SUNDAY LEGISLATION IN GERMANY.
[It may be a matter of interest to those who are watching the progress of Sunday legislation in our own country, to know the extent to which such legislation has been pushed in one of the most prominent nations of the Old World. Dr. Heinrich Soetbeer, a German authority, has recently published an exhaustive article on the subject of Sunday legislation in Germany since the consolidation of the empire in 1870, from which the Christian Union reprints the following statements:—] “In 1872 a petition bearing many thousands of signatures was laid before the Reichstag by the Central Committee of the Society of Friends of Sunday and the Workingman. This asked for the passage of laws for the protection of workmen against employers who compelled them to labor on Sunday. After two other similar petitions had been presented, a committee was appointed to consider the whole matter. They reported that the existing laws were both lame and unenforced, that the question was one of the greatest social significance, but that they found it difficult to bring in any recommendation in the absence of accurate statistical knowledge of the extent of the evil. They accordingly requested the Chancellor of the Empire to appoint a commission to inquire into the best methods of protecting workingmen against Sunday work, especially in the case of women and children. The Reichstag voted, April 30, 1873, to create such a commission, though its inquiries into the condition of women and children as affected by Sunday work, were limited to those employed in factories alone. The Bundesrath approved the measure January 31, 1874, and also ordered special investigations to be made in regard to the relations of apprentices to the question of Sunday work. “These reports were duly drawn up, and laid before the Reichstag February 24, 1877. They showed that Sunday work was the rule in glass-making and sugar-raising, as also, of course, in those classes of manufacture requiring processes to be in continuous operation; but that it was exceptional in other branches of industry. Apprentices, however, in many trades regularly worked on Sunday until noon. Many motions were made and laws introduced in the wake of this Commission. The Government freely admitted the need of making more stringent laws on the subject, but pleaded the difficulty of enacting general legislation without working much particular harm. ‘Shall we,’ asked Minister of State Hofmann, ‘forbid workingmen to labor even in their own homes, or break up industries that need to be carried on uninterruptedly?’ “It was not till 1878 that the Government brought in a law amending the existing act (Section 105 of the Gewerbeordnung) so as to make it read: ‘Employers cannot compel workingmen to work on Sundays or feast-days. Workingmen in manufactures which, from their nature, cannot be broken off, do not come under this provision. The local authorities shall decide what days are to count as feast-days.’ “This was far from giving satisfaction. Petitions for a more thorough-going measure kept pouring in, but were left by the Government unheeded. On December 11, 1881, Bismarck, answering an interpellation, said that all this agitation in behalf of the workingmen to secure his Sunday rest was in danger of killing the goose that laid his golden eggs. Sunday work, he said, brings in, in the trades where it is now common, alike to the employer and laborer, one seventh of their income. He did not know how a decree could be passed cutting off that proportion, or how it could be endured, if passed. “The question came up afresh, and was debated with renewed vigor, in the last months of 1884 and the first of 1885. The Conservatives and Socialists united in demanding a law absolutely forbidding Sunday work. There was a great debate on May 9, 1885, in the course of which Bismarck spoke five times. He went back to the position of 1872, and maintained that it was impossible to go on until a more thorough investigation had been had, to get at the facts of the situation exactly, to learn the views of employers and workingmen, and to find out what the consequences of the proposed law would be. Against this, Windthorst urged that it was rank materialism to stop to ask what would be the consequences; the divine command to sanctify the Sabbath was the only thing they needed to keep in mind. But the Chancellor had his way, of course, and appointed a new commission, July 5, 1885. “Their inquiries were conducted along the line of an elaborate series of questions formulated by Bismarck. They were to ascertain the extent of Sunday labor, the reason given for it and their value, what would be the result of forbidding it, as regards both employers and workmen; and were to collect the opinions of all classes as to whether a law forbidding labor on Sunday would be feasible. The Commission did their work thoroughly, and their report was printed last year in three folio volumes, containing more than a thousand pages. They took the testimony of 39,269 employers, and of 30,651 workingmen. The results, in general, confirm what has been established in so many cases as to the harmful effects of all unnecessary Sunday work. Perhaps the only result of the inquiry that would strike an American reader as novel is the fact that Catholics in Germany are more particular about the observance of Sunday than Protestants. Out of a total of 22,617 employers who were asked if a law forbidding Sunday labor would be feasible in their judgment, one fourth said yes unqualifiedly, two fifths said yes with certain qualifications, and one third said no. Out of 15,284 workingmen to whom the same question was put, the corresponding proportions were one third, two fifths, and one fourth. “The report was laid before the Reichstag, June 13, 1887. December 14, it was brought up, and was amply discussed in several sessions. Finally, by a large majority, an elaborate measure was passed, March 7, 1888, the first three sections of which are appended in translation:— ‘Employers cannot compel their workingmen to labor on Sundays or feast-days. The local authorities shall determine what days are to be reckoned as feast days for the purposes of this act.’ ‘In mines, salt-works, foundries, factories, work-shops, dockyards, and building of all sorts, workingmen cannot be compelled to work on Sundays or feast-days. In commercial business [Handelsgewerbe], apprentices, helpers, and workingmen shall not work on Sundays or feast-days more than five hours. The hours during which work may go on shall be determined by the local police authorities. The hours may differ for the different parts of the same business. The local authorities, with the consent of the Government, may permit an increase of the hours of Sunday work for a period not to exceed four weeks.’ ‘The provisions of the foregoing section have no application to (a) workmen engaged in cleaning or repairing, upon which the regular operations of their own or another pursuit depend, provided that employment can be so regulated that each workingman shall have every second Sunday or feast-day free, at least from 6 A. M. to 6 P. M.; (b) work required to be done in cases of emergency; (c) to workingmen employed in hotels, beer saloons, or engaged in the business of transportation.’ As yet, it is a matter of uncertainty whether or not the Bundesrath will approve the measure sent it by the Reichstag, and so give it the force of law.