THE “CHRISTIAN SABBATH” IS UN-CHRISTIAN

6%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Nov 13, 1888

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 65, No. 45.

Read the full edition

THE “CHRISTIAN SABBATH” IS UN-CHRISTIAN.

BY F. A. ROWE.
We use the term “Christian Sabbath” in its usual application, as synonymous with Sunday. It is unnecessary to cite instances showing that this is the day ordinarily signified by that expression. They abound in all the sermons and popular religious literature of the time. It is the only day thus designated by those who hold it to be of sacred obligation upon Christians. Its only possible rival in Christendom is Saturday, which is called the “Jewish Sabbath” by observers of the first day, though neither “Jewish Sabbath” nor “Christian Sabbath” are terms that can be found in the word of God.
We can better decide whether this so-called “Christian Sabbath” is Christian in its character, by observing the characteristics of that which is confessedly Christian. Webster gives three definitions, which we quote in full, so that its meaning may be obvious:—
“1. Pertaining to Christ or his religion; as, Christian doctrine.
“2. Professing Christianity; as, a Christian people.
“3. Pertaining to the church; ecclesiastical; as, a Christian court.”
It is evident that only the first and third definitions can concern us in this question. It is evident also that whatever is Christian is inculcated either by precept or example in the Bible, as something belonging to the duty of Christian people. A thing may be Christian, because it is a matter of obligation upon Christians as well as all other men, or because it is an obligation upon Christians exclusively. The law which forbids murder is an example of the first case, and the observance of the Lord’s Supper an example of the second. We submit these facts as self-evident, and no Christian can deny that all Christian practice falls in one class of obligation or the other. From these considerations it is clear that whatever is Christian in character was taught by Christ, either by precept or example; or it was thus taught by his apostles. Now let us apply these truths to a consideration of Sunday as the “Christian Sabbath,” and we have this proposition to offer:—
Sunday observance was not taught by Christ. We assume that all agree that if it or any other Christian obligation has been taught, we shall find the account recorded in the Scriptures. We deny that there is any command whatever, either of Christ or the apostles, for the observance of the first day, mentioned in the whole Bible. Sunday observers have been repeatedly challenged to produce a “Thus saith the Lord;” but it has never been done, and the burden of proof lies with those who affirm such a command.
But it is asserted that Christ taught first-day observance by example; so we will examine every text which is supposed to prove this. Mark 16:9: “Now when Jesus was risen early the first day of the week, he appeared first to Mary Magdalene, out of whom he had cast seven devils.” Verse 12: “After that he appeared in another form unto two of them, as they walked, and went into the country.” First part of verse 14: “Afterward he appeared unto the eleven as they sat at meat.” In all these texts Jesus is simply spoken of as “appearing” to certain ones; nothing is said about a new Sabbath; but the events are mentioned as occurring on “the first day of the week.” We ask candidly, “Is there anything here of command or example for Sunday observance?” Those who claim that, seem to see some mystical meaning in the word “appeared,” by which they immediately conclude that henceforth Sunday must be the “Christian Sabbath!”
We read the same events of verse 12, recorded at greater length in Luke 24:13–31; but still nothing about the Sabbath. The occurrences of Mark 16:14 are also described in Luke 24:36, and John 20:19; but in none of these instances is there any mention of the introduction of a new Sabbath institution. Yet Sunday advocates profess to see a wonderful significance in the fact that all these appearances happened on the first day of the week. Apparently, the only thing which could convince them that this first appearance was not intended to sanctify Sunday, would have been for the Saviour to remain in hiding for a time, until that momentous “first day of the week” had safely passed. It is fair to presume that even in that case, if they could have ascertained that the resurrection actually occurred on the first day, it would have been re-instated in all its sacredness in their eyes; for the fundamental doctrine of such reasoners is that “redemption is greater than creation,” and that, recognizing this fact, the disciples had assembled to solemnize that first day in honor of Christ’s resurrection. All these appearances are to them but so many divine sanctions of the disciples’ new departure; for we have seen that no one offers to show that Sunday observance was commanded by Christ.
