DISCUSSION AT BRUSHY KNOB, TEXAS

8%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Feb 21, 1882

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 59, No. 8.

Read the full edition

DISCUSSION AT BRUSHY KNOB, TEXAS.

For some months the friends of the cause in Texas have been looking forward to this discussion with considerable interest. It commenced Jan. 23, and continued five days, being conducted throughout in a very commendable manner.
The question discussed was concerning the abolition of the ten commandments, Eld. Stirman, of the Christian denomination, affirming that they were abolished at the death of Christ, and Eld. Kilgore, S. D. Adventist, denying. Four speeches of thirty minutes each were made by each speaker daily. The attendance was quite large from the first. It was my privilege to be present the last four days.
The affirmative labored nearly all of the first three days to prove that there was but one law, and that the ten commandments were a part of that law. But this position was fully met by plain texts of Scripture that speak of the ten commandments as a law written with God’s own finger on tables of stone, in distinction from the law given to Moses to be written in a book (Ex. 24:12; Deut. 31:24), as well as by many other texts exhibiting the contrast between God’s moral law of ten commandments—which is immutable—and that ceremonial law regulating those types and shadows which pointed forward to Christ, and which, of necessity, must be done away at his death.
The second position taken was that the ten commandments constituted the first covenant. Its fallacy was clearly seen when the distinction between a law and a covenant was made, and it was shown that the ten commandments were not a covenant in the primary sense of the term, but the conditions of the covenant, or that about which the covenant was made. This point was still more clearly seen from the fact that the second covenant was also made with the same people and concerning the same law. Jer. 31:31–34.
The third and most strongly urged position was that usually taken by the no-law people upon 2 Cor. 3:7; viz., that Paul here teaches that that which was written and engraven in stone was what was done away.
The inconsistency of this view was shown in various ways; e. g., if the ten commandments are done away, we are left without even a basis for the second covenant; for, as already stated, both covenants are made concerning God’s law, and unless the ten commandments are that law, there certainly is no such law in existence. Again, if Paul designs to teach in this text that God’s law is done away, he plainly contradicts himself; for in another place he says, “Do we then make void the law through faith? God forbid; yea, we establish the law.” Rom. 3:31. He contradicts Christ also, who says, “Think not that I am come to destroy the law, or the prophets; I am not come to destroy but to fulfill;” and then, as if to leave no chance for those who would abolish God’s law, he continues, “For verily I say unto you, Till heaven and earth pass, one jot or one tittle shall in no wise pass from the law, till all be fulfilled.” Matt. 5:17, 18.
But harmony and consistency are maintained when we understand Paul to teach, not that the law is done away, but that the ministration of that law, which required the immediate death of the transgressor, was what was done away. And while he speaks of that ministration as glorious, the ministration of the spirit of the same law, which now has taken its place, he speaks of as much more glorious. That is, whereas the former ministration requires obedience to the letter of the law, and a violation of the letter made it necessary for the ministers of the law to mete out the penalty of death, the present ministration of the spirit requires that the same law be applied to the heart and life in all its spiritual force, as illustrated in Christ’s sermon on the mount where he applies some of these commandments spiritually. Matt. 5:21, 22, 27, 28. The infliction of the penalty for a violation of the law is now meted out by God himself. Heb. 10:30. This ministration of the Spirit is the same thing as the carrying out the second covenant, i. e., writing the law of God upon the heart.
With this view all is harmony. With the other, we have Paul against Paul, Paul against Christ, and all is confusion.
That there was a law abolished, of course was admitted by the negative; but it was plainly shown not to be God’s law of ten commandments, but that to which reference has already been made, “which stood only in meats and drinks, and divers washings, and carnal ordinances, imposed on them until the time of reformation.” Eph. 2:15; Heb. 9:10.
Some who were undecided before the discussion, became satisfied in regard to the immutability of the law of God. The friends of the cause were encouraged and strengthened, and felt more than ever thankful for the truth.
Cleburne, Texas, Feb. 9. E. W. WHITNEY.