth the spiritual nature of his work, and, in doing so, reveals the beautiful fact that—
The Epistle of Christ Is the Law of God,
written in the hearts of believers. This appears from his language in verse 3: “Forasmuch as ye are manifestly declared to be the epistle of Christ ministered by us, written not with ink, but with the Spirit of the living God; not in tables of stone, but in the fleshy tables of the heart.”
The apostle had been the means, in the hands of God, of bringing these Corinthians to Christ under the provisions of the new covenant; and when persons are thus converted, what is it that is written in their hearts?—The law of God; for that is the great work promised in the prophecy of the new covenant: “I will put my laws into their mind, and write them in their hearts.” Heb. 8:10, etc. But this is a work which can be wrought only by Christ through the operation of the Holy Spirit. Therefore when a person gives evidence that the law has been written in his heart, he gives evidence that Christ has been working for him; and through the change thus effected, such individual becomes, as it were, an epistle from Christ, declaring to all men what the power of the gospel is able to accomplish.
And because, in case of the Corinthians, Paul had been instrumental in this work, he says, “ministered by us;” that is, he had been the minister in the work of causing the Corinthian church to stand as an epistle from Christ, read of all men, on account of their having the law written in their hearts. And secondarily, in so far as Paul’s instrumentality in the matter was known, they were his epistle, known and read of all men. His declaration that they were written in his heart very naturally refers to the affection and love he had for them, as his children in the Lord. But the root and trunk, flower and fruit, of all that transaction and that relationship, was the fact that they had had the law of God written in their hearts by the provisions of the gospel.
Verses 4 and 5: “And such trust have we through Christ to God-ward: not that we are sufficient of ourselves to think anything as of ourselves; but our sufficiency is of God.” In this language the apostle expresses the complete confidence and assurance that he entertained that they were such true and genuine converts as he had represented; but he would not have any of the credit of this work attributed to himself. He would not “think,” or reckon, anything to have been accomplished of himself, in his own strength; but his sufficiency, whatever he was able to accomplish, was of God.
By this thought he is now led to state the position to which the Lord has called the gospel minister. This he does in verse 6, as follows: “Who also hath made us able ministers of the new testament; not of the letter, but of the spirit; for the letter killeth, but the spirit giveth life.” The “new testament” of which he here speaks is the “new covenant” (Gr. diathēkē). The operation of the new covenant, so far as it pertains to man’s probationary state, is to provide mercy for his unrighteousness. Heb. 8:12. This is the “spirit” of this covenant. And this is all pertaining to it that men can minister; for the apostle says that it is not committed to them to minister the “letter.” The new covenant has its “letter” as well as the old. But the letter being that which causes death (“the letter killeth”), that is held in abeyance till all men shall have made their choice in regard to its “spirit,” that is, in regard to its offers of mercy and life. Those who accept its spirit will never suffer its letter; but upon those who reject its spirit, the letter will at last take its course, in the second death.
The expression, “the letter killeth,” is general, and applies alike to the old covenant and the new. Some mistakenly read verse 6 as though the “letter” meant the old covenant, and the “spirit” the new, thus: “Who also hath made us able ministers of the new covenant; not of the (letter) old covenant, but of the (spirit) new covenant; for the (letter) old covenant killeth, but the (spirit) new covenant giveth life.” Such an application utterly destroys the sense of the passage; for, long years before Paul penned this language, the old covenant had passed away; and it would be absurd in him to say that he was not a minister of the old covenant, when there was no old covenant of which he could be a minister. No; he speaks of two features of the new covenant, of one of which he had been made a minister, of the other, not; he was a minister of the “spirit” of the new covenant, but not of the “letter” of the new covenant.
As the “letter” is that which causes death, both under the old covenant and the new, we can at once determine what is meant by that term; for the law of God is the great instrument that inflicts death; and that must therefore be the letter that killeth. That is its office. True, it is the standard of righteousness, but its only operation is to condemn sin, and demand the life of the transgressor. He, therefore, who should undertake to minister the letter, would have on his hands the obligation to execute the penalty of the law.
