DEATH.—NO. 2.
REPLY TO U. SMITH
BY REV. N. WARDNER, D. D.
Eld. Smith seems quite boastful over the unity of sentiment among Seventh-day Adventists compared with Seventh-day Baptists. Yet I think it would be difficult to find five Seventh-day Baptist ministers whose teachings clash as much upon most of the points under consideration as do his or Dr. K.’s. If he believes what he says, why am I repeatedly charged with holding this, that, and the other sentiment, simply because some other Seventh-day Baptist has expressed them? This looks as though it is thought that what one believes all believe; whereas I have not ventured to attribute to him or to Dr. K. scarce anything that other Seventh-day Adventists have taught, fearing I should do them injustice. Dr. K. seems very sensitive about being charged with anything that any other Adventist has taught. What is the ground, then, of this boasting?
Eld. S. says: “It cannot be possible that Eld. W. believes we hold the idea that the death which ends this mortal life comes upon us as the penalty of our personal transgressions. Then what does he mean by suffering the same penalty twice for the same offense?” Answer: I have been in the habit of reading Advent works or of hearing Adventists preach and talk more or less for over twenty-five years, and of constantly seeing and hearing the statements made that mind and sin proceed from the body, and therefore that physical death is the penalty for sin, and the threat and execution of it upon Adam, as our federal head, held up as proof. I have also seen and heard it stated that we are all to die once for Adam’s sin, and then be brought into existence again, and the wicked die for their own sin; but I do not remember to have seen or heard any such explanation as Eld. S. now gives. If it is in his book, he does not see fit to quote it, and I am still left to doubt, especially when I read from his pen statements in connection with which I should expect to find such explanations, if anywhere, but find instead what goes right against it, like the following, which I quoted: “The same fearful sentence has everywhere, from first to last, been pronounced against sin,—‘The soul that sinneth it shall die.’ Sentence was pronounced against Adam for his sins; it is pronounced upon us for our sins. It was told Adam he should die; it is told us that we shall die. We have seen the effect death had upon Adam, and who shall affirm that it will have a different effect upon us?” Here he says, “We have seen the effect death had upon Adam,” and claims that it will have no different effect upon us. This he holds up as the penalty for sin. But I ask, Have we seen the effect of the second death upon Adam? Have we seen him burn up in a lake of fire, after the general Judgment? If, as Eld. S. contends, physical death is the penalty for sin, we have only seen it in such deaths as daily occur around us, which bear no resemblance to the description he gives of the punishment of the wicked in the other quotation I made from his work. Yet he claims that we shall experience no different punishment than that which we have seen that Adam suffered.
Again, Eld. S. teaches that man has no conscious existence out of the body, which he represents to be the only responsible part of man. Also that “death is a state of non-existence.” It follows, then, that in death nothing remains of the former man. His personal identity is utterly lost. Hence the raising up of a new man, made of other matter, can no more be the same man than Eld. S. is Adam; and punishing this new man would no more be punishing the one who committed the sin than punishing Eld. S. would be punishing Judas. But since man possesses an intelligent moral entity, which does not perish with the body, and which is the seat of character and responsibility, it will, therefore, make no difference how many new bodies he may have; his personal identity still exists, to be punished or rewarded. Eld. S. says, “We die in Adam because we have inherited from him this mortal, dying nature.” Answer: The Bible assigns no such reason; but all die because “all have sinned.” Could Adam have still had access to the tree of life, he would never have died physically. How does Eld. S. know but that men would be translated, as were Enoch and Elijah, if they would cease to sin? If Eld. S.’s language states anything, it is that Adam died for his personal sin, and that our penalty for personal sin will be the same kind of death. In his so-called explanation, he says Adam’s penalty for transgression “was unconditional. This sentence had to be executed without rebate or variation.” Answer: If so, then Adam’s sin was unpardonable. Eld. S. claims also that the same penalty is inflicted upon all Adam’s posterity, simply because Adam transgressed. If so, then here is an unpardonable sin imputed to us, and its penalty executed “without rebate or variation” upon countless millions who had no part in its commission, and which the atonement of Christ cannot reach! But Christ says, “All sins shall be forgiven to men but the sin against the Holy Ghost.” Does Eld. S. claim that Adam’s sin, “thus entailed upon us,” is the sin against the Holy Ghost?
