If the reader will take out from the foregoing article of Eld. W.'s what he quotes from our work, and read it consecutively, he will have a very fair idea of what we have tried to teach on this subject. But as Eld. W. has succeeded in conjuring up so much mist and moonshine, perhaps the simpler way will be for us to restate briefly our position. This we will try to do in a manner as plain and simple as a primer, so as to leave no one ground of misapprehension, nor excuse for misrepresenting us.
Adam and Eve were placed upon probation. They had the privilege of being obedient and living forever, or of transgressing and suffering death. This was a primary and independent arrangement. No provision was made for the pardoning of the offense, or the removal of the penalty. Adam sinned, and thus became subject to the penalty. The immediate consequence was that he became, in his physical nature, subject to death. In pronouncing sentence upon Adam for his transgression, God explained the meaning of the threatened penalty when he said, “In the sweat of thy face shalt thou eat bread till thou return unto the ground; for out of it wast thou taken; for dust thou art, and unto dust shalt thou return.”
After 930 years of toil and suffering, Adam died. He who was taken from the dust, the intelligent, responsible Adam, went back to dust again, as God had said that he should, for his sin of eating of the forbidden tree.
The first act in the drama is now completed. We have seen Adam endowed with life; the conditions placed before him of the continuance of that life; his violation of the conditions, and the consequent loss of life in the exact terms of the threatened penalty. Had nothing else been done, this would have been the final condition, both of Adam and of his posterity, for he could transmit to his children no higher physical nature than he himself possessed; and after they had fallen in death, they would forever have remained as though they had not been.
But Christ interposes in man's behalf to save him from this condition. He offers his own life a ransom for man. God accepts the offering, and by virtue thereof places man upon a new probation. But did Christ undertake to release men from the penalty of death pronounced upon Adam? By no means; for that transaction was closed up and finished, and God could not, without dishonor to himself, go back and change the unconditionally-established arrangement; and so death passed upon all men. And our only reason for not quoting the remainder of the sentence,—“For that all have sinned,” was to save space. And this spoils no argument of ours; for it is simply parallel to another expression of Paul's, that “in Adam all die.” Death passed upon all men, according to Paul, when Adam sinned. It was then that all had, in the sense of that passage, sinned; and if Eld. W. takes exception to the statement, he must settle it with the apostle.
If we may venture to state the opinion of one who so studiously keeps his own views in the dark, we should judge that our reviewer would have the text read, Death passed upon all men, for all will sin; but will he tell us, then, why infants are subject to death?
For a race thus subject to death, the provision of salvation is to be made. And how was it accomplished? God says to us, viewed in the relation of our own personal accountability to him, “The soul that sinneth, it shall die;” “The wages of sin is death.” But we are now taken at a disadvantage, for we inherit a nature prone to sin. But Christ interposes for our help right here, by making provision through his blood to cancel the sins we do commit if we seek pardon through him, and by his Spirit to take away the carnal mind which is prone to sin, and give us a spiritual mind which leads to obedience, so that by means of the blood and the Spirit of our Saviour, we stand at last before the law as if we had never transgressed.
But what will this avail, since in Adam all die? Answer: Christ in his work in our behalf has made provision for this very contingency; “for as in Adam all die, even so in Christ shall all be made alive.” Thus the life which we have lost unconditionally in Adam, is restored to us unconditionally in Christ. Then we are past the physical effects of Adam's fall. Then all stand before the judgment-seat of Christ to give an account of their own personal deeds. The condition of everlasting life is obedience. The result of disobedience is death, for still “the wages of sin is death.” If, then, we are found sinners, the sentence of death passes upon us. If we have secured pardon through Christ, and stand before the law as uncondemned, we live on everlastingly.
After the plan of salvation intervened, Adam stood in the same relation to God that we now stand. He must give an account for sins as we are to give an account, and to meet the result as we are to meet it. If a sinner, then death; if obedient through Christ, then everlasting life.
This seems to us all very plain and simple, but perhaps our reviewer will be unable to comprehend it. It will perhaps be sufficient to ask the reader to compare the foregoing reply by Eld. W. with the view here briefly set forth, which is the same view we have ever held. If he will do this, we think he will be able clearly to discern that all Eld. W.'s arguments per contra are simply a misapprehension of the position occupied, or a perversion of the arguments offered in its defense. And if the reader is amused or edified by what our reviewer has set forth in his remarks respecting Adam's second death, and the sin against the Holy Ghost (!), so be it. He is welcome to the consolation. For our own part, we feel no disposition to indulge in quibbles. We have just as little disposition to spend time over those presented by others; and if we might be allowed to make a suggestion right here, it would be that considerable time might possibly be saved if Eld. W. would request each of his readers to seek some retired spot and repeat by himself, “Death is non-existence.—U. S.,” five or six hundred times, to the end that he might be spared the necessity of quoting it so often. We venture to express the opinion that his readers would in this way make just as relevant an application of it as he has done.
The second death is to be inflicted in Gehenna, the lake of fire. The death includes the dying. In this death there will be visited upon the transgressor “tribulation and anguish, indignation and wrath;” and there shall be “weeping and gnashing of teeth.”
Finally, Eld. W. proposes four questions to which he insists that answers shall be given. We had supposed these articles were written for the purpose of comparing views in order to elicit truth; but we are at a loss to understand how this can be done by one party studiously concealing his own views, and spending his time in catechising the other. And we, therefore, before answering his questions, claim the privilege of propounding a few to him. 1. We understand him to say that we suffer death in this life because we are personally sinners. Will he, then, answer this question: Why do infants, who have never personally sinned, die? 2. For what purpose are the wicked dead raised? 3. When and how did the divine nature of Christ, as he holds it, unite itself with the human nature? Was it before, at, or after the birth of Christ as a babe in Bethlehem? 4. If only the human nature suffered, have we anything more than a human sacrifice?
To his questions, we are content to let the Scriptures reply. In answer to the first, we refer to John 1:14; Heb. 2:9. To the second, to Heb. 13:20. To the third, Heb. 2:14-18. To the fourth, Phil. 2:5-8. A great deal of needless perplexity, it seems to us, is created respecting the idea of the divinity of Christ during his incarnation. Is the son of an emperor any less a royal personage if, for a time, he humbles himself to perform the office of a servant?