The fact that Paul, in setting forth the work of the minister under the new covenant, takes pains to state so explicitly that he is not a minister of the letter of that covenant, would imply that the ministers of the former covenant did minister the letter of that covenant. And such was the case, so far as that work can be performed by men.
Under the old covenant the form of government was a theocracy. God was their ruler in every sense—in their secular and temporal affairs as well as their spiritual. He of course could have no other rule of government but his law; and this law, under that arrangement, performed the double office of moral law and civil law; and the people sustained a double relation to it: first, as morally responsible beings, accountable to God as their creator; secondly, as citizens of the State, accountable to the authority of the State. But here the king of the nation, as a nation, was God; and the Constitution of the nation was his law. In its civil capacity, this law must have penalties to be executed by God’s appointed ministers of justice here among men. So we find the penalty of death attached to a violation of every one of the ten commandments, as witness the following scriptures:—
First commandment, Deut. 13:6–10; Ex. 22:20; second commandment, Deut. 13:12–16; third commandment, Lev. 24:16, 22, 23; fourth commandment, Num. 15:32–36; fifth commandment, Lev. 20:9; sixth commandment, Lev. 24:17, 21; seventh commandment, Lev. 20:10; eighth commandment, Josh. 7:20, 21, 25; ninth commandment, Deut. 19:16, 17, 19, 21; tenth commandment, Josh. 7:20, 25; all the commandments, Num. 15:30, 31.
And under that covenant the ministers of the Lord were the ones appointed to judge the people and to execute the laws. But when the penalty of death was executed upon offenders as citizens of the commonwealth, that did not cancel the account which the same individuals have to render at the bar of God, as creatures, in a higher relation, morally accountable to him. But this arrangement was a part of the old covenant, and this execution of the laws was ministering the “letter” of that covenant so far as man could do it.
And the old covenant also had its “spirit,” to which Paul’s rule—“the spirit giveth life”—would likewise apply. But in this case we must take it, subject to the imperfections and limitations of that covenant. Its offer of life was couched in the law of Moses, and depended on the value of animal sacrifices. But of these sacrifices Paul elsewhere speaks as follows: “In those sacrifices there is remembrance again made of sins every year. For it is not possible that the blood of bulls and of goats should take away sins.” Heb. 10:3, 4.
Thus sins were held in remembrance, but not put away; hence in itself the arrangement was of no value. Its efficacy lay in the fact that it was leading on to something better, a shadow of good things to come, a medium for the time then present, for the manifestation of faith in a Redeemer to come, and the expression of a desire to have an interest in a better covenant to which that would finally give place. It set forth Christ in type, and life in shadow. But even this provision for faith was interwoven with that element which pertains to the “letter;” for “he that despised Moses’s law died without mercy under two or three witnesses.” Heb. 10:28.
Such was the old covenant, and such the prominent place which the ministration of the “letter” held therein. Under the new covenant there is as yet no ministration of the “letter.” The execution of the penalty of the law, God reserves to himself. “Vengeance belongeth unto me; I will recompense, saith the Lord.” Heb. 10:30. He commits to his servants the work of ministering the “spirit” of this covenant; that is, to proclaim its offers of life and salvation through Christ. “The Lord is that spirit” (2 Cor. 3:17), and they are ministers of Christ. The civil magistrate enforces and executes laws; but they are the laws of the land, not the laws of God as such. His work has no connection with the new covenant, and he is not “ministering the letter” of that covenant. We are now having only the ministry of its spirit; we shall in due time have that of its letter, when the Lord avenges all the evil done against him.
Having thus shown the difference in the nature of the two covenants, and the different work which the minister of God has to do under each, respectively, the apostle proceeds to compare the glory of the two systems.
(To be continued.)