He goes on to say: “But the plan of salvation through Christ immediately supervened, and Adam was placed upon a new probation. So he commenced his downward march to the tomb, under the sentence of death for his first sin,” which Eld. S. claims was unpardonable. Then I ask, Why should God revoke his irrevocable sentencep. 323 by raising Adam to life again, if the sin which demanded his death was unpardonable? And again, of what avail could probation be, under an irrevocable sentence of “non-existence;” for the same unpardonable sin rests upon all men who are perfectly innocent of the crime for which it is imposed, although God has declared that the sons shall not die for the iniquities of their fathers? Again, if Adam suffered the full penalty for his sin, then that cancelled it; and after justice has been fully satisfied upon the guilty party by the execution of the penalty affixed to his transgression, why should it still continue in force, and be inflicted upon the innocent? Yet strange to say, according to Eld. S.’s theory, this transgression, which was unpardonable, could, after all, be satisfied by the death of the body, without any atonement, so that Adam could go to Heaven, the same as though he had never committed it, i. e., be remitted in consideration of physical death; while the Scriptures say that there is no remission for sin except through the atonement of Christ!
Again, he says: “The death Adam died was for his first sin of eating of the forbidden tree, and that alone. It had no connection whatever with any of the acts of his 930 years of life, viewed from a moral standpoint, after the scenes described in Gen. 3. And if, in the Judgment, when Adam comes to give account of his after-life, after he came under the provisions of salvation through Christ, it shall be found that he did not repent so as to secure the forgiveness of his sins through Christ, he must die again the second death just like any other transgressor.” Reply: If I can understand this language, it implies that Adam’s first sin and its effect had no connection with his subsequent acts, viewed from a moral standpoint. On the contrary, was it not as inseparably connected with them as a fountain is connected with, and gives rise to, the stream that flows from it? Again, he says, if after Adam “came under the provision of salvation through Christ, it should be found that he did not repent so as to secure forgiveness of his sins through Christ, he must die again the second death, just like any other transgressor.” This represents that all other sins may be forgiven through Christ; but this one cannot be, even to us who are not guilty of it, and yet Adam and all others may be delivered from its irrevocable penalty by the resurrection, without pardon! In what light does this place God?
Then, says Eld. S., “How did this affect his posterity? Standing as the federal head of the whole human race, when death passed upon him, it passed upon all men; for Paul says (Rom. 5:12), ‘Wherefore, as by one man sin entered into the world and death by sin, and so death passed upon all men.’ Why did not Eld. S. quote the rest of the passage? Ah! it would spoil his argument. Paul says the reason why death passed upon all men was because ‘all have sinned.’
The Elder says: “Adam, having brought himself into a dying state, could transmit to his posterity no higher nature than he possessed; hence all the race have been morally subject to death. But when Adam was put upon a new probation, it was also as the federal head of the human race.” Answer: If, then, by Adam’s death he cancelled his first sin, why not, as our “federal head,” cancel it for the race, as well as to entail it? Again, Eld. S. says, “Hence we all, though subject to death, as Adam was after the fall, are also on probation, as he again was after the plan of salvation intervened.” Answer: We did not sin under that first probation, as Adam did, and why should we suffer as he did, the innocent the same as the guilty, especially since he satisfied it in his death? “Shall not the Judge of all the earth do right?” Eld. S. says, “The death we now die is not the result of the sin which we commit in our own persons, but is entailed upon us as the result of Adam’s transgression in the manner above stated.” But where is the justice, if physical death was the penalty for Adam’s sin? This imposes two deaths upon Adam’s posterity, one for their own sins, for which they are guilty, and one for Adam’s sin, for which they are not guilty, and only the same upon Adam, who is guilty of both. And yet God is no respecter of persons!
Eld. S. then goes on to caricature the sentiment of those he opposes by representing spiritual death to be “a state of sin and alienation from God.” Is it so? No. It is the result of sin and alienation, just as the second death is the result of sin. Hence there is no pertinence in his next sentence: “To make this a part of the threatening is to make God say to Adam, ‘In the day that thou eatest thereof thou shalt surely be a sinner.’ This is making too sad nonsense of the word of Jehovah to be for a moment tolerated.” Yes, indeed; and who turns Jehovah’s words into such nonsense? Not those whose views Eld. S. thus represents. Paul said, “The wages of sin is death,” not, The wages of sin is sin. Eld. S. quotes the apostle’s language, “Every one of us shall give account of himself to God,” and says, “For this purpose we are all to have a future life.” Answer: According to Eld. S.’s theory, all men utterly pass out of existence at death, hence nothing pertaining to man or his present life will exist again; but a newly created man, including soul, body, and spirit, will be substituted for him. This is the best that can be made of the resurrection, according to his theory.
