THE SABBATH AND ITS OPPOSERS

7%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Jan 10, 1882

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 59, No. 2.

Read the full edition

THE SABBATH AND ITS OPPOSERS.

BY ELD. J. O. CORLISS.
Nearly every writer upon the Sabbath question who argues in favor of first-day observance, has a theory of his own, regardless of established church tenets. Some of these positions, too, are decidedly novel, and somewhat ingenious, though generally very loosely constructed. It has long since been seen and acknowledged by many who oppose the observance of the seventh day that the New Testament affords no direct proof of a change of the Sabbath, and in order to give the appearance of divine sanction to an old custom, every imaginable device is employed to produce a plausible theory, and thus set at rest those whose attention may have been called to an investigation of the subject.
Some, in their eagerness to be heard in the matter, first vociferously denounce the rank and file of seventh-day exponents as exceedingly ignorant, and fanatical in the extreme. But in the display of their own enlarged talents they sometimes, upon this subject at least, betray damaging weakness.
I recently saw an article on the subject of the Sabbath in the Christian Advocate, wherein some of these defects were plainly visible. After asking the question, Does God now require that violators of the Jewish Sabbath be put to death? the writer says, “No sane person contends for this; yet the divine law and its penalty must be co-existent. If the penalty is obsolete, so is its law.”
No one who reads such a statement can fail to understand its import; for certainly it is plain to be seen that the argument is just this and nothing more, that because God does not require men who now violate the Sabbath to be immediately taken out and killed, the law enforcing its observance has been abolished. But does such a conclusion necessarily follow? We think the writer of the article referred to will not admit such reasoning generally. Does he not teach it to be just as wrong now as in the days of Moses to lie, steal, swear, or to dishonor parents? Yet these are only violations of the same law that enforced the observance of the seventh day, and the offender’s life paid the penalty for these offenses as surely as for violating the Sabbath commandment. See Lev. 24:16; Deut. 21:18; Josh. 7:11, 21, 25.
Now, because the Lord does not in this dispensation inflict the same penalty, shall we say that the law prohibiting such things has been abolished? To use the language of the Advocate, “No sane person contends for this.” Why not be consistent, then, and admit the same process of reasoning in favor of the binding observance of the seventh day, that we use to enforce other precepts of the same law?
But we are constrained to believe that even the Advocate will admit the above process of reasoning when trying to enforce the observance of Sunday in the church of which it is the organ. Has it not frequently appealed to its readers to have a high regard for what it is pleased to term the Lord’s day? And in all these appeals has it not set forth that the Sunday-breaker is as certainly doomed as the thief and liar? From whence, then, arise all these inconsistencies?
How easy to see that the same arguments that make men responsible now for taking God’s name in vain, and for worshiping false gods, make them responsible also for the violation of the fourth commandment. And the very same reasoning exactly that others employ to induce men to keep nine of the commandments, as originally given, Seventh-day Adventists use to induce the world to see the necessity of keeping the entire ten as they were first written by the finger of God.
“But,” says the Advocate, “the Saturday Sabbath was classed with the abolished feasts under the name of ‘holy convocations,’ ‘feasts of the Lord’ (Lev. 23:1, 4, 37). This classification requires that the Saturday Sabbath be a dispensation Sabbath; otherwise, the Sabbath institution itself is fatally involved.” If this be true, then of course with the dispensation ended that Sabbath, and the law enforcing it became “obsolete.” “Yes,” says the Sunday advocate, “and we now have the glorious Christian Sabbath with all its privileges, which far surpasses that old rigid Jewish Sabbath that the law enforced.”
But hold, my friend, where do you find the authority in the New Testament for another Sabbath? With all the authority of Sinai’s thunder, the seventh day was enforced, and you often state, in order to give weight to your arguments, that the New Testament never alludes to the Sabbath only incidentally. Then where is it proclaimed, and by what law is it enforced, that the Christian world shall now observe the first day of the week?
Admitting the statement to be true that the seventh-day Sabbath expired by limitation, shall we not, till another is plainly pointed out in the Bible, conclude that there is no Sabbath in this dispensation? This would be the only legitimate conclusion of such reasoning. But we believe there is something better than this. The Advocate has been altogether too hasty in classing the Sabbath of the Lord, enforced by the fourth commandment, with the typical Sabbaths of Lev. 23. It is true that certain annual feasts, held on certain days of the month regardless of the day of week, were called sabbaths, because no servile work was to be done on those days. But the Lord, in instructing Moses with reference to them, was very careful to make a distinction between them and his own weekly rest-day. Thus, after enumerating these days and the order to be maintained in their observance, he distinctly says that these shall be regarded “besides the Sabbaths of the Lord.” Verse 28.
The Saturday Sabbath, then, was not classed with the abolished feasts, but, in the very chapter cited by the Advocate, was distinctly separated from them by the command of God, which fact the author of the statement under review might easily have seen had he read the chapter carefully.
Thus, instead of being left to wander through uncertainties to find a position on the Sabbath question, the word of God gives clear and unmistakable bearings by which we may be guided in all our decisions relative to the duties imposed by him on his people.