Religious Dissent in Russia

11%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · May 30, 1882

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 59, No. 22.

Read the full edition

Religious Dissent in Russia.

RUSSIA will soon be summoned to meet a very troublesome question, whose solution is a pressing necessity. A violent fermentation is now agitating certain portions of the realm in regard to religious matters. The masses are becoming day by day more impatient of the ignorance and intolerance of the Russian clergy, and the latter are beginning to see that neither priestly threats nor police interference can prevent the spread of new religious views among the more intelligent of the people.
These “dissenters” complain of the established church that they find nothing in its service but the baldest formalism, and declare that its meaningless ceremonies have nothing for their hearts or their reasons. They therefore refuse to submit to its mandates or practice its rituals, and are now turning to other sources for some satisfaction for their spiritual wants. Many of these so-called “apostates” are men of intelligence, morality, and energy, and they form just the element for a successful propaganda. And this is proved by their works. Recent investigations show that these dissenters from the state church now number about twelve millions, or fifteen per cent. of the whole population. And when we remember that they have naturally in Russia no judicial status, and are not only not tolerated, but frequently persecuted and prevented from teaching their doctrines, the immense success of their efforts is very remarkable.
Now it is clear that this massive protest against the Russian Church is no transient opposition that can be crushed out by proscription or preached down by an ignorant clergy, and it is clearly bound to win a recognition against all opposition. The existence of this dissent is therefore recognized and beginning to be feared, and is designated by the contemptuous term of “sect.” These sects are of very different tendencies, according to locality and class of the population, many of the most intelligent of them leaning toward rationalism for want of something positive and intelligible in default of the old state church ritual and doctrines.
The masses are now anxiously looking toward them in their eagerness to find new ways to free themselves from the galling burdens of the orthodox church. This fermentation bids fair to disintegrate Russian society into a thousand different circles; and therein lies the great danger to the state, which the latter can only avoid by obtaining control of it. For if the masses once succeed in separating their religious belief from the formal tenets of the state religion, they have attained a great success, and one that cannot be taken from them by sermons, or pastoral warning, or appeals. And those who thus rebel against the orthodox rule of the church are soon ready to make other experiments in the domains of social economy and politics. This is now seen among some of these sects that have formed communities apart and introduced a better social order, that has brought them wealth and contentment, when compared with the condition of the ignorant and helpless herds who are under the spiritual guidance of the idle and ignorant priesthood of the ordinary Russian village.
With such examples and encouragement before them, other communities are becoming restless, and thus dissent is rapidly growing throughout Russia. The latest information from one of the interior provinces announces a veritable stampede from the state church over to Mohammedanism. In one village a hundred families are said to have been converted within the last year, and many of the baptized Tartars refuse to take the civil oath according to the Greek Church ritual. In October last the authorities of another large village center notified the local clergy that in future none of the inhabitants would appear at the Greek service; and at the same time many of the people had their hair shorn, and appeared in the street with the Mohammedan fez on their heads instead of the Russian cap. The local clergy have appealed to higher authority to sustain them in their priestly authority, but so far without success.
Thus the government has another dilemma added to its perplexities, and is now at a standstill as to the best measures to be adopted in the crisis. It would seem to be unpardonable folly to proceed against these dissenters in any way that would offend their conscience, or deprive them of their own form of worship, or forbid them to live together, as many of them do, in communities or large families, similar to the Shakers of this country. They have already on their side moral power and cleanliness in mode of life, firmness in their faith, and steadiness of character. To persecute these people would be still more to undermine the authority of the ruling church and cause it to be yet more thoroughly detested.
But the intolerant state church seems determined to push its pretended claims on the conscience and the religious convictions of the people to the uttermost, and is thus hastening a conflict which may precipitate its own downfall. Indeed, this movement may be providential in causing a more searching investigation into the character and modes of a large portion of the Greek clergy, and lead to the abolition of abuses. It will certainly cause the nation at large to study with care the morality or immorality that can thus drive millions of people from the faith of their fathers over into unknown beliefs, or the most complete agnosticism.
These “dissenters” extend from the Caucasus to the wastes of Siberia, and thence away into Central Russia, and practically enjoy only the restricted liberty that may be obtained from a bribed police. Their history extends back for more than a score of years, but their numbers have increased greatly of late under the stimulus of the political and social fermentations of the period. In some of the “governments” they are inhumanly persecuted, and never know what a day may bring forth. They dare not regard their religious books or sacred images or places of worship as their own, and are even, in certain districts, driven from their own houses into prisons. An accusation of a village priest or policeman may bring on hundreds of families dire persecution or utter ruin. It is thus one of the most difficult problems of the future for the government to settle this question of the dissenting sects, until now so strangely neglected by the authorities except to persecute. In religion, as in many other things, the Russian state has chosen to remain immovable, and in its stolid passiveness has remained behind the time. The masses are therefore obliged thus to protest against the hollowness and ignorance of the church and the clergy of the Russian state.—Christian Weekly.