In this connection he quotes the passage I quoted from his work (of 1865), and throws in a parenthetical remark, which materially changes the sense of the original statement in the book, and shows that he has become dissatisfied with his own doctrine. He shapes it thus: “We have seen the effect that death had upon Adam, and who shall affirm that it (the death we are to die, if sinners, that is the second death), will have a different effect upon us?” Answer: This is but changing position and keeping the pain. Have we seen the effect the second death had upon Adam? Has he yet experienced it? Such contradictions need no comment.
Eld. S. says: “We certainly see no reason, scarcely an excuse, for Eld. W.’s giving the representation he has of our views of this matter.” We commend to his consideration Eze. 18:26, “When a righteous man,” etc. In Eld. S.’s comments on this passage, is he seeking to set me right as to his views, or is he trying to give my views? I am in doubt. He comments thus: “Here a man commits iniquity, that is, he has died a spiritual death, he is dead in trespasses and sins; but he then dies in them, that is, loses his physical life in this condition, and after this, for his iniquity that he has done, he is to die again. Can he tell us, on his theory, what this last death is, and when, where, and how experienced?” Does Eld. S. also believe in a spiritual death, i. e., that a man may be “dead in sins” while alive physically? What does he mean by a spiritual death, since he claims that all there is of man is physical, and that death is “non-existence”? How can a man die physically a spiritual death? In his comment, above quoted, Eld. S. has made out three deaths. He claims death to be “non-existence.” Then man has three non-existences. And from the fancied wisdom of this position, he absurdly calls upon me to tell, on my theory, what the “last death is, and when, where, and how experienced.” It is impossible that the same person who once loses all existence should die again. If Eld. S. wishes to know my views of the second death, he can read the closing paragraph of the discourse he is commenting on.
Now, in turn, I will ask him, If by committing iniquity a “man dies a spiritual death” while still alive physically, is he not in the same state which God told Adam he should be in if he ate the forbidden fruit, and was in after he ate it? To deliver men from this death and its cause, was Christ’s mission to earth. This was the death that Adam died the moment he sinned, 930 years before he died a physical death, and from which he could only be delivered by the atonement of Christ; while Eld. S. claims that physical death was a punishment “without rebate,” i. e., unpardonable. The threatened death which Adam died manifested itself when God called him to account, by the exhibition of guilt, fear, equivocation, meanness, and a disposition to justify his sin by charging the blame upon another, and even upon God. He was thus dead to the chief end for which he was created,—communion, fellowship, and service of God. Redemption and resurrection through Christ restores men back to that life, and to the possession of the characteristics thus lost; viz., a sense of justification with God instead of guilt, faith in God instead of fear, truthfulness instead of equivocation, manliness instead of meanness, honest confession of personal guilt instead of charging it upon others or upon God. Paul defines this life and death thus: “To be carnally minded is death, but to be spiritually minded is life.” “I am crucified with Christ; nevertheless I live; yet not I, but Christ liveth in me; and the life which I now live in the flesh I live by the faith of the Son of God, who loved me, and gave himself for me.” “You hath he quickened, who were dead in trespasses and sins.” “Even when we were dead in trespasses and sins, hath he quickened us together with Christ.” Christ said, “He that believeth on the Son hath everlasting life; and he that believeth not the Son shall not see life, but the wrath of God abideth on him.”
In the next paragraph, Eld. S. endeavors to explain the passage I quoted from his book on degrees of punishment by quoting from the next page. While I am pleased to see a desire to discard the sense of his statement, yet I do not see as his quotation adds any light. He distinctly declares, as his belief, that death is the penalty for sin, and “death is a state of non-existence,” “a state which can be reached only on a complete extinction of life. As long as there is life about a man, he is not dead.” No statement could be more positive, that the penalty for sin is “non-existence,” which is not reached “as long as there is any life about a man.” Now to say that God, as a punishment for degrees of guilt, “will graduate the pain attendant upon the sinner’s being reduced to” that state of death, seems like an imposition upon common sense. No pain is possible in a state of “non-existence,” which state Eld. S. declares to be the penalty for sin, and “which is not reached as long as there is life about a man.” Without any kind of life, no pain is possible. If Eld. S. cannot accept the inevitable conclusion which his own definition necessitates, he should change his theory, and not undertake to reconcile what is utterly irreconcilable.
