THE COMING QUESTION

11%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Nov 18, 1880

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 56, No. 21.

Read the full edition

THE COMING QUESTION.

The New York Atlas of Oct. 16, 1880, contains an article headed, “Sunday or Sabbath,” in which we find some statements quite significant as showing the tendency of the public mind on the Sunday question, and the basis of the agitation which is to bring it to public notice. After speaking of the fact that many corporations and institutions so manage their business that they leave their employes no day of rest at all, it says:—
“The truth is that the time has come for a thorough examination of this Sunday question, not simply from the standpoint of the church-members, but from that of the hard-working and laboring classes, and the statutes of the commonwealth.”
The rights of the laboring classes are to be urged as one reason why Sunday laws should be enforced. We quote again:—
“Have workingmen any rights that employers are bound to respect? Thousands of respectable men besides those who belong to the churches, are obliged to violate their moral principles as well as religious duties in order to retain their places. We ask consideration for them, and from them, for we intend to ventilate this Sunday question through and through, in all its aspects. We shall not shrink from a radical investigation of the causes assigned for maintaining two days of rest, when, according to those who believe in the divine origin of the day, but one Sabbath, or rest, was appointed. There can be no doubt that the observance of one day in seven is in accordance with the necessities of man’s nature as a complex being, and that rest for the mind as well as the body is essential to his welfare.”
The Atlas, in the foregoing, shows itself to be very much in earnest, but still more so in the following challenge to the clergy:—
“We have been very much surprised that the clergy, who have been so frequently challenged to the contest by the Sunday daily papers, have not universally taken up the question and endeavored to settle it satisfactorily. The Sun has been especially emphatic in defying the clergy to show that there is any demand in Scripture to hallow the first day of the week, and, although it does admit that there is a divine command to rest on the seventh day, it manages to keep its employes at work all days. We again respectfully offer to the clergy the use of the Atlas for short, logical arguments on this important subject, not from a sectarian standpoint, but from that of the beneficial effects and results of the day of rest to individuals and to society; also any brief and compressed articles concerning the origin, use, and authority for the change from the seventh to the first day. If there be no clear, direct commands to that effect, it may be a question for consideration whether the Jewish Sabbath from 6 P. M. to 6 P. M. would not be far better adapted to the requirements of modern society than the artificial time now kept from midnight to midnight. Let us have light on this important subject, for the sake of those who require rest from toil and drudgery.”
The law of the Sabbath is indeed written, not only in the decalogue, but in man’s physical nature. One day of rest in seven is essential, as above stated, to man’s highest welfare, and there is a radical mistake somewhere in the maintenance of two days of rest when God appointed but one. The claim of the Sun will be found to be correct, that there is neither command, example, nor logical inference to be found in the Scriptures for hallowing the first day of the week. Here is the weakness of the Sunday movement from a religious point of view, and the reason why of late so many seem inclined to change it to a national institution, upheld and enforced by the secular arm alone.
The command for the observance of the seventh day is still in force. For the change from the seventh to the first, there is no authority. Would all Christians unite upon the Sabbath of the Bible, a moral power could be developed on this question which would insure to all their rights and their privileges. But there is a prejudice against the Sabbath, falsely called Jewish, which will prove an effectual barrier to such a result; and the methods by which the Sunday people hope to achieve their purpose can end only in disaster.