A DISCUSSION

13%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Feb 28, 1882

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 59, No. 9.

Read the full edition

A DISCUSSION.

BY CHAS. STRATTON.
There has been quite an excitement in this place on the Sabbath question. Eld. Corttis, the Free Baptist minister, gave out an appointment that he would tell the people why they kept Sunday for the Sabbath. His arguments were as usual,—Christ and Paul meeting with the disciples on first day, Pentecost, and Lord’s day. He also tried to make a strong point by affirming that if the seventh-day Sabbath was brought into this dispensation, the penalties and appendages must come with it. It was a poor attempt, and it was evident that neither himself nor his people were quite satisfied; therefore he gave out another appointment, stating that he would show what belonged to the old dispensation, and what to the new. He did not attempt to bring much proof from the Bible on the subject, but said the Saviour knew that the disciples would keep the first day of the week in memory of his resurrection, for how could they forget it? He had also found an antiquated newspaper which gave what purported to be the history of the Fathers. This he read with great satisfaction, so interspersing it with his own comments as to have it all pass off for the testimonies of the Fathers.
I saw that the people were terribly deceived, and felt very anxious that the truth should be plainly brought out before them. Knowing of no other way by which both sides could be induced to hear, I proposed a discussion. Eld. Corttis responded that he was at my service, but would not accept any question that I suggested. Finally he produced one to suit himself, to which I made no objection. It is as follows:—
“Resolved that the day God gave to Moses as a Sabbath, and as he gave it, is the true and only Sabbath day Christians are commanded to keep.”
I then sent for Eld. R. S. Webber to take the affirmative, which he consented to do. They met, and though Eld. C. arranged the question and chose the chairman, he evidently had a hard time. Never a man tried harder to get out of a discussion before the time expired than he, but a written agreement and a large majority held him. The truth gained a decided victory, and in such a manner that even the opposers could find no fault. The first evening Eld. W. offered a hundred dollars for one text where Christians were commanded to keep any day but the seventh, and the third and last evening he increased his offer to five hundred.
But alas for the negative! The text had been entirely left outside of the Bible. Eld. C. made a great effort to attach the stoning penalty to the transgression of the fourth commandment, but could give no reason why the same penalty should not be attached to the remaining nine, and therefore failed to establish the point. After expatiating largely on the blessings God had bestowed upon this nation for keeping the first day of the week, he admitted that he did not pretend that he was keeping the true first day, but a day in honor of Christ’s resurrection, no matter what day. This man is considered the champion in his denomination. Eld. W. followed him so closely on every point that the last evening he did not dare to make one, but closed before the time was up, with an exhortation having no connection whatever with the question. No vote was taken; but if there had been, no doubt the affirmative would have had a large majority.
Burnham, Me., Feb. 6.