To say nothing of the audacity by which a mortal presumes to judge of the comparative importance of two infinite acts of the Almighty, let us notice whether the disciples were really assembled to honor the resurrection. Lest it may be thought there was a concealed purpose in quoting only the first part of Mark 16:14, let us read it entire: “Afterward he appeared to the eleven as they sat at meat, and upbraided them with their unbelief and hardness of heart, because they believed not them which had seen him after he was risen.” What! Is it possible that Jesus did not know they had assembled to honor his resurrection? What can it mean? It is barely possible that they had come together for a different purpose. Let us see. John 20:19 says, “The disciples were assembled for fear of the Jews.” Why does Luke say (chap. 24:37), “They were terrified and affrighted”? Can it be that their Master’s bodily appearance was unexpected, if they had met to solemnize his resurrection? And why did Jesus interrupt their solemn religious worship (?) by asking (verse 41), “Have ye here any meat?” And when the horrified disciples “gave him a piece of a broiled fish, and of an honey-comb,” he took it, and “did eat before them.” Was this a part of the solemn ordinance of sanctification of the new Sabbath? or was it a simple proof to them that he had risen in the flesh? We leave the reader to decide.
When this dearth of direct testimony for the divine sanctification of Sunday is urged upon its advocates, they reply that the continued meeting of Christ with the disciples on that day is an undeniable evidence of its sacredness. We are disposed to admit that the idea of Sunday-sacredness being evidently new to the disciples, and the proceedings of Christ being so wonderfully mystical on these occasions, the example must needs be repeated a number of times before they could grasp its symbolic meaning. So John 20:26 is appealed to for proof that Christ continued to meet with them on the “first day of the week.” “And after eight days again his disciples were within, and Thomas with them: then came Jesus, the doors being shut, and stood in the midst, and said, Peace be unto you.” But it is remarkable that the text does not mention the day of the week. Yet Sunday advocates cannot see anything strange in supposing that “after eight days” means exactly the next first day. Why not? Monday is one day, Tuesday is after one day, Wednesday is after two days, Thursday is after three days, Friday is after four days, Saturday is after five days, Sunday is—oh, well! You know the writers of the Bible were not particular about reckoning! Has any one any excuse for not knowing that after eight days from one first day, could not by any possibility mean just the next Sunday?
But the ceremony which Jesus directed Thomas to perform on this occasion, was yet more mysterious, if it was intended to teach the sacredness of Sunday. It is admissible that Thomas had hitherto doubted his Lord’s resurrection, and hence could not be expected to know that the day of its occurrence was to be a new Sabbath. But after that meeting he did believe what before was incomprehensible to him. It is, however, difficult to see how he could understand the sanctity of Sunday from what he had seen. We have never known a Sunday champion to explain the significance of that strange proceeding; and strange to say, we never read that Thomas thenceforth no longer doubted, but kept the “Christian Sabbath.”
Some are judicious enough to skip from this point to the day of pentecost for the next evidence of Sunday obligation. But if, after the resurrection, Christ always met his disciples on the first day, let us see where and under what circumstances the third meeting occurred. John records it in his gospel (chap. 21:1–13), and we find that Jesus sent the disciples fishing. Verse 14 distinctly states that “this is now the third time that Jesus showed himself to his disciples, after that he was risen from the dead.” It is true that the day of the week is not mentioned; but if it was not Sunday, then its advocates are committed to the fact that no day is rendered a Sabbath merely because Christ appeared to his disciples upon it; and also to the admission that Christ did not always meet them on the first day. They will not deny also that four other first-days intervened between this one—if it was the third Sunday-appearance—before the day of pentecost. Still no one has offered to show that Christ appeared on these days. On the other hand, he certainly did appear on the day of the ascension, and Bible believers, the world over, are agreed that this was Thursday. So we see how futile is the effort to prove a continuous record of meetings on the first day exclusively.
Now let us see what evidence the day of pentecost affords. We find the account of it recorded in the second chapter of Acts, and as all know, it was solemnized by a wonderful manifestation of the Spirit of God. If we go outside of the Bible, we shall learn that commentators disagree as to whether this day fell on Saturday or Sunday. The Scripture itself does not even mention the day of the week. Why?—Because it had no significance. The disciples had not tarried in Jerusalem until the beginning or end of a certain week had arrived, but had waited to be “endued with power from on high.” Why had not the four previous first-days been solemnized by a manifestation of the Holy Spirit? Why must the disciples tarry for the blessing? Simply because it was a thing,—the pentecost,—which was to be signalized, and not a day of weekly recurrence. We ask every candid mind this question: If God intended the day of pentecost to be observed thenceforth as a Sabbath, if he regards its non-observance as a breach of Christian duty, would not the day of the week have been mentioned by Inspiration? We are not to be understood as implying that the mere mention of it would have sufficed to indicate its holiness, but that at least would have been recorded.
We have now examined all the passages which are relied upon for evidence that Christ taught the obligation of Sunday-observance. We might show how Christ both observed and taught the sanctity of another day,—the seventh,—but that is unnecessary in proving our proposition; so we will only refer to the proofs: Luke 4:16; John 15:10; Matt. 24:20, etc.
(To be Continued.)