Of his statement, he says, “If this language does not make pain a part of the punishment, we know not what language could do it.” Answer: It certainly does; but it contradicts his definition of the penalty itself. He says, “Death is here spoken of as the climax of the penalty, and the degrees of punishment are found in the intensity and duration of the pain.” Thus with one breath he declares that death, “a state of non-existence,” is the penalty God affixed to sin, and with the next breath, that it is only the “climax” of the penalty, and that the rest of the penalty is a state of conscious suffering through an indefinite portion of eternity. Thus he makes the penalty for degrees of sin to consist in the degrees of suffering and its duration, and death, non-existence, to be a release from it, instead of being the penalty itself. This mental or spiritual suffering, he says, so far surpasses the suffering of the body, while being consumed in the lake of fire and brimstone, that the bodily suffering will be but “an unnoticeable trifle” in comparison. He refers to his work, Mortal or Immortal, page 100, where he quoted Rom. 2:6–9, and says, “We believe as firmly as any one can, that indignation and wrath, tribulation and anguish, will be recompensed upon every soul of man that doeth evil.” “We have never believed or taught differently.” Answer: Then why not make his definition of the penalty for sin, and his formulated creed, harmonize with that statement, instead of contradicting it? Did Christ say, “These shall go away into everlasting punishment, till the climax, non-existence, is reached”? According to Eld. S., some will be punished a long time before their penalty, non-existence, is reached. He says, “When set forth in one word, the destiny of the wicked is expressed by a single term, death. But who will not admit that death includes the dying?” Eld. S. does not, when he defines the penalty of sin to be “a state of non-existence,” which cannot be “reached as long as there is any life about a man.” If God fixed such a penalty for sin, no one has a right to say that it includes an indefinite period of torture to prevent it. Nor has Eld. S. a right to complain because he is held to his own definitions, or charged with self-contradiction when he explains away his definitions, in trying to extricate himself from difficulty. He proceeds to explain: “When the death sentence is pronounced upon the criminal, is it that he is sentenced to be dead? and then is the sentence suffered to become a nullity, and pass without execution, because it would not be right to torture the man before the penalty comes? No; but he is hanged by the neck till he is dead. So the wicked shall be cast into gehenna, where the agents of destruction shall never cease to prey upon them till, as intelligent, conscious beings, they have ceased to be.” Answer: The Bible says nothing about tormenting the wicked in gehenna, till the penalty (death) is reached; but that being cast into the lake of fire “is the second death.” In our law, the mode of executing the death penalty is included in the sentence, and is intended to give the least possible torture. God could put man out of existence without any suffering, so that there would be no need of subjecting him to the least torture in reducing him to that state; and to claim that non-existence is the penalty God affixed to sin, and then represent him as subjecting the sinner to such indefinite degrees and periods of torture, in addition to the sentence pronounced, is to represent him in any other light than as a consistent, merciful being. Non-existence is either the penalty God affixed to sin, of every degree and duration, or it is not. If it is, it does not include a process of torture that shall precede it, since God could put them out of existence as easily without as with it. But if it is not the penalty, why represent it to be? According to Eld. S.’s definition of the sin-penalty, all this suffering in gehenna is extra, and implies the conscious, intelligent existence of the victim, and not “a state of non-existence.” But he sees the necessity of penalties to suit degrees of guilt, and so has to discard his own interpretation of what he claims to be the penalty—“death,” “non-existence”—and make it include an indefinite period of torture before it can be reached! Again, Eld. S. here admits that conscious pain is a necessary part of the penalty for sin. Death, however, according to his definition, is not pain, but deliverance from it. Where there is no life, there is no pain, and where there is no pain, there is no punishment.
What Christ said about Lazarus and Dives may be called a parable, or an illustration. It was intended to teach the truth under consideration more clearly than it could be taught otherwise. The most important facts concerning his kingdom, its progress, and the Judgment, etc., he taught by parables. Though in all illustrations there are words thrown in to fill out the picture which cannot be made to have a literal application, yet the parable itself must show what is intended to be elucidated by it, or it is useless, if not deceptive. The doctrine intended to be taught in this parable is clearly set forth, and is made certain by reference to the five brethren, who were still living on earth in a state of probation, while Lazarus and Dives were conscious, in the unseen world.
Christ’s remark to the women, that he had not yet ascended to his Father, evidently meant since his resurrection. His disciples saw him ascend forty days after. Eld. S., to evade the force of Christ’s statement to the thief, that he should be with him in Paradise, that day, says, “It is by no means probable that the thief died that day.” On the contrary, the Scriptures make it not only probable, but very certain, that he died that day. In Deut. 21:22, 23, it is commanded, “If a man have committed a sin worthy of death, and he be to be put to death, and thou hang him on a tree, his body shall not remain all night upon the tree, but thou shalt in any wise bury him that day.” Josephus says that in his day it was the custom to take down and bury the crucified before sunset. War. 4, 5, 2. This explains why they broke the thief’s legs, to hasten his death, so they could bury him before sunset. They did not break Jesus’ legs, because they found him already dead.
Again Eld. S. quotes: “Eld. Wardner says that the spirit, at death, goes to God who gave it.” Answer: I thought Solomon said that. He asks also, “What do the spirits of the wicked go to God for?” For an answer, I refer him to him who made the statement.
I quoted from Eld. Waggoner, who teaches that Christ, who “was God, the pre-existing divinity,” was transmuted into flesh and died; and also Eld. S., who says, “Death is a state of non-existence;” and then I put the following questions: 1. What was his pre-existing divinity, if it could thus be put out of existence by men? 2. Was the universe left without any Divine Being for three days and nights, or is there a plurality of such beings? 3. Who raised Christ to life again? 4. If his divinity was made into flesh and annihilated at death, when did he possess immortality, before his advent or at his resurrection? 5. Was his immortality an element of his divinity, which became flesh, or did he obtain it from some other source?p. 324 The responses from Dr. K. and Eld. S. are, evidently, efforts to avoid meeting these questions squarely and fully, and to turn attention away from them.
Eld. S. assumes that I am in perplexity about Christ’s divinity, growing out of my “trinitarian sentiments,” without knowing that I hold such sentiments. Anything to turn the subject and escape from his dilemma. I am happy to inform him I am in no such “perplexity.”
He and the Doctor indorse Eld. Waggoner’s position. Therefore, they claim that the Word, God, “by whom all things were created that are in heaven and that are in earth, visible and invisible, who is before all things and by whom all things consist, who had power to lay down his life and power to take it again,” that this Divinity, this Godhead, was transmuted into flesh, and was killed by weak men, and put into “a state of non-existence,” and for three days and nights there was nothing of him but dead flesh and bones! According to this interpretation, the pre-existing divinity became mere flesh during Christ’s earthly life, and was constantly corrupting, dying, and passing away and being replaced by new flesh, derived from the productions of the earth; and thus this divinity passed away in corruption, and was renewed several times during his sojourn upon earth. If, to escape from this absurd conclusion, they say that his divinity consisted in his soul, they make it out to be an imagined, lifeless, unintelligent form, or organization, a mere abstraction, the memory of whose existence was only preserved for three days and nights, by means of a record or photograph. Or, if they say it was his spirit, they claim that that is only a breath of air, oxygen and nitrogen, which belongs to the earth, and passed away every second during his life, and was followed as often by a new inhalement. Such they claim him to be, who was God, the almighty Creator of heaven and earth, the Giver and Fountain of immortality and eternal life!
Eld. S. claims that any other theory makes the atonement to consist in a mere human sacrifice. But his theory not only makes the sacrifice wholly human, but makes divinity itself to consist of mere corrupting human flesh! For if divinity was thus transmuted into human flesh (and the man Christ Jesus was made in all respects like unto his brethren), then it ceased to be divine and became human, like the rest of us, of the earth, earthy. All his thoughts, according to this theory, were originated by his “brain;” and his brain was produced by the productions of the earth, through the digestion of a fleshy stomach. There was nothing spiritual about his brain; for “flesh and bones” do not pertain to spirit, and nothing but spirit can produce spirit, according to Christ’s testimony to Nicodemus.
I therefore insist upon answers to each of my questions. 1. What was the pre-existing divinity that could be thus put out of existence by men? 2. Was the universe without a Divine Being for three days and nights, or is there a plurality of such beings? 3. When did he possess immortality, before his advent, or at his resurrection? 4. Was that immortality an element of divinity, which became flesh and was killed, or did he obtain it from some other source? These I claim to be fair and legitimate questions, naturally growing out of the discussion of this question, and include the chief difference between us and our Advent brethren, and therefore should by no means be passed